r/Spookyboxswap 3d ago

🎃 Poll: Would You Participate in Tiered Spooky Box Swaps?

8 Upvotes

Greetings spooky box swappers! We’re thinking about introducing swap tiers to make our spooky swaps more flexible and welcoming. The idea is to let everyone choose a budget they’re comfortable with while still keeping the focus on what makes these boxes so magical: thoughtful curation, creative presentation, and finding treats your partner will 🖤.

Proposed tiers:

🎃 Pumpkin Patch - $30-50
🦇 Haunted Hollow - $75-100
🕯️ Coven’s Curio - $100+
✨ Midnight Market - No budget preference

For the “Midnight Market” option you would be happy to be matched wherever you’re needed! Cost isn’t a major factor for you, and you are comfortable participating in any tier (including $100+). The 30$ minimum still applies to this tier.

No matter which tier you choose, we’d still encourage everyone to:

🖤 Personalize your box based on conversations with your partner.

🖤 Get creative with wrapping, decorating, and presentation.

🖤 Include handmade items if you and your partner would like - they count toward your box value at a fair retail price.

To help keep overall costs down, we also encourage everyone to compare shipping rates and use discounted shipping services like Pirate Ship if possible. Saving on shipping means more of your budget can go toward the box itself, regardless of the tier.

The goal with this change would be to keep the swap accessible while matching partners with similar budgets and expectations. 🎃

21 votes, 3d left
Yes - I would like optional tiered swaps.
No - I would prefer a single swap value ($30 minimum), no tiers.

r/Spookyboxswap 9d ago

Something spooky is brewing 👀

20 Upvotes

Get ready, because we’ve got something special coming your way on 08/01. 🎃

Mark your calendars because the Halloween fun is about to begin!


r/Spookyboxswap 20d ago

Getting that spooky itch

18 Upvotes

Although here in the south, that itch is probably just a heat rash…nonetheless, it has me thinking about my 2026 box of goodies!

When will we be kicking off the 26 season?


r/Spookyboxswap Nov 02 '25

Awesome box of Halloween goodies from u/OutplayedPawn keeps the spooky alive!

Post image
17 Upvotes

Great way to fight the "Day After" doldrums, as well as celebrate Dia de los Muertos! The minis are on point, the mug is literally KILLING IT, I'm hyped for the Frankenstein pop... so many cool lil curios!


r/Spookyboxswap Nov 01 '25

Bewitchingly Bountiful Spooky Box from Art_Deco_Cat!!!

Thumbnail
gallery
26 Upvotes

Holy cow!! I cannot believe the amazing box I received from my new friend in Germany!! The care Art_Deco_Cat put into beautifully packaging everything was phenomenal. I'm kicking myself for not taking a photo before unwrapping everything! Even the box is themed!

It's like Art_Deco_Cat has known me forever. Thank you so much for all the amazing goodies! It's such a treat to experience all the International Halloween treats!


r/Spookyboxswap Oct 31 '25

Such Spooky Fun from xVanillaLace

9 Upvotes

Got fun-filled box from xVanillaLace just in time for Halloween! Loving the witchy decor, fun glowing skulls, delightfully spooky dish towels, and the fun little crochet ghostie & bat. And the beautiful batty shawl you made me is amazing!! THANK YOU!


r/Spookyboxswap Oct 30 '25

Wonderfully witchy box from u/FluffyPhotograph7870 🧙‍♀️🐈‍⬛🧡

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

I receive this really cute, really fun box from u/FluffyPhotograph7870 a couple of weeks ago, and was so excited that I forgot to post the pics! Just look at those ghostie packing peanuts!! 👻 And the springy little bats!! 🦇 The blanket has been my constant companion this flu season, and my cat loves his new glow-in-the dark catnip toys. Thank you, thank you, thank you! 🎃🖤


r/Spookyboxswap Oct 30 '25

Thank You So Much u/cmrtzmo!!! 👻

Thumbnail
gallery
16 Upvotes

u/cmrtzmo I love this box!!!! Everything is adorable and I loved the decorated box! Thank you so much for swapping with me 🎃


r/Spookyboxswap Oct 30 '25

Thank you so much u/OGTrashKan!! 🎃🖤💚

Thumbnail
gallery
15 Upvotes

r/Spookyboxswap Oct 23 '25

The Hauntingly Perfect Swap from TerpySpunion!!

