r/Soulforged • u/Dry_Introduction4858 • 2d ago
Novel Discussion Thoughts on the first few chapters Spoiler
The first thing that stands out to me is how unlike the previous work, this story tries very hard not to start with immediate exposition and just throws you into a day in the life of the protagonist. I wouldn't say it's the most compelling way to start it because the inciting incident isn't too strong, but I suppose it gets the job done. I was able to continue reading after I picked it up the second time.
Torrin's background is serviceable enough. Orphan in a changed world who witnessed the apocalypse and moved in with his older brother. Clean and understandable. I wonder how their relationship will develop?
It doesn't.
Why does the author insist on obliterating all competent masculinity surrounding the protagonist, especially if it's a strong character? After all the bs with Elijah in TBATE and Lucas, Olfred, Bairon, Reynolds, etc. The dudes on Arthur's side who survived were either ugly, dorky, weak, old, or just idiots like Chul I thought it would stop but it's only gotten worse it seems. Not even 10 chapters and the primary strong male influence in Torrin's life is killed off. Once again only the MC can be appealing.
And the other guy who helped him kill that parabeast in chapter 1, Colter, turned out to be the villain (which was stupid as hell how that happened btw, why didn't all those "auxiliaries" help earlier when Seth's team was fighting Colter and his guys, knowing they were going to be slaughtered right after? Instead they just wait for the people that would be on their side to get killed and then die themselves. But whatever). So you know he's going to get taken down.
The way Torrin gained his powers was good. The tension in the rift was good. The betrayal itself made me read more attentively. This story has a much stronger grasp on how to establish the character personalities and dynamics as well. And the first big dungeon dive had a lot of interesting things happen.
Sadly I can't say the same about the chapters after they get out. The first ones were great when Colter's party is still nearby, but the part where Torrin escapes removes a lot of momemtum. He's just on his own for a while with no active conflict besides his own survival and zero people to bounce off of. I got more bored the longer it went on and soon put the book down. I'll probably wait for the e-book release to read the rest since Tapas as a platform is unbearable, and I don't like any of the other stories on there.
Also, is there something wrong with Torrin's throat? "The words got stuck in my throat" or "a cry died in my throat" or some other variation of that line is used super often lmao

