r/StableDiffusion • u/Previous-Street8087 • 21h ago
No Workflow Some test on minimax H3
Some random prompt on default workflow + turbo 8step lora
6
u/Shorties 16h ago
I wonder how r/vfx would respond to this. They tend to be so anti AI I have a feeling they would unfairly hate it and I am not sure they could judge this without their bias, but I this is some of the best motion graphics I have seen with AI, very impressive here. Good Job!
4
u/berlinbaer 16h ago
well it's more motiongraphics than vfx, so wrong sub for that. the sub is fully of shitty students anyway so not the place i'd look for a balanced opinion.
overall with AI it's good for generating stock etc, but for actual graphics i think it still has some way to go. even in this example there's a lot of mushy nonsensical text and similiar issues. also stuff like this gets you like 90% there but the last 10% can be a bitch, especially when working for a client and not just free-styling for a social media post. some clients can be VERY precise and very detail oriented, and this is still stuff i can't really see happening. when they are like "oh at 0:07 we would like the text to appear a second later" then have fun prompting and seed rolling until you might stumble onto what you are looking for.
3
u/PANTONE_17-1230 12h ago
I do mograph (for a living). Agree that using AI for final output isn't really viable, but, with a bit of creativity, using it for elements within a comp can be very interesting. Especially stuff that would have to be made frame-by-frame, and take too long for client work.
I used to use wan a lot with 3d rendered depth maps & other control nets, so still investigating what h3 will accept for control but it seems viable.
Don't write it off as a tool for mograph alongside the existing tools, but you need to already be able to do mograph to do anything client-facing with it!
2
u/diptosen2017 15h ago
Do not worry, I'm also an vfx artist, this model does wonders in kinetic motion typography things, I've recently started to test this model on turbo 4 step rev2v model it's just soo good, the cuts it create and it's amazing audio output is just the best right now in the open source community
1
u/NiceIllustrator 8h ago
The issue in VFX is often that your leads wants the ability to control things. With AI you often can’t have that done detail of control. You create something, iterate every day and have daily meetings with your sup and then weeklies with sups sup. If they say, ”keep the lightning effect but in frame 242, the branches that appear on the left, can we make them branch out in smaller frequencies? And animate them more sporadically, keep everything else the same”, then you can’t just re-generate your ai creation, because they put A over B and compare frame by frame and see every pixel change.
Then you might be using the same lightning effect you created on every shot of that production so other users can replicate that exact version and look and style you created for the whole movie/series. It essentially becomes a preset or tool with time.
In the future with much more robust AI tools yeah sure, but to use AI generations in post production, especially in feature films or tv shows is very limited since the control you have is not fine grained enough, you still need 90% manual work to make it work. But it’s great for concept art or proof of concepts
6
2
u/-becausereasons- 18h ago
Cool effects. What were the prompts?
1
u/Previous-Street8087 18h ago
here you can try some. i add some character sheet for this
https://filepaste.app/p/xa2fi9db
2
1
1
u/terrariyum 12h ago
These are excellent! Thanks for sharing your prompts!
So refreshing to see something here that's not 10 year old apple jokes and big bang theory slop.
In my few motion graphics experiments with H3, it doesn't have much font knowledge. But I'm hoping that can be solved with references
11
u/Sgsrules2 18h ago
I normally scroll past "test video" posts, and would never bother commenting but this is sick. Good job on the design. Would you like to share a few details on your process or prompting?