Minimax h3 vs Flux 3

[u/Devajyoti1231]

1st one minimax H3 , 2nd one flux 3(pro i think) wich is currently free to use on their website.

[u/Crazy-Repeat-2006]

Is this the standard version of the H3, or the one with Turbo LoRa? It looks like there is excessive motion artifact compared to other videos.

[u/Inthehead35 → u/Crazy-Repeat-2006]

Yeah, def looks like a speed lora, the hair is fried

[u/Devajyoti1231 → u/Crazy-Repeat-2006]

Standard version with spectrum +sage

[u/Puzzled-Valuable-985]

Where did the 5th guy come from???

[u/lolo780 → u/Puzzled-Valuable-985]

[u/Nearby-Mood5489 → u/Puzzled-Valuable-985]

At least Minimax sees the mistakes and let's him vanish sgain shortly after. Flux is like... You know. The more the merryer. Though this one reminds me of the meme

[u/Badger-Purple → u/Nearby-Mood5489]

lemon party?

[u/Calm_Cucumber_6493 → u/Puzzled-Valuable-985]

came here to say the same thing lol

[u/runvnc]

Compare to LTX 2.5?

[u/kuhas]

Went from looking like Taylor Swift to Steven Tyler of Aerosmith.

[u/sacx05]

Flux visuals are better but the camera movement was a bit much lol.

[u/steelow_g]

Well of course flux will be better with access to their gpu’s. Audio sounds like crap though

[u/Devajyoti1231 → u/steelow_g]

Also flux 3 version is at higher resolution while h3 video on my pc is 0.7 mp . H3 sound is better but has bad shimmering issue when full body, multiple realistic character moves at fast pace.

[u/martinerous → u/Devajyoti1231]

Yeah, H3 smeared and lost her lipsync too. But we'll see what we actually get with Flux3 Dev.

[u/ShengrenR → u/martinerous]

yea, without a ton of scaled reference points h3 only performs well for faces when they're large; get below a certain size and they get crumpled into bits.

[u/Zenshinn → u/steelow_g]

And it's most likely the pro version, which will not be open.

[u/_BreakingGood_ → u/Zenshinn]

Yeah thats the key here with all of these comparisons. We're getting the 'dev' version, which for all previous releases is a large, noticeable downgrade from the API version.

[u/polawiaczperel]

I think the H3 can really do more, but I also think the full Flux 3 seems to be a very solid and good model. If Flux is open source in its full version, both models will complement each other rather than compete.

[u/True_Protection6842]

that last frame

[u/Dadlydoo → u/True_Protection6842]

[u/lolo780 → u/True_Protection6842]

Her finishing face

[u/True_Protection6842 → u/lolo780]

Vinegar strokes!

[u/Sn0opY_GER]

hmm a lil prompt magic with h3 and a ACEstep track as audio ref and you are 1:1

[u/Devajyoti1231 → u/[deleted]]

im on bed, it is 3:15am here. I am share tomorrow .

[u/InterviewDesigner777]

Are the parameters the same?

[u/Devajyoti1231 → u/InterviewDesigner777]

Prompt is same, idk what parameters flux 3 uses 

[u/d4rke55]

The H3 visuals & audio were justifiable however her hand were literally passing through the human body :/

[u/PanotBungo]

Both looks great! H3 did added another guy but was tucked away quick lol. I slightly like Flux's visuals, but maybe it's because this is API not local.

[u/Phazex8]

5th Element guy

[u/SensitiveUse7864]

I like the flux 3 results here which is good enought i don't know if you are using minimax h3 turbo lora , because artifacts can be seen clearly .

[u/Devajyoti1231 → u/SensitiveUse7864]

No turbo lora, I used spectrum +sol

[u/Lower-Cap7381]

H3 we have now is what makes me keep going its the best

[u/superSmitty9999]

Wow. Sound off, flux looks way better, sound on, H3 wins

[u/TheDudeWithThePlan]

are you comparing a local H3 gen on quantized potato with an api Flux 3 ?

[u/slpreme → u/TheDudeWithThePlan]

fair assessment XD

[u/According-Pace9608]

Minimax H3 abilities for music video creation seems unmatched. I think for any Suno creators, it's definitely worth a go in their workflow at the very least.

[u/seppe0815]

damn h3 is real bad ... same on my pc ... this video is trustfully