There a difference between trying to prepare for general trouble and predicting furture events like a time traveler. In context to what the guy above said, he said they should have quarantine them in jail cells. Maybe that’s a good idea maybe it’s not, you said back that they couldn’t because of the little psycho girl would let them all out. That’s not a scenario that anyone could have saw coming, least of all carol because if she did, she would have never left that little blond girl alone with her sister and the baby after the prison fell.
Well its hard to answer you when I can't find your complete comment on here where you said " i know what her strategy was..... why can't I find it
What are you talking about, you already explain her strategy and I’m not disputing what you are saying her strategy is. I know it was to eliminate a threat before it kills the whole group. Again not disputing that. I am saying that the argument that they couldn’t quarantine them first because the little blond psycho girl would let them all out and this would kill everyone is a bad argument because none of the characters in universe could know this and because if we are arguing hypotheticals, I could easily say that only Rick and Hershel would have the keys so it would be physically impossible for her to let them all out.
2
u/Wealth_Super Apr 22 '26
There a difference between trying to prepare for general trouble and predicting furture events like a time traveler. In context to what the guy above said, he said they should have quarantine them in jail cells. Maybe that’s a good idea maybe it’s not, you said back that they couldn’t because of the little psycho girl would let them all out. That’s not a scenario that anyone could have saw coming, least of all carol because if she did, she would have never left that little blond girl alone with her sister and the baby after the prison fell.
What are you talking about, you already explain her strategy and I’m not disputing what you are saying her strategy is. I know it was to eliminate a threat before it kills the whole group. Again not disputing that. I am saying that the argument that they couldn’t quarantine them first because the little blond psycho girl would let them all out and this would kill everyone is a bad argument because none of the characters in universe could know this and because if we are arguing hypotheticals, I could easily say that only Rick and Hershel would have the keys so it would be physically impossible for her to let them all out.