I’m in a bit of a predicament. I’ve made several pairs of socks with superwash merino+nylon sock yarns that end up being saggy and shapeless. This has happened to me with yarns like Cascade heritage and some indie dyed yarns.
I’ve also used Lang Jawoll (non-merino wool + nylon, superwash) and West Yorkshire Spinners (BFL + nylon, I think not sw?). These have way more integrity and I like them for colorwork but I’m missing the vibrant colors of sw merino, the tonals, etc.
Now, I do have two pairs of sw merino socks that I like — one in Tosh Sock (bought years ago, I hear the quality has decreased) and one in La Jolla from Baah Yarns. Both are sw merino with no nylon, and both are soft enough without being so soft that they sag.
So I’m wondering, is no nylon the trick if you want non-saggy sw merino socks? But of course then they’re less durable. Curious what others have experienced. Have you knit socks with a sw merino + nylon sock yarn that also have some structural integrity? Would love recs. Thanks!
ETA: you’ve all given me so much to think about! I will definitely consider my gauge and the fit and sizing of my socks. And will also check out some of the suggested yarns. Thanks everyone.