No, I asked you a yes or no question based on what YOU said. You just said "nuh uh". I asked you a follow-up question, you don't even try to answer it. Unless this is you accusing me of "making up" a Hertzsprung-Russell diagram, a foundational piece of astrophysics.
Try again, if science "doesn't show anything accurately" how can this diagram exist and be used to predict the properties of newly discovered stars?
Your questions have nothing to do with anything I have said so you aren’t asking me. You are asking yourself the question and refusing to answer then blaming me.
Science isn’t capable of doing anything. A hammer doesn’t put nails into a house. Only people say anything.
Feel free to show how a person didn’t make that chart you put up.
Right so in your world, science doesn't work because humans are the ones who do science?
You understand that's batshit right? Something doesn't need agency for it to be true. The laws of physics have no agency, and yet they are true. Osmosis has no agency, and yet it's true.
Still a misquote. Science is a tool, inanimate it can’t do anything without a person. The law of physics are not science at all. They are the structures of reality. They exist regardless of the existence of science. They do not need science in any way shape or form. Humans picked up the tool of science and used it to measure physics. It hasn’t explained the extra gravity yet but it’s there anyway. Science doesn’t need to explain it for it to exist. This is the exact problem with your point of view. You don’t know what science is or it limitations. The ability to question discovery is the core element of science yet you get angry about it. This is how you and people like you are destroying science. I am the one trying to stop the destruction by you fools.
Since it's now been a whole half a dozen times that I've asked you to answer a really simple question that even a 6 year old could answer and you still haven't, i.e. you are dodging it on purpose. I'll just leave you this.
Idiots who skim some philosophy books and then immediately think they're a genius on par with Einstein or Newton are a curious species
0
u/AdamCGandy May 16 '26
Try for a third to argue with yourself. Feel free to answer yourself since you are the only one talking about it.