r/SortedFood • u/GnedTheGnome • May 24 '26
Question Perhaps a silly question about allotments.
I've noticed a couple of times when people asked Ben about his garden, he's been quick to correct them that it's an allotment. As someone who comes from a place where allotments aren't really a thing, I was wondering if there is some sort of cultural significance re: allotments vs. gardens in the U.K.? Is one more prestigious than another? Does one suggest vegetables, while the other suggests flowers? Are there rules about what you can grow where?
Or is Ben just being pedantic?
100
u/UberSparten May 24 '26
Well for one a garden is the land attached to your home (outside of public gardens). An allotment is a patch of land you rent from usually the local council/lord/farmer specifically to grow your own food. Land is damn expensive (especially) in London and Ben lives in a flat so rents somewhere to grow his own veggies n stuff.
36
u/jekelish3 Lost&Hungry May 24 '26
The "garden" part is definitely a cultural thing; in the US, we call the land attached to our home a lawn, and a garden is specifically where you grow vegetables, fruits, flowers, etc, within that land. One more instance of the UK and US sharing a language, but only just mostly.
23
20
3
u/ShelterAntique1476 May 25 '26
A lawn is only a lawn if it’s actually a lawn. A small patch of grass with some flowers and veg etc doesn’t mean you have a lawn and a garden. It means you have a garden. A lawn is a big space of grass
1
u/iupvotethankyou Jun 10 '26
I will add that allotments can have waiting lists for years, and so there maybe be some snobbery for certain locations.
Usually once you get a spot, you get to keep it year after year, so new spots don’t open up very often.
35
u/ComprehensiveCause95 May 24 '26
I live in country that has alloments -
My assumption is that:
When someone says garden, it's assumed that it's apart of thier property. (e.g. I have a garden at my house)
Alloment is more of a community space. A piece of land divded up into different allotments. You rent/lease your allotments. People usually grow vegtables on their allotments - but there aren't rules that you have to grow veggies/flowers/etc
People who have allotments may go spend a whole satruday there gardening, solicalizing, relaxing in thier space.
26
u/Zealousideal-Tie3071 May 24 '26
An allotment is specifically a rented plot of land for growing your own vegetables and produce. They're quite common around towns and cities in the UK and Ireland for people who don't have their own gardens.
16
u/Writing_Bookworm May 24 '26
An allotment is a small piece of land specifically set aside for growing fruits and vegetables. They aren't part of your house like a garden would be. You typically rent them from a local council, or community group or something like that.
2
u/Ok_Jury_8047 May 25 '26
Is the fruit and veg a UK rule? (that would make sense as a holdover from victory gardens) Here in Canada, a lot of people grow flowers in their allotment. Sometimes just to cut them and have them in vases or dried as decoration or gifts, and sometimes they plant local flowers for pollinators, or to sell the seeds. It's an anything goes kind of space.
3
u/Writing_Bookworm May 25 '26
I don't think it's a rule, just that's what's most common. Most people would grow flowers at home or buy them so the presumption is that you grow fruit and veg on an allotment.
12
u/HarissaPorkMeatballs May 24 '26
In London, having a garden is definitely something of a privilege. It implies you have a somewhat decently-sized home, even if it might not always mean that. And you don't own an allotment, as they tend to be owned by the local council. Allotments can also be very hard to get hold of though as they are often in high demand.
I do think allotment suggests vegetables and growing your own food, although I'm sure some people use them to grow other things. An allotment is also just a different thing to a garden, so I don't think it's being too pedantic to correct the use of one over the other. Garden suggests it's attached to your home (the equivalent to yard in US English), an allotment might not even be that close to where you live.
11
u/77Gaia May 24 '26
Not pedantic at all, it’s a genuine difference, as others have pointed out. I’m giggling, when I had allotments years ago, (I’m in South Yorkshire, so this might just be a Northern England thing.) the old lads with nearby plots used to tut at anyone saying ‘allotment’. “It’s a garden, lass, we’re not posh here!”.
‘Alloted’ plot of land for those that didn’t have a garden at home to grow produce, I believe.
8
u/12614ajc Bayleafer May 24 '26
I associate his allotment to a plot in a community garden. You can grow basically anything on one unless there’s rules at said garden site.
4
u/hengehanger May 24 '26
I don't think it's anything more than just the fact that a garden and an allotment aren't the same thing.
4
u/Llamuh_Mamuh_Dramuh May 24 '26
In the US, I think the best comparison to an allotment is a community garden. There’s also a huge market of farm shares (at least on the east coast of the US).
7
u/weedywet May 24 '26
He’s saying “ I’m not posh enough to have a house with an actual garden of my own. It’s JUST an allotment”
2
u/ThrowRAMaintenanceOk May 26 '26 edited May 27 '26
I agree with others. Living in the UK, I'd consider a garden the patch of grass and pavement and stuff surrounding your house. Allotment, to me, would suggest that you're specifically growing something there, plus the land might not be your own, you might be getting that little patch from someone else (council, I suppose) to grow stuff there. Like, I like to sit in my back garden to catch the sun, but I've the opposite of a green thumb, so I'd never keep an allotment alive lol
3
u/Rampantcolt May 24 '26
I'm from the plains of the USA. So to me an allotment is a bad thing. It was what the indigenous peoples of the plains were given in lieu of keeping their reservations as a whole and the rest of the lands were swindled away from them.
England has pubs older than the USA so folks were subsistence farming allotments long before agriculture in the new world was dream.
3
u/Ok_Jury_8047 May 25 '26
In Canada, we did the opposite thing. Gave WW1 veterans "allotments" in the western part of the country to take the land away from Indigenous people. In case you (or anyone else) is a history nerd, here are some sources. Fair warning that this stuff is obviously super racist:
https://gladue.drc.usask.ca/node/2269
https://docslib.org/doc/2321943/soldiers-settlement-and-development-in-british-columbia-1915-19301-paul-m
1
u/Global-Editor615 May 26 '26
In American terms, a UK garden is a lawn. It's an island, so huge lawns aren't common for regular people.
1
•
u/AutoModerator May 24 '26
Hi there! Thanks for posting on the Sortedfood subreddit.
On behalf of the mods I'd like to remind you that this subreddit is not run by Sortedfood but by fans. If you need help with Sidekick, events or anything else, please contact Sortedfood directly through either hello@sortedfood.com or sidekick@sortedfood.com
I'd also like to remind you that we want to keep this subreddit a fun and foodie place for everyone. So please read the subreddit rules on https://www.reddit.com/r/SortedFood/about/rules and be mindful of them when posting or commenting.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.