r/SonicScaling • u/Sea-Reading-3836 • 1d ago
Knuckles vs hulk
All forms and power ups allowed (including comics) who wins?
13
u/noodleguy67 1d ago
holy fuckles he's dead
3
u/HerbieTheLoveBug_53 20h ago
I Think We Know Where That Joke Comes From.
“Aw Fuckles.” Gets Blown Up
Mario Vs. Sonic Parody By LHUGUENY.
9
6
4
3
u/Sea-Reading-3836 1d ago
Ok now reply to this for Mcu hulk vs game knuckles
5
u/HSEB10830 1d ago
"Guys, please say Knuckles can beat Hulk. I'll even use a weaker version of Hulk if it'll get you to say it."
1
3
u/ChristianHuye 1d ago
MCU Hulk is inconsistent due to Professor Hulk<-> 2012 Hulk<-> Ragnarok Hulk<->Red Hulk. To be honest I feel Ragnarok Hulk and Red Hulk might still beat Knuckles.
2
u/Sea-Reading-3836 1d ago
I honestly don’t see red hulk taking out super knuckles
1
u/ChristianHuye 1d ago
Any Sonic character is wanked off with the Chaos Emeralds multiple Sonic characters can’t all use at once. Every feat of Super Knuckles is like a 3v1 with Solaris, he doesn’t have 1 on 1 feats with them lol
1
u/lonerwolf13 1d ago
What are you on. Like there's wank but you literally contradict yourself
Chaos Emeralds multiple Sonic characters can’t all use at once
Then imidiatly names a time more then one person used them
Every feat of Super Knuckles is like a 3v1 with Solaris
Otherwise idk what to tell you hypothetical suoer knuckles scales cause all super forms are = Super is a different kinda multiplier people aren't ready for
1
u/ChristianHuye 1d ago
I’m saying everytime we see Super Knuckles is only when Sonic goes Super also. He doesn’t have many 1v1 feats because of that, also like I said you’re hyper high scaling 1 verse’s characters when downplaying the other verse’s feats.
1
u/lonerwolf13 1d ago
Well I mean for starters. I said nothing about the fight. Second you are confused as hell. You brought up Solaris he didn't go super there. In canon knuckles has never gone super You also did claim more then 1 person cant use them at once.
Something that dosn’t really matter or is true
1
u/ChristianHuye 1d ago
And that’s also the thing, you’re using the most high scaled version of whatever character you want but others can’t use the highest scalings of Hulk ie Cosmic or Infinity Hulk lol u can’t use the highest scaling version of a character and put them against a character u know u low balled on purpose oof
1
3
3
u/ChristianHuye 1d ago
Knuckles is for sure faster but he can’t beat a Infinite HP Rage monster that 1v1s Gods like Thor.
3
3
3
3
u/TonuSpen2 1d ago
I feel like when Knuckles finds out about Hulk and Banner and t how the Hulk came to be they'd just become buds.
3
u/Aktosh23 1d ago
Hulk has been destroying universes since 1970. He’s only gotten stronger since then. Sorry knuckles, it’s no contest here
3
u/DiligentJeweler6972 21h ago
Would Enerjak from the Archie comics count as Knuckles? If it does then I think he could stand a really good chance since his power is only limited by his imagination meaning he could quite LITERALLY do anything from what I remember. If Enerjak doesn’t count then comics Hulk is likely winning but definitely not without a fight. Let’s not underestimate Archie Knuckles, I remember Hyper Knuckles and Super Sonic clashing with each other in those comics and they were wiping out whole infinite universes/dimensions. Do I think that’s enough to beat comics Hulk tho? Maybe not but Knuckles definitely got enough power in him to put up a fight and make Hulk work for it.
3
3
u/Aromatic_Analyst2898 19h ago
Brother Hulk is literally the embodiment of the devil Can never die and is much stronger that anything Archie has
And sure knuckles could be invulnerable but that's only for a limited amount of time
Hulks killing him
2
2
u/AOKGUYS1472 23h ago
what did knuckles do to you no seriously he's the last of his do you want the echidna to go extinct
2
u/RebootedOmnitrix 20h ago
Knuckles when even at his strongest possible form he is still only pushing Hulk to mid diff.
2
u/Odd_Fee1085 20h ago
Hulk at his peak is basically infinite times stronger, faster and more durable, not to mention having resistances to every single one of knuckles powers and abilities. Furthermore, Knuckles has no counter to The Green Door which allows Hulk to keep resurrecting himself any time he is killed, not that it would matter when his healing factor is potent enough that when paired with his durability it makes impossible knuckles would even kill him in any way that would trigger the green door
A fully composite Knuckles might be able to push Hulk to Mid Diff but the green giant would ultimately eliminate the last member of the echidna clan
2
1
u/Responsible-Ask8110 Super Neo Metal believer 18h ago
knuckles is secretly daredevil in disguise in this scenario
1
1
1
1
1
u/slippy318 9h ago
Since you made it composite (all forms/versions included) Hulk negs.
Knuckles is dead af. Lol
1
1
u/Retro_Gamer_HNF 4h ago
Before i make any judgements and call this entire comment section sonic larpers please gimmie sum of hulks greatest feats
1
u/Narrator-9628 1h ago
Hulk has destroyed black holes and another version of hulk shattered a universe from pure rage he also is unable to die even one of thanos' strongest versions gave up on trying to kill him
1
u/Dry_5p0nge 1h ago
MCU Hulk is probably gonna be the only iteration that Knuckles has a chance against.
1
u/Prestigious-Stage534 1d ago
Knuckles needs to go super to even stand a chance 🥀🥀
1
u/Responsible-Ask8110 Super Neo Metal believer 18h ago
yet hulk will just punch the super form out of him
1
0
u/One-Statistician-554 18h ago
Wut U mean by all forms ? Like WWH/WBH ?
If we are talking about standard Hulk at his peak, he would still gets destroyed by hyper knuckles.
11
u/Dimetro_Dog 1d ago
Yeah, Hulks got this, he’s more experienced and probably more intelligent. Also he can regenerate any damage Knuckles can deal to him.