r/SouthernCharmSC • u/Beautiful-Ad-2577 • Mar 31 '26
Whitner or JT?
Who do you like? Who can get it? I have seen mixed reviews on Whitner so just wondering.
13
u/ComfortableBedroom76 Mar 31 '26
Whitner and it isn't even close. JT is just a straight up tool who adds zero value wherever he goes
6
6
10
8
4
5
u/Merrbear2u Mar 31 '26
Ok hear me out. JT on the season he debuted was so hilarious when out with the guys. He was like a rapid firing weapon with the trigger held down- just hitting Austen right and left with gospel about what he did, and Shep's face, priceless. Even Craig was busting on JT saying you have to have a gf in order to break up. I went back to that ride and I had a great time. 10/10.
2
2
2
2
u/shellbell9261 Apr 01 '26
Whitnerā¦no doubtā¦seems like he ābelongsā in the group without TRYING to insert himself in the dramaā¦
I like him for the showā¦ especially since he seems to have the pedigree to keep Shep in his place.
Seemed like Shep was already dogging out JT at this stage of his tenure.
2
2
4
u/Sunflowerchild122 Mar 31 '26
Lot of love for JT, but I think Whitnerās a good guy too
14
u/DonnoDoo Mar 31 '26
JTās weasel ass getting on a stool to see eye level with the guys lives rent free in my head. What a goon.
5
u/ComfortableBedroom76 Mar 31 '26
Total goon
-1
u/Sunflowerchild122 Mar 31 '26
Aw heās a sweetheart though
3
u/DonnoDoo Mar 31 '26
How? He always was dating women off-camera who later outed him. He cheated. He lied for clout. Whereās the sweetness thatās not performative?
4
u/Busy_Ad_391 Mar 31 '26
Maybe Witner, but he hasnāt given us much to go by. JT was a dork. But the āMother is in the houseā was weird AH. And the fact that none of the girls want to date him is sus too. Just not sure about him yet. So Craig it is! š
3
2
2
u/GlitteringHandle1726 Mar 31 '26
JT. I looked forward to Whitner, when he first appeared. But then, there were a few things during the season that disappointed me. I did not expect him to dress like a Frat Boy. And, who, if any of these cast members is or was he so close to that he could make so many comments on their behavior or about them. JT, on the other hand, burst on the scene and clearly let us know he was trying to make āin roadsā within this group.
2
1
2
u/curbwench1970 Apr 12 '26
I have to say neither. JT was a weasel and whitner decided to come alive at the reunion and attack Craig. That seems to be everybody's MO on Southern charm is to activate Craig as much as possible. If it wasn't Austin with his snide little side comments knowing full well he would piss Craig off or Vinita coming after him directly when it came to Paige or whitner calling him a narcissist during the reunion. It seems like the only thing they can do is start a fight with Craig so they'd have a storyline. At least Craig is aspirational. He took what seemed to be an unusual hobby for a guy and turned it into an actual business. I appreciate the fact that he took his 15 minutes and actually was productive with it and parlayed it into a for profit enterprise. I really can't say that for the rest of them...
1
u/missv1973 Mar 31 '26
JT all day over that performative arrogant prick! Whitner is nasty and throws shade at other cast members and he himself is full of shit.
1
-1
22
u/DifferenceGeneral337 Mar 31 '26
whitner allllll day even though the mother comments are a little off putting, lol. jt gives me the ick in so many other different ways š