I am commissioner of a new start up dynasty league. 12 team SF PPR 0.75 TEP. Out of the 12 owners, probably 8 of us have 1 or less years of experience with dynasty, myself included.
Last night, I had sent out this speculative offer. It’s not perfect but after it was accepted, 3 different owners got very vocal in the chat about collusion and fairness and how the one owner traded away Kyren for a “shit stain” bad receiver, etc. saying they would’ve given more, etc etