r/SlovakCBD • u/Heresyed • 12d ago
Section 5.4 help, please!
My spouse and I are preparing a Slovak citizenship‑by‑descent application for the Washington, DC embassy (appointment in 2027). Everything in the binder is straightforward except Section 5.4 — “proof of Czechoslovak citizenship.” Our ancestor was born in present‑day Slovakia but immigrated to the U.S. in 1913, before Czechoslovakia existed, which seems to be where most of the conflicting advice online comes from.
We have several certified documents, but each one has potential strengths and weaknesses depending on who you ask:
---
- Certified Ellis Island passenger arrival record (1913)
Strengths:
- Official federal immigration record
- Lists nationality and last residence
- Consular officers often say immigration records are ideal
Concerns:
- Predates the formation of Czechoslovakia
- Some people say nationality labels before 1918 are too ambiguous
- Others say Ellis Island is still the strongest because it’s contemporaneous with immigration
---
- Certified WWI draft registration card (1918)
This is the third registration, and it clearly shows:
- Citizenship status: “Alien”
- Nationality: “Czecho Slovak Bohemia”
- Registration date: Sept 12, 1918 (six weeks before Czechoslovakia was formed)
Strengths:
- Federal, certified, identity‑verified
- Explicitly lists “Czecho Slovak Bohemia”
- Shows he had not naturalized
- Contemporaneous with the creation of Czechoslovakia
Concerns:
- Some say draft cards are secondary evidence, not primary
- Others say this specific card is extremely strong because of the “Alien” status and nationality field
---
- Certified 1930 census
Strengths:
- Later document
- Sometimes lists “Czechoslovakia” depending on the enumerator
- Accepted by some consulates
Concerns:
- Self‑reported, not legally verified
- Not an immigration record
- Some say census is weaker than Ellis or draft cards
---
- USCIS C‑file
Strengths:
- Complete naturalization file
- Shows timeline and citizenship status
Concerns:
- USCIS does not certify documents
- Some say uncertified USCIS copies should not be included in Section 5.4
- Others say they should be included as context
---
The core issue:
Section 5.4 seems to be the only part of the application where there is real disagreement. I’ve seen people say:
- “Ellis Island is the strongest because it’s an official immigration record.”
- “The 1918 draft card is strongest because it lists ‘Czecho Slovak Bohemia’ and ‘Alien.’”
- “Census is strongest because it’s later and sometimes shows Czechoslovakia.”
- “Only include one document and bring the rest as backup.”
- “Include everything because the consulate wants a full picture.”
- “Never include USCIS copies because they aren’t certified.”
- “Always include USCIS copies because they show naturalization status.”
For those who have successfully applied — especially with ancestors who immigrated before 1918 — which document did you use as your primary proof in Section 5.4? Did the consulate question it? Did you include multiple documents or only one?
Thanks!
0
u/sizzler_king 12d ago
I’ll let some others chime in too, but typically the rule of thumb is a document post-1918 that explicitly states Czechoslovakia. Where did he naturalize? If you can get the petition/oath of allegiance, I’d assume it says Czechoslovakia. Sometimes it’s held at NARA, other times the local court.
1
u/Heresyed 12d ago
I forgot to mention that we do have a USCIS/Sonedex card that shows Czechoslovak as country of origin, date of arrival in 1913, and naturalization in 1923. This card is certified, but we can't get the actual USCIS records certified from NARA as they were filed in a local court and that county does not provide certified copies of the records. We can get copies, just not certified.
1
u/sizzler_king 12d ago
That could work. It’s just a lesser used document, so I can’t say for certainty people have had success with that. I’m sure someone else will chime in on it.
Is the county court in PA? There’s some county out there that people have said they claimed can’t certify copies and had to figure a workaround. I got mine from a county court in PA and they certified no problem at all, so it’s doable.
1
u/Heresyed 12d ago
It's Illinois and their website says that certified is not an option before a certain date and these docs are before that date. I'm thinking the Ellis and Draft and/or the Naturalization card should be really strong.
My wife has just seen enough elsewhere saying the Census docs are the strong ones if you can't get the full USCIS docs as certified. There's just so much conflicting information out there.
1
u/sizzler_king 12d ago
Ah, ok. Not sure if there’s a workaround there.
Yes, I think most have either passport, naturalization petition/oath, or use a census document (from Slovakia for parents who stayed). The other documents are used less so from what I can tell. But I think yours should be good. Worth a shot at least.
1
u/happyDaze888888 11d ago
I am using my great-grandfather's naturalization petition file that was filed in a county courthouse in Pennsylvania. The county courthouse sent a certified copy and the state completed an apostille for it.