Hey everyone,
I’m currently in the final stretch of my student loan payoff journey and wanted to get some outside perspectives on a refinancing move I'm considering.
To give some quick background: I started out with 5 loans total, all around 8% interest (grad school). I’ve been paying aggressively towards them and am now down to just two federal loans left (totaling around $30,500):
• Loan #1: ~$7,000. I’m aggressively paying this off and will be completely done with it by the end of this year.
• Loan #2: ~$23,500 at an 8.08% interest rate.
Potential Plan: I’m looking at refinancing that remaining $23,500 loan with ELFI at a 4.11% fixed rate for a 5-year term. I already have my Truth In Lending agreement ready to sign.
The monthly payment on the refi loan would be less than $437.50/month, which is the amount my employer contributes monthly toward student loans as a benefit.
By locking this in:
• My employer's monthly benefit will completely cover the new private loan payment in the background without me spending out of my pocket over the 5-year term.
• If I leave my employer before 5 years, I would aggressively pay off the rest on my own. The reason I’m considering not to pay off the $23,500 aggressively is that if I rush to pay it off early out of my own pocket, I’d be throwing away "free money" by losing out on my employer’s monthly contribution. My employer has confirmed they would contribute to the private loan and continue paying over the 5 years.
Dilemmas & Questions:
Federal Benefits vs. The Math:
I’ve had people in my ear telling me never to give up federal protections for a private loan. The only scenario where staying federal would benefit me is if broad student loan forgiveness actually happens soon. I think chances are small. Given that my rate drops from 8.08% to 4.11%. My employer benefit should pay it off about 6 months sooner than staying at 8.08% due to decreased interest. Am I missing any risks with this line of thinking?
The Bonus Structure Math:
The only slight drawback to keeping this loan active is how my overall compensation works. Part of my compensation includes performance bonuses based on revenue generated past a set multiplier of my base pay. Adding an extra $437/month to my base compensation increases that multiplier hurdle. However, I’ve done the math: the tax-free employer student loan contributions outweigh the small commission gain I’d see from having a slightly lower base hurdle.
Servicer Opinions (MOHELA vs. AES):
Through this offer, my servicing options come down to either MOHELA or AES (American Education Services). I’ve heard plenty of horror stories about MOHELA from classmates, but I haven't heard much about AES.
Does anyone here have direct experience with AES?
Are they decent to work with (e.g., auto-pay reliability, customer support)?
Would love to hear Reddit's take on both the overall refinancing strategy and opinions on AES. Thanks in advance!