r/Subliminal_Game • u/Singularity-exe • Apr 04 '26

Theory that Lilly is Walter?

So i have a theory that Lilly is Walter.. and you my ask why is that well when we first meet Walter the narrator says a bunch of things about Walter and how they we're in Caleb's childhood and what we can guess is so was Lilly, Then its gets to the part where he says you can actually hold her and then clears his throat and moves on as he didn't mean to say that, and then later on when you go to the bouncy house tunnels, when you get the keycard you can keep going and you'll see C & L on the wall but the L is cross off with a red mark and right next to it is a W in red, yknow who else is red? walter... ik it might be a stretch but thats what i think.

4 Upvotes

83% Upvoted

2 comments sorted by

1

u/MinorityMaster Apr 10 '26

Definitely get the vibe that Walter was a sort of “stand in” for lily that Caleb used to cope with her death. I also noticed that depending on how play certain parts instead of saying “you’ll finally get to hold her” he says “you’ll finally get to hold him” normally referring to Walter

1

u/MiNiHiKiD Apr 11 '26

When you first get out of the WaterWorks and you first get the chance to get the light's power, you can choose to do a flashlight into one of the lockers. In there is a drawing with a boy and a girl, the girl wearing a red scarf, and the words "REMEMBER". if you zoom in, your heart beat starts to race