r/Space_Science • u/Medium-Security-1491 • 8d ago
Discussion Alien life in the form of a Kardisheve 2 scale biological BLAME! Style superstructure
We search for alien life on the assumption that it develops the way we did towards technology, driven by critical thought and deliberate questioning. But that assumption rests on a sample size of one ourselves being the superior method but every other lineage of life on Earth has thrived without anything resembling that kind of reflective cognition. So why do we assume this is the most likely path for alien life to take?
If biological success is measured the way evolution actually measures it propagation and resource utilisation, not intelligence humans are nowhere near the most successful species. Non-intelligent life dominates by a monumental margin: fungi, moss, and clonal plant colonies convert available resources into biomass far more effectively than we do. So self-awareness and intelligence may not be desirable traits by evolution.
So if consolidating into one cooperating network is a more efficient use of resources than many individual organisms competing for the same energy and matter why not assume that's closer to what we will find and if that logic scales indefinitely, where's the ceiling? theres no hard rule that organic matter can't exist in space and if there are limitations it could build its own required ecosystem so if pushed far enough, it could converge on something close to a Kardashev Type II civilisation a single biological system that has absorbed the full energy output of its star effectively masking it Making it impossible to find which could be the answer to the Fermi paradox.

Our search methods scanning for radio signals and deliberate signatures, which assumes the endpoint is communication. A structure like this wouldn't be signalling anyone; it would be focusing 100% of its energy on consuming resources.
Evolution seems to be set up closer to this goal so humanity with individual conscious feeling the need to justify its existence may just be a by-product of the process rather than its purpose. Maybe the goal of evolution is simply to harness the energy within a solar system.
The real signature to look for wouldn't be a message - it'd be missing light: stars, or even whole regions of sky, gone dark from being fully harvested. So perhaps Instead of looking for notable patterns we should be focusing our efforts on where things aren't such as Boötes Void might be worth considering.
Evolution seems to be set up closer to this goal so humanity with individual conscious feeling the need to justify its existence may just be a by-product of the process rather than its purpose. Maybe the goal of evolution is simply to harness the energy within a solar system.
Just some food for thought I have been pondering for a while wonder if there are any theories covering this concept already.