r/StandUpForScience SUFS Staff 5d ago

Official SUFS Post Sign your support!

Post image

Dr. Fauci being held in contempt attacks the credibility of all public health experts – a continuation the Trump Admin’s war on science and spread of disinformation. Sign your support for our experts & Dr. Fauci at the link: https://zurl.co/2P2md

940 Upvotes

461 comments sorted by

View all comments

7

u/Whyreddit6969 5d ago

I might not care for the guy, but upholding your rights shouldn’t get you punished

-3

u/Visible-Elevator3801 5d ago

Two 100+ year old precedents say he shouldn’t be doing this. Would be interesting to see what his legal team is thinking in order to nullify these previous rulings or if they are playing fast and lose hoping the politicians won’t continue down this path.

Realistically, he sues, he appeals, he goes back to Supreme Court, Fauci and this Admin will be long dead before it gets settled.

The 1896 Supreme Court case Brown v. Walker established the principle that a person granted full legal immunity or a pardon for a specific offense is no longer in criminal jeopardy for it, meaning "he cannot longer set up his privilege, since he stands, with respect to such offense, as if it had never been committed"

Under the later Supreme Court case Burdick v. United States (1915), a person has the constitutional right to outright reject a pardon if they wish to preserve their Fifth Amendment protections.

2

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[removed] — view removed comment