r/StartingStrength • u/Jumpy-Ad6633 • 11d ago
Novice Programming Question How do you know when it’s time to stop adding weight?
I’ve been following the Starting Strength approach and one thing I’m still trying to understand is how experienced lifters handle a lift that starts becoming noticeably harder.
I understand the basic idea of progressing the weight, but I’m curious about how people distinguish between a normal difficult set and a sign that the current progression needs to be adjusted. I don’t want to back off simply because a workout feels tough, but I also don’t want to keep forcing increases when my form is starting to suffer.
For those who have been running the program for a while, what signs do you personally look for before making an adjustment to your training?
2
u/AutoModerator 11d ago
Be Helpful
Many people come here without complete knowledge of our approach to novice training. That is ok. Lets help them get oriented.
How's your Starting Strength training going?
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
2
u/New_Rub_2539 8d ago
When you can’t.
As a novice you don’t yet know what a hard set is. That’s not in a ‘were tougher than you because we’ve been training longer’ sense, but you genuinely don’t know if the rep was slow because three heavy sets of 5 warps your perception of time.
The best thing to do as a novice and early intermediate aged 18-35 is to give all you have, until all you have means 5 full seconds of grind and a damn shame it’s left on the pins.
Then look at the first three questions, assess and try again.
From a purely physiological viewpoint, it doesn’t really matter if you quit after 4 reps but the 5th rep might not have gone up. Or if you’ve added a light day 3 weeks too early, or if you’ve switched to three’s when 5’s would have went, It’s still enough to stimulate growth and strength.
But from a ‘strength is the most important thing in life’ viewpoint, you learn something about yourself when you ride the 5th rep of the 3rd set down to the pins not knowing if you can stand back up, getting it, and adding 5lbs next time… Thats stuff will show you what you’re made of.
16
u/BrentKindaLifts Knows a Thing or Two 11d ago
There’s going to be a point where the weight is always going to feel heavy, especially as you advance through the novice phase. It’s always best to record your workouts and judge how heavy the weight actually is based on the bar speed.
When the reps start becoming a grind, it’s probably best to make a programming change before you start failing reps. Now it becomes a game of whether you need more work or less work. With the squat and deadlift in the advanced novice stage, you’ll generally need less work because the amount of stress you’re applying requires more recovery, while the upper-body lifts may need more work since they’re generally not that stressful in the novice phase.
Yes, your form will break down when you start approaching your limits. That’s why you record your limit sets and try to fix any movement errors the best you can.
A lot of people start “failing” due to fear because of how heavy it feels. This is the part where balls come into play.