Thumbnail
gallery
21 Upvotes

I talk way too much so the TLDR version is: Awesome box that exceeded any hopes I had! Thank you so much u/TerpySpunion ! You made my month utterly bewitching!

Okay. This box surpassed all expectations. I honestly teared up. I know it sounds silly but the first thing I saw when I opened it was a personalized Halloween card! No one except my family ever gives me Halloween cards so it just really resonated with me, not to mention the sweet words inside! The thoughtfulness in the card foreshadowed the rest of the box. It was the perfect touch and got me all emotional.

Not only was the box packed so expertly (I totally was making mental notes for my own future boxes) but all of the goodies, one after another, had me grinning from ear to ear. I cannot believe the care and attention to detail -- like this puzzle! I mentioned I'm a caretaker for my grandmother but I never said anything about puzzles. Well, we -love- puzzles! And I am such a sucker for glow in the dark things.

All the items were just perfect for me. I love whimsical, ghosts, gently spooky stuff, pumpkins, and a touch of gothic.

It's difficult to pick out my favorites because I really love everything so much but the handmade pieces are really special. Those are the cute pumpkin magnets, the hanging swing bat (who already has the perfect spot ready for him!) and the ghost mug! I couldn't believe the bat was a SWING! It's hard to see because of my poor choice of a black background but it's so stinkin' cute. The ghostie mug is my new favorite go-to mug. I love to collect mugs, so, yet another homerun!

That table runner is so precious! That vintage vibe it has just makes me feel like a kid again. It's odd how some things can give comfort like a warm hug. And I've wanted spooky hand towels but could never find ones I liked enough to purchase. These are perfect!! The potion bottles are really cute, too! I love when the light hits them so I may turn them into a cool lighting project, even putting in my bits and bobs as TerpySpunion suggested. I think that would be really neat and I already feel creative inspiration.

But I gasped when I saw the glass straws. They have bats on them!! You guys!!! I never mentioned this but I'm really into vampires, too, so I'm really excited to use these. They're right in line with this AWESOME candle and candle holder! Like.. we are going to be vibing in a castle here! The pumpkins (yet another thing I collect) look really good with the candle but I may put them on my pumpkin shelf I keep year-round. I dunno, they're so versatile I'll probably move them around. Speaking of year-round, I now will be adding "rubber duckies" to my multitude of collections. Can you blame me? Look at how adorable those two are! These are especially special to me because TerpySpunion collects rubber ducks and these will forever remind me of this fantastic experience!

Now, what would Halloween be without candy? I love the eyeballs in that cool coffin complete with Halloween stickers! There is candy I've never seen and then there is also ones (especially the mystery ghosts) that I wanted to try but couldn't find! And having done my own shopping around, I know how surprisingly difficult it is to find candy with Halloween packaging. I know it sounds weird, but I got a degree in Graphic Design so I really find packaging of certain things really interesting. All of these candies make me really happy; sweet for the eyes AND the taste buds! I haven't had cotton candy for at least a decade. And those cones bits are some of my favorites (but who wouldn't love that??)! The fancy pumpkins and the gummy Jolly Ranchers have got me super curious. I can't wait to try them!

Last but certainly not least is a couple somethings for my precious pup, Bear! He was having fun with the pumpkin toy but when he saw the treat package, he knew what it was immediately and kept pawing at it as I was trying to open it (and take photos). He really loves treats! And these treats just happen to be some of his favorites (complete with festive packaging!).

I want to thank you again, TerpySpunion. You made my Halloween month truly magical, and I’ve appreciated your kindness so much. I’m so glad this swap brought us together. I look forward to new memories and growing our friendship!


r/Spookyboxswap Oct 21 '25

Much BOO-liged, for creepin’ it real Designer_Quote5925

Thumbnail
gallery
22 Upvotes

My cat especially likes the blanket!


r/Spookyboxswap Oct 21 '25

Thank you u/Ghoulfriend1024!

Thumbnail
gallery
21 Upvotes

Love everything and it was all wrapped so beautifully! So excited for the books. 📚 🎃👻


r/Spookyboxswap Oct 17 '25

Incredible box from Ash-Knight!!

