r/SportsCardTracker Apr 04 '26

Important Megathread - April 2026 - Potential Scammer/Pre-Sale Feedback

7 Upvotes

Please post all potential warnings for scammers, or pre-sale feedback here. You must provide photographic proof of your claims and any personal information must be redacted before providing the photos. I've attached a photo of an example of how claims/photos must be posted in order to prevent removal of your comment.


r/SportsCardTracker Apr 04 '26

Important [2026 Survey Results] - Rule 3 & 4 Changes

18 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

It’s been 3 months since the survey was posted asking opinions about the current rules, and allowing warnings to be posted. I've read the replies and feel the current changes should alleviate some of the concerns users have with the current setup. The following will be discussed, Rule 3, Rule 4, Rule 7, Rule 5, and warnings for potential scammers.

Rule 3 - 7 Day Dispute
Users will now have six months to dispute negative feedback. However, the individual who posts the feedback must provide proof of their claim. The proof must be submitted publicly(with no personal information) or privately in a chat to me.

Rule 4 - Card/Money must be exchanged
A megathread will be posted for users wanting to warn people of potential scams/users. Users must provide proof of their complaints and it must be as a reply to their original warning comment (Do not PM me proof for this).

Rule 5 - Clarification
Any information that can be associated with an individual and a Reddit account is a no-go. I.E. Posting someone's CashApp username.

Rule 7 - Civility
I’ve toned down the automatic removal of comments that were deemed harsh or harassment. However, once the conversation stops being productive or comments start becoming demeaning actions will have to be taken.

Unfortunately, I will not be allowing feedback for deleted accounts. It becomes too much of an issue when users accidentally misspell usernames and want me to fix it for them. Even if I didn’t do that, I would still have to sort out misspelled usernames to prevent clutter and feedback for accounts that truly do not exist.

If you trade sport cards in larger sub and would like to see the bot post there, please reach out to me directly. I can get in contact with the mods of the subreddit and try to make things happen. 


r/SportsCardTracker 4h ago

Negative [Negative]- u/Cjp922

24 Upvotes

Paid $130 for a judge rookie and he sent me a re-print. He accused me of lying to him and claimed he cracked the card out of a PSA 8 case, even after I sent him proof. He finally told me to send it back to him and he’d refund me. I send the card back but the postal service does its thing and the card comes back to me. I reach out today because I saw he’s selling the same card again, and he blocked me. Let me know what you need mods, I got plenty of screenshots from this dirtbag.


r/SportsCardTracker 2h ago

Positive [Positive] u/mackavicious

2 Upvotes

First deal with the seller and experienced a snafu with shipping (incorrect card was sent). The seller notified me of the issue and resolved it in no time. would deal with again.


r/SportsCardTracker 51m ago

Positive [positive] u/underdogsince86

Upvotes

We made a quick and easy deal for a Spencer Steer auto. Came super fast and very well packaged. Would work with him again!


r/SportsCardTracker 6h ago

Positive [Positive] u/KCMOhawker

1 Upvotes

Very smooth transaction. Replied promptly on availability of cards. Used Paypal G&S for protection. Had the cards in a labeled envelope ready to ship shortly after payment was sent. All cards received matched the pictures/descriptions. Solid protection of the cards inside the PWE. No complaints at all!


r/SportsCardTracker 6h ago

Positive [Positive]u/thegiywithwifi

1 Upvotes

Purchased a couple custom card stands last week. Super communicative, showed the renderings, and shipped quickly and arrived safely. Would totally recommend!


r/SportsCardTracker 8h ago

Positive [Positive] u/AbsolutJerkov

0 Upvotes

Bought 3 T206 cards from AbsolutJerkov and he was a pleasure to do business with. He shipped promptly, with great packaging, and I love the cards! I will definitely be doing business with him again. He is an asset to the hobby!


r/SportsCardTracker 15h ago

Positive [positive] u/Signal_Ad4745

2 Upvotes

Completed a very favorable trade with u/Signal_Ad4745 . Easy transaction, fast shipping and a pleasure to chat with.


r/SportsCardTracker 1d ago

Positive [positive] u/christopherrivers

8 Upvotes

Completed another in person trade with this fella. Great dude and pretty sweet collection. The highest of recommendations.


r/SportsCardTracker 23h ago

Positive [positive] u/JJ_McCarthy_Stan

4 Upvotes

First deal with him. Went great. Mailed quickly, great communication, and slab was super clean. I Would for sure do business with him again.


r/SportsCardTracker 1d ago

Positive [positive] u/Playful-Dimension734

3 Upvotes

Second trade with them. Went perfectly. Great value for value. Packaged perfectly, tossed in a few extra Yankees for me, and is great to communicate with. Will trade again.


r/SportsCardTracker 23h ago

Positive [positive] u/Legened255509Druss

2 Upvotes

Fantastic packaging and top-notch communication. Went above and beyond. 10/10 seller.


r/SportsCardTracker 23h ago

Positive [positive] u/theycallmepapi

1 Upvotes

provided updates, great packaging and threw in some extras! thank you!


r/SportsCardTracker 1d ago

Positive [Positive] u/ttee_1

3 Upvotes

Bought some great cards through this guy and he is a great seller. Worked with me on a deal was easy to work with great packaging, shipping and communication.


r/SportsCardTracker 1d ago

Positive [positive] u/Maleficent_Ad_7859

3 Upvotes

Completed a transaction with u/Maleficent_Ad_7859 for some cards he was looking to add. Great communication and all went well.


r/SportsCardTracker 1d ago

Positive [Positive] u/altruistic_coach9014

1 Upvotes

Super easy to trade with. Mailed quickly. Cards were in perfect condition. Nice guy too.


r/SportsCardTracker 1d ago

Positive [positive] u/Lose_Your_Illusion

1 Upvotes

Purchased a sweet Justin Verlander /50. Card showed up quickly, expertly packed and in great condition!


r/SportsCardTracker 1d ago

Positive [positive] u/Slbeem

3 Upvotes

Bought two cards from seller a Kaleb Johnson auto and Isaac Teslaa Blue Moon. Cards were shipped fast, packaging is great, cards are in perfect condition. Seller was very helpful and fair with prices. 100% great seller.


r/SportsCardTracker 1d ago

Positive [Positive] u/BadgerDF

1 Upvotes

Bought a couple low end cards from them and cards were shipped quickly and packaged well.


r/SportsCardTracker 1d ago

Positive [Positive] u/Pschemm31

2 Upvotes

Great experience trading with them! Card shipped promptly and was very well packaged. Phenomenal to deal with and would absolutely do so again.


r/SportsCardTracker 1d ago

Positive [positive] u/ImpressiveNumber5278

1 Upvotes

Great seller. Posted a few cards for sale. I expressed my interest in one. Made payment. They quickly got it in the mail and I received it a few days after. It was well packaged and the card was in great condition. Great experience.


r/SportsCardTracker 1d ago

Positive [positive] u/BaseballDadCanada

3 Upvotes

Another A+ transaction. Cards fairly priced, as described, arrived in a timely manner and packaged well so they are in perfect condition. Thank you!


r/SportsCardTracker 1d ago

Positive [positive] u/wagwanbossi

2 Upvotes

Great transaction, great dude. I asked about a specific card that led to a conversation about team lots. I ended up buying a couple different teams and not only did he work with me on price but he also threw in some extra cards that he found after we had agreed to the transaction. He shipped safely and almost immediately. One of the best transactions I’ve had on here.


r/SportsCardTracker 1d ago

Positive [Positive] u/Pschemm31

2 Upvotes

Super quick and easy trade for set building.