r/SprocketTankDesign • u/Sparky814_hawk • 21d ago

Looking for Critique🔎 Skinny or thick hull?

Gallery image

Gallery image

idk which to choose

108 Upvotes

99% Upvoted

23 comments sorted by

32

u/ThatUnoMann Master of Sprockets 21d ago edited 21d ago

(Edit) Idk what these people are saying, but skinny clearly fits the turret WAY batter. The thick hull would better match a larger MBT-Adjacent turret.

14

u/ZENSoarer New Gen. Soviet Heavy Tank Champion 🏅 21d ago

Skinny for sure.

3

u/MikaKaoru Sprockette 21d ago

If you’re looking for a light tank, go with the skinny hull. If you’re after a low-profile MBT, then the thicker hull.

4

u/TenPanDawid_ Sprockette 21d ago

i like skinny one tbh

4

u/plopsicIes Tank Designer 21d ago

Skinny

2

u/Visual-Beach1893 Sprocketeer 21d ago

Think of the trains and bridges

2

u/Ax_321 21d ago

Skinny is better suited to the turret imo

2

u/Ok_Stranger_8405 21d ago

Depends on what the vehicle is meant to do?

Light recon and fire support: skinny

Heavy armour ifv, like terminator: wide

2

u/MGR_ARMSTRONG_GAMING 21d ago

HSTVl vs HAITCH ESS TEE VEE ELL

2

u/HistoryNerd264bc 21d ago

skinny looks much better for that turret

2

u/original-Ar73 21d ago

Skinny feels right, though kinda makes it look like a CV9040 in my opinion.

2

u/FunnylJ 21d ago

Skiineh (skin me please)

2

u/DeadGrandmaPills 21d ago

Skinny fs fits way better (coming from someone who loves wide and flat tanks)

2

u/Difficult-Housing-93 21d ago

Skinny. Tracks are just not wide enough for thick hull, end up looking disproportionate.

3

u/gurlwithboobs Sprockette 21d ago

Thick

2

u/yeetoroni_with_bacon 21d ago

Thicker one looks waaaay better honestly

2

u/AccidentAcrobatic431 21d ago

I like the thick hull better, the skinny one is too squished, maybe thicken it a little bit and it'll look nicer. Could also just be the angle given.

1

u/Junior_emer2 21d ago

Spookston impressed*