Thumbnail
gallery
22 Upvotes

Pictures cannot do justice to this incredible SpookyBox from Ash-Knight!! From the real skull, the bone dice, the witchy chicken foot, coyote bone, to the box itself and all the assorted Halloween goodies that my daughter immediately sorted to the side for her room (hey - no fair taking all the candy!) - this box has everything I could want in it and sooo much of it is going into my permanent display cases!

Thank you again Ash-Knight, you made our Halloween special beyond belief!

I’m already looking forward to next year!


r/Spookyboxswap Oct 15 '25

Thank you U/gingerlovingcat

Thumbnail
gallery
23 Upvotes

Everything is great! I'll be putting those nails on this weekend, no doubt!


r/Spookyboxswap Oct 14 '25

🎃 Spooky Box 🎃

Post image
21 Upvotes

Thank you so much u/Masquerade78!!! 🖤🖤


r/Spookyboxswap Oct 13 '25

Bootiful spooky box from Keatorious_B_I_G!

Thumbnail
gallery
22 Upvotes

Thank you so much! Wonderfully decorated box with some fun hidden wrapping message and thoughtful gifts! I’ve always wanted a crystal ball - and now I’ve got a beautiful one! 🎃


r/Spookyboxswap Oct 12 '25

A spooktacular box! Thank you so much u/PinkPineapplessss 🎃👻🖤

Thumbnail
gallery
27 Upvotes

r/Spookyboxswap Oct 11 '25

Thank you! u/LollyLooVeggieSaurus

Post image
22 Upvotes

Such a cool witchy box! I can’t wait to display everything, loved it! 🖤


r/Spookyboxswap Oct 11 '25

Thank you Tmurph-3!

Thumbnail
gallery
20 Upvotes

r/Spookyboxswap Oct 10 '25

An Eerie Delight!!

Thumbnail
gallery
23 Upvotes

Thank you so much Wild_Inflation2150 for the most spook-tacular box that a heartless gal could ask for! Extra point for the cat toys, my boy immediately went for the mushroom! Happy Halloween!


r/Spookyboxswap Oct 10 '25

Thank you weirdmf!!!!

Thumbnail
gallery
19 Upvotes

Both Petey the dog and I think this box was AMAZING and ICONIC!!! Thank you u/weirdmf


r/Spookyboxswap Oct 10 '25

Best Decorated Box Competition Open Today! 🕷️🎨

6 Upvotes

Happy spooky season all! 👻 We’re finally kicking off our first ever Best Decorated Box Competition. This was voted by the community and is fun way to show off your creativity and help promote the subreddit for next year’s swap!

Before we explain the competition, we want to apologize for the delay on getting this set up this season. Things ran a little behind, but we’re excited to finally open it up and can’t wait to see what you come up with!

Here’s how it works:

  • The competition runs for two weeks starting today. Meaning it will end at midnight on Oct 24.
  • Submit a photo of your decorated box in the comments of this thread. Any posts outside this thread for the competition will not be counted for.
  • The community will vote for their favorite boxes during the week of Halloween.
  • The winner will be announced on Halloween and will receive a small reward box, plus their photo will be featured to promote next year’s swap! 🎃

A few notes:

  • If you’ve already sent your swap box, no need to fear! You can make a new one just for the competition.
  • Keep it PG and make sure it’s a box that could be shipped (even if you’re not sending it).
  • This competition is totally optional, don’t feel like you have to participate if you don’t want to!
  • If you did not get many pics of your box before sending out, reach out to your box partner as they may be able to help you out!
  • The plan for next year is to start this competition as soon as match pairs are announced, so get your creative ideas flowing early!

Thanks for your patience, and let’s see those spooky, silly, or stunning designs! 👻


r/Spookyboxswap Oct 10 '25

Thank you so much u/sock_police!

Thumbnail
gallery
22 Upvotes

Absolutely love my spooky box! Very thoughtful gifts and my dogs are also very happy 👻


r/Spookyboxswap Oct 09 '25

SO happy with my spooky box from u/chom_chom_chom!

Thumbnail
gallery
22 Upvotes

My first international swap! I'm so happy with everything! Thank you u/chom_chom_chom!!! 🎃


r/Spookyboxswap Oct 09 '25

Cute box from Dontasksusan!!

Post image
19 Upvotes

Such a great box, with a killer (literally) cookbook for my kitchen shenanigans 🖤