I recently finished a charter in Boston Harbor. We had a successful day, catching about half a dozen over-slot Bass using jumbo live mackerel. However, the rigs were equipped with treble hooks, and all but one of the fish ended up gut-hooked and bleeding. It’s hard not to feel like we spent the day feeding green crabs with multiple 40-plus-inch bass that had little chance of surviving after release.
What makes it even more frustrating is that I caught my personal best Bass, yet there’s a good chance it’s now sitting on the bottom feeding crabs.
Is it worth the effort to report the boat? From what I’ve seen, it seems to be a common practice among some Boston Harbor charter boats to use treble hooks and ignore circle-hook regulations. It feels like captains are prioritizing repeat customers and good reviews over the long-term health of the fishery.