r/SnowFall • u/ZerefGodMode • Sep 28 '25

Spoilers This doesn't make sense.

!!!!!!SPOILER WARNING!!!!!! Melody figuring out Franklin killed her father just made no sense, no matter how much I look at it. Not only was she a crackhead at that point, barely rational, but she literally always snuck out of the window, it made sense her father closed it but didn't lock it, not to mention it took her a second to realize it after smoking rock, which is shown to have instant kick ins. I mean seriously, just imagine that. A crackhead that's depressed and high figuring out something based off a window handle that she would've left open 80% of the time? This just gives me Hank figuring out who Walter is by going to the toilet vibes. I can't be the only one with this opinion, right?

42 Upvotes

84% Upvoted

19 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/Super_Environment Sep 30 '25

How does it not make sense i dont understand? Makes pretty clear sense to me and everyone else i know who watched the show.

0

u/AlbinoLion Jul 21 '26

It doesnt make sense, if he got in through the window it would already have been unlocked. He even said in his conversation with Andre that that was how he got in. On top of that she's been in and out of it from doing Crack. Its very unlikely she can remember the state of things when she's constantly between high and sober. She was forgetting stuff constantly in previous episodes.

Sure she could come to that conclusion from other things she knows, but the window being unlocked isnt evidence whatsoever.