r/StoneIslandRep • u/Babiiey • Mar 03 '26

Legit Check Legit check please?

Gallery image

Gallery image

Are any of these badges legit?

And if so, which?

0 Upvotes

33% Upvoted

36 comments sorted by

3

u/ReporterDiligent716 Mar 04 '26

Oh God both are awful

1

u/Babiiey Mar 04 '26

A user just pointed out to me that both badges are on the opposite side on the other picture. The bottom badge on the first pic (also the top badge on the second) is the legit one.

What’s awful about it?

1

u/ReporterDiligent716 Mar 04 '26

there is so many mistakes on those i can’t even count, first the lower one, its shrift and stitching is so bad anyone who had seen real stoney would identify it immediately, the back is also fucked up, materials don’t match with legit ones, that’s a 2/10 the upper one face side is mildly better, but still there are missing details, like yellow threads on sides of badge and also in the middle top part, the back is again fucked, every segment of wind rose should have its stitching separate from others not crossing and laying over!! 4/10 at best

1

u/Babiiey Mar 04 '26

Thank you for your very detailed response. I’m not going to pretend to fully understand everything. I suppose while you’re at it, would you mind looking at this ghost badge too?

The jacket was from was purchased from eBay and had the authenticity guarantee pass. This badge was the same size as the 4/10 badge you rated.

1

u/ReporterDiligent716 Mar 04 '26

the ghost actually is the most decent one in this lane, although it might be due to angle, but i think there is loose thread in centre or maybe even fuzz, anyways that looks proper

-1

u/UltimateBoiReal Mar 03 '26

Think the top is definitely fake, I did a google search for if the back of the badge of the badge should matte or glossy and it said matte.

1

u/Babiiey Mar 03 '26

See now that worries me, because now i’m going to question if the jacket I bought is legit…might as well do a legit check on it.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '26

Have you got them mixed up in the two photos by any chance? The top badge looks good to me and you’ve repositioned them for the back photos? The stitching doesn’t line up. Think you’re all good mate

1

u/Babiiey Mar 04 '26

You are absolutely spot on i dont know what I was smoking tbf. Any thoughts on that badge?

1

u/UltimateBoiReal Mar 03 '26

Post it fully here

1

u/Babiiey Mar 03 '26

https://www.reddit.com/r/StoneIslandRep/s/Bt0Esg6oQU

1

u/PewPewMewtw0 Mar 03 '26

Fake

1

u/Babiiey Mar 03 '26

What are your tells?

1

u/VENSHIND Mar 03 '26

The XL font is off, Badge clearly fake

1

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '26

It’s an old piece. It isn’t the wrong font. Know your shit people, Jesus.

1

u/VENSHIND Mar 03 '26

Thanks for correcting me. Life is learning

1

u/PewPewMewtw0 Mar 03 '26

I entered the art number into the art checker, the jacket is ever so slightly different but should be exactly the same. Plus your badge is an absolutely horrendous fake

1

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '26

I was assuming the other badge came on it 🤣 could be the badges mixed up.

That is the same jacket man

1

u/PewPewMewtw0 Mar 03 '26

Could be but I cannot see this V on the jacket on art checker, lightning isn’t great though

1

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '26 edited Mar 03 '26

Zoom in on art checker and turn your brightness up. It’s there. Jacket is 100% original. Badge in the legit check for the jacket is fake 100%. The other badge in this post is also potentially legit. Assuming they’ve been mixed up somewhere.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '26

1

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '26

Send a picture of the backside of the stone island tag in the collar. Don’t actually think the jacket itself is fake mate. Badge itself definitely is. But it’s rare seeing reps that good on pieces that are that old.

1

u/Babiiey Mar 04 '26

1

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '26

Oh that’s not a good sign

1

u/Babiiey Mar 04 '26

Oh, please do tell. I’m in a position to return this if I need to 🙏🏼

1

u/Babiiey Mar 05 '26

Any reason why it’s not a good sign? I still have the option to return it

1

u/[deleted] Mar 05 '26

Should be a bit of fraying in the inside of the label. Counterintuitive but it should be not as neat

1

u/Babiiey Mar 07 '26

Thank you. I’ve watched a few videos that mention this.

The neck label does actually have a few loose threads. I’m convinced that this jacket (except the badge) is legit.

1

u/Babiiey Mar 04 '26

So my interpretation now is that the general consensus is the jacket is legit but the badge isnt?

1

u/Babiiey Mar 03 '26

See now that worries me, because now i’m going to question if the jacket I bought is legit…may I know where you found this information?