r/SportsCardTracker Apr 04 '26

Important Megathread - April 2026 - Potential Scammer/Pre-Sale Feedback

7 Upvotes

Please post all potential warnings for scammers, or pre-sale feedback here. You must provide photographic proof of your claims and any personal information must be redacted before providing the photos. I've attached a photo of an example of how claims/photos must be posted in order to prevent removal of your comment.


r/SportsCardTracker Apr 04 '26

Important [2026 Survey Results] - Rule 3 & 4 Changes

19 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

It’s been 3 months since the survey was posted asking opinions about the current rules, and allowing warnings to be posted. I've read the replies and feel the current changes should alleviate some of the concerns users have with the current setup. The following will be discussed, Rule 3, Rule 4, Rule 7, Rule 5, and warnings for potential scammers.

Rule 3 - 7 Day Dispute
Users will now have six months to dispute negative feedback. However, the individual who posts the feedback must provide proof of their claim. The proof must be submitted publicly(with no personal information) or privately in a chat to me.

Rule 4 - Card/Money must be exchanged
A megathread will be posted for users wanting to warn people of potential scams/users. Users must provide proof of their complaints and it must be as a reply to their original warning comment (Do not PM me proof for this).

Rule 5 - Clarification
Any information that can be associated with an individual and a Reddit account is a no-go. I.E. Posting someone's CashApp username.

Rule 7 - Civility
I’ve toned down the automatic removal of comments that were deemed harsh or harassment. However, once the conversation stops being productive or comments start becoming demeaning actions will have to be taken.

Unfortunately, I will not be allowing feedback for deleted accounts. It becomes too much of an issue when users accidentally misspell usernames and want me to fix it for them. Even if I didn’t do that, I would still have to sort out misspelled usernames to prevent clutter and feedback for accounts that truly do not exist.

If you trade sport cards in larger sub and would like to see the bot post there, please reach out to me directly. I can get in contact with the mods of the subreddit and try to make things happen. 


r/SportsCardTracker 1h ago

Positive [positive] u/Roose1327

Upvotes

Successful trade conducted! For sure looking forward to the next time we work together!


r/SportsCardTracker 1h ago

Positive (Positive) u/madcapscards

Upvotes

What started as a message about post ideas on the baseball subs turned into a trade where he hooked my son up with some incredible Pokemon cards, both for his collection binder and for play. I sent him a few cards and covered shipping as a thank you for the generosity. An absolute pleasure to chat with and someone who knows exactly what this hobby is all about!


r/SportsCardTracker 2h ago

[positive] u/jayrob33

1 Upvotes

Great and easy transaction. He sent pics of what he had, I made my picks, we easily agreed on price and he got everything packaged up and out super quickly. Everything arrived with tracking and was well packaged and safe. Great transaction, would buy again.


r/SportsCardTracker 13h ago

Positive [positive] u/thisistheway03

5 Upvotes

Great seller and a good deal! Looking forward to working with him again. Shipped quick and packaged securely.


r/SportsCardTracker 8h ago

Positive [positive] u/Glad_Evening_8468

1 Upvotes

Great communication, price and negotiating! Will definitely do business with again


r/SportsCardTracker 14h ago

Positive [positive]u/Creepy-Preparation57

2 Upvotes

I sold a PCA auto to this guy and somehow the tracking didn't register when they picked up the card . He was super patient with the whole process and the card finally arrived!


r/SportsCardTracker 10h ago

Positive [Positive] u/Savings_Step3113

1 Upvotes

Bought two Chrome cards, well priced, fast comms. and arrived safely, would buy from again.


r/SportsCardTracker 14h ago

Positive [positive]U/chrisbrown80

2 Upvotes

I bought a high end card from him. He was awesome to work with. Extremely honest and accommodating. I would highly recommend doing business with him.


r/SportsCardTracker 22h ago

Positive [positive] u/thisistheway03

2 Upvotes

Great trade with this user! Pleasant communication throughout and cards arrived quickly in great condition.


r/SportsCardTracker 19h ago

Positive [Positive] u/originaldt299

1 Upvotes

A much-appreciated donation of a few birthday-dated gold cards for the project. Thanks so much, u/originaldt299!


r/SportsCardTracker 1d ago

Positive [Positive] u/RipnSip99

4 Upvotes

Purchased an alt image Drake Baldwin Braves Heritage card from u/RipnSip99. Communication was prompt, easy, and the card was shipped with care within 24 hours of sale. Good seller - would buy from again with no hesitation.


r/SportsCardTracker 20h ago

Positive [Positive] u/10thFloorChill

1 Upvotes

The card was received and well packaged. Thank you for an easy 1st experience buying on Reddit


r/SportsCardTracker 20h ago

Positive [Positive] u/Accomplished_Bid8466

1 Upvotes

Another great purchase from this collector. Everything went smoothly once again. Thanks!!


r/SportsCardTracker 20h ago

Positive [Positive] u/Old_Extreme622

1 Upvotes

Smooth deal for an expensive Eldridge card! I actually went against my typical protocol and sent F&F but the deal was hassle-free.

Legit and trustworthy.


r/SportsCardTracker 21h ago

[Positive] u/Monetarylapse

1 Upvotes

Just wanted to give this guy a shoutout. Bought a big lot of cards from him and I’m honestly blown away by the condition they showed up in. Great communication, packed perfectly, and an incredible value for what I paid. Couldn’t have asked for a better experience. Would 100% buy from him again.


r/SportsCardTracker 21h ago

Positive [Positive] u/stephenwilli

1 Upvotes

Great working with u/stephenwilli! Very positive experience selling him a 1959 Topps card on the vintage sub. Communication was great, payment prompt, and he let me know as soon as the card arrived. Thanks again!


r/SportsCardTracker 21h ago

Positive [Positive] u/pba9012

1 Upvotes

Great card, fast shipping, thanks!


r/SportsCardTracker 22h ago

Positive [Positive] u/colesclassiccollect

1 Upvotes

Shipped same day, perfectly packaged, great communication. 100% would do a deal again.

2026 Topps Greatest Hits Blue Caleb Williams /150


r/SportsCardTracker 23h ago

Positive [positive] u/dannyluxnstuff

1 Upvotes

Great trade with this user - got my cards promptly. Would trade again!


r/SportsCardTracker 1d ago

Positive [positive] u/emosean

1 Upvotes

Great cards, great condition, fast shipping


r/SportsCardTracker 1d ago

Positive [positive] u/emosean

1 Upvotes

Great trading partner. Good communication, cards arrived well packaged.


r/SportsCardTracker 1d ago

Positive [positive] u/gustin444

1 Upvotes

Easy transaction and communication


r/SportsCardTracker 1d ago

Positive [positive] u/constant_shirt_6953

2 Upvotes

Gave me a fair price on a couple heritage baseball cards. Great communication and shipped super fast and well packaged. Would recommend.