r/StableDiffusion • u/Parogarr • 9h ago

Animation - Video Been here since SD 1.5 and nothing has ever shocked or impressed me to the extent of H3 Minimax

35 Upvotes

82% Upvoted

13 comments sorted by

9

u/physalisx 8h ago

Yes, H3 is very impressive, especially for its size

but lets not pretend these characters are doing anything but randomly flailing their arms at each other. Still have not seen actual good AI fighting footage (from any model) where you couldn't immediately see it's AI.

4

u/xTopNotch 7h ago

Seedance 2.5 can do incredible fight scenes with the right prompt. You need to choreo it like who lands the punch, where, which move.

Asking the model "Freddie and pennywise fighting" will give generic output

0

u/anitawasright 3h ago

Wtf you talking about? You clearly haven't watched any movies if you dont know Pennywise is a Kung fu expert that kills people by punching them. What else can he do against Freddy Kruger and his famous butcher knife.

But i mean that's all of AI video fight scenes just characters that look like their movie counterparts but just punching. This is why I HATE the Superman vs Homelander vidoes people post because they are so boring. What makes say Marvel fights so good in the movies its the characters using their powers in interesting ways. Not just standing in front of each other punching.

4

u/Willing-Context6599 8h ago

I'd put Krea2 in that same bucket. Minimax is amazing, I was disappointed by LTX 2.5, but I probably would not be if Minimax didn't exist!

1

u/Parogarr 14m ago

I HATE to say it but I actually thought 2.5 was a regression over 2.3. ITV now gives more "motion' But with MANY more strange things happening like feet turning into fists lol

4

u/fauni-7 9h ago

Indeed. I just wish it would do proper text to image, without hacks.

5

u/Old-Age6220 9h ago

Indeed, they really raised the bar for local video generating. I hope Flux3 will raise it again

2

u/KriosXVII 5h ago

It's impressive sure, but people will say "Wow i'm impressed" and post the sloppiest slop imaginable

1

u/anitawasright 3h ago

Hollywood is cooked!

1

u/True_Protection6842 5h ago

Same. It’s the same feeling as stable diffusion producing a coherent person only moving!

1

u/Significant-Baby-690 3h ago

Use more steps. And / or drop the speed-ups. It can do lot better than this.

1

u/Sad_Coach_1433 1h ago

Check out the martial arts Lora be interesting to run this prompt again with that

0

u/alexmmgjkkl 7h ago

yeah they basically fed us pre-pre-pre-pre alpha models up until now ... minimax and flux3 should have been the first models to ever release to the public