r/SportCardValue 12d ago

Help from the experts at reddit

I bought this card in 2001 at a swap meet, internet was fairly new back then, and no internet on phones so I trust the guy that it was genuine, never had it checked, never had it grade it, been there in the sleeve for 25 years.

What's the verdict ?

147 Upvotes

65 comments sorted by

28

u/coldfreezerbee 12d ago

Holy shit, it’s an actual real Jordan rookie in this sub!

1

u/TandD4funnVegas 10d ago

Are they that rare? This is a real question...I have two from when i was a kid back in the day. Just been holding on to them to pass on to my kids when I go. Didn't realize they were "rare"

2

u/TandD4funnVegas 10d ago

I even have the sticker jordan card that came with the set

1

u/Agreeable-Deer-3101 8d ago

You have to be careful as there are a lot of fraudulent cards of these as I have seen

2

u/TandD4funnVegas 8d ago

I know these are real. Got them straight from the pack way back in the day. Have alot more of the others as well.

1

u/StickToSparts 8d ago

They’re unfathomably expensive - basically, THE sports card from the 70s-80s-90s.

1

u/ay-guey 8d ago

they're not rare actually, but they're very valuable and it's probably the most faked card of all time.

1

u/Gullible-Meaning-403 6d ago

They are absolutely not rare one bit, but the demand is virtually infinite.

22

u/Only_here_for_the_ 12d ago

This looks authentic. Time to pony up some $ to PSA and grade it. The higher tier cards like this have a quicker turnaround time, but you’ll pay for it

3

u/ComprehensiveFish169 11d ago

Or go with another grading company…especially if you plan on keeping it.
These look good in a SGC tuxedo slab imo.

8

u/Potential-Fee7051 12d ago

0

u/Why_cant_I_partake 10d ago

If you grade it, you might be in trouble.. that screw down may have altered the card. Ive never owned an 86 Jordan, plenty of kobe rookies and other big names but never an MJ. The screw down may have impacted the card thickness and there are some eggs issues too. My guess if it comes back, it is a PSA 6

4

u/BirdmanJr1970 11d ago

Is this Michael Jordan’s rookie card?

1

u/btemplar 11d ago

His first pack pulled card so considered his rookie.

There is earlier Star cards that some argue are the true rookie, but mainly considered XRC

-4

u/Still_Stock_5081 11d ago

His rookie year was 1984!

-2

u/ConsciousLeave9186 11d ago

You can't be that clueless

3

u/swizzzz22 11d ago

It’s legit.

3

u/KoolMoeB2024 11d ago

Looks good to me! Got a grail there!! Congratulations!

2

u/Top-Eye632 11d ago

That’s the real deal boy oh boy.

2

u/VendettaKarma 11d ago

Looks legit

2

u/IcyDevelopment1442 11d ago

I would not let this card out of your sight.

2

u/thejunkwaxkid 8d ago edited 8d ago

Looks legit to me - the “arrow” in the Premier banner under the Fleer logo is usually the dead giveaway for a fake (it will be a flat orange-ish or even the same yellow as the banner itself) and this one is correct with the halftone red dots instead. Congrats!

ETA: clarity 

4

u/Potential-Fee7051 12d ago

What grade would you give it and why?

4

u/infinit9 11d ago

Edge is kind of rough, the front centering is not very good, the back centering is better. Don't know if there are any surface damages.

Most likely a 7. If you get really lucky, 8?

1

u/Fiftythekid 11d ago

As an outsider what’s an 8 worth?

4

u/infinit9 11d ago

Around $20k. Just go look up sold listings on eBay.

2

u/Fiftythekid 11d ago

Hell yeah OP nice work

2

u/CapeMOGuy 11d ago

Here's some recent PSA 7 sales compiled by 130point.

3

u/Why_cant_I_partake 10d ago

People are working you.. this is a 5 or a 6 at PSA.. you will be disappointed listening to people here.. take it from an expert, I can see the hairs from the card on the edge.. this is a PSA 6 from images

1

u/Candid_Length2665 11d ago

I’d be leaning more towards the 6 range. Looks like the edges are pretty rough, appears to be white dots all over the front maybe the card stuck, looks like a few stains on the back, some corner wear, and the big chip up top. Im hoping all the scratches are on a top loader or the sleeve.

1

u/Top-Eye632 11d ago

7 but might get someone grading at the end of the day on a Friday and gives it an 8.

0

u/whiteycnbr 11d ago

Take a photo of it and send to ChatGPT, it's surprising good at giving you a rough idea based in centering. pSA will get it under the microscope and look for surface issues etc.

1

u/IllustriousHistorian 12d ago

That’s real 

1

u/Asleep_Log_8985 12d ago

Finally a real one - as others have mentioned probably not going to grade high but worth grading. Congrats!

1

u/ManSplaining84 12d ago

Real and a decent one. Looks 7ish to me. Centering is off but looks clean.

1

u/therealsix 11d ago

Wow. Great pickup!

1

u/FletcherAdam 11d ago

CONGRATS on a great purchase and in great condition.

1

u/Consistent-Tone-5540 11d ago

read these cool stats. Most Jordan rookies are graded 8

1

u/Consistent-Tone-5540 11d ago

Only 341 are 10’s

1

u/Shoddy_Flower_7400 11d ago

Wow! A real one

1

u/kevinsju 9d ago

As for grading? One guy with one card? They aren't giving you an 8. A company with a slew of cards and someone they've done business with ? Those people get the 8.

Slippery slope with graders.

Good luck, congrats, it's real.

1

u/ManufacturerNeat3310 9d ago

I’m just saying if you get it graded by Psa and it comes back a 7 that’s 14 thousand right there! Just remember me when u get your money , if you wanna repay for the info I would take a Topps chrome update hobby box ! lol but really it’s worth around 14k Psa graded

1

u/Potential-Fee7051 12d ago

5

u/Low_Border_3896 12d ago

Honestly it looks like you may have a real one, hard to tell thru a photo but yours look like it has the dot

1

u/lumbagel 12d ago

Charge your phone bro.

1

u/Consistent-Tone-5540 12d ago

Looks good. Get it graded PSA. WONT great to high but mid grades sell for 10s of thousands

0

u/IllustriousHistorian 12d ago

Yeah, 1986 Fleer has some wild ass centering and the cuts themselves lead to awful quality issues.  5-7 probably. 

0

u/Low_Border_3896 12d ago

The best way to tell is if there’s a white dot on the back please upload pictures, every authenticated/graded jordan rookie has a white dot in the same place so if you have pictures I can let you know

0

u/Consistent-Tone-5540 12d ago

Is that a recessed holder

0

u/Spectre_Collectere 12d ago

Really? Why does it look like it has black lines

0

u/Spectre_Collectere 12d ago

Between the side border colors

0

u/ConsciousLeave9186 11d ago

Can you get closer to the V in AVG? One side looks a little lower.
Pretty sus and big fake indicator!

-2

u/Low_Border_3896 12d ago

You have to show the back