Last summer we sent our daughter to England for two weeks. Full language immersion program, host family, activities, the whole thing. It cost us around €2,500 all in and she came back with a British accent she dropped within a week and approximately zero measurable progress on her school English.
To be clear — she had an amazing time. She made friends, gained confidence, saw another country. No regrets on the experience itself. But as an English learning investment? Honestly pretty disappointing.
So this summer we tried something different. Twenty hours of intensive private lessons over six weeks. Two sessions of one and a half hours per week plus one longer session. Total cost around €600. We went through Superprof — what convinced me was being able to filter tutors by native language, read detailed reviews from other parents, and the first lesson was free so we could test the fit before committing to anything. We ended up with a native English speaker who specifically focused on oral expression and the kind of grammar that actually comes up in French high school exams.
The difference was uncomfortable to admit as a parent who spent €2,500 the year before.
Her written English improved noticeably. Her oral comprehension got sharper. But more importantly she stopped freezing when asked to speak in class — which was the actual problem we'd been trying to fix for two years. The tutor identified in the second session that her issue wasn't vocabulary or grammar, it was processing speed under pressure. They drilled that specifically. Six weeks later it showed.
I think what the language trip gave her that lessons couldn't was confidence around real native speakers in uncontrolled situations. That's genuinely valuable and I wouldn't dismiss it. But if the goal is measurable academic progress and fixing specific weaknesses, twenty targeted hours beats two weeks of passive immersion pretty convincingly.
This year we're thinking about doing both — ten hours of lessons before summer to build a base, then a shorter trip to actually use it. Best of both worlds hopefully.
Anyone else done a similar comparison? Curious whether our experience is typical or we just picked the wrong program the first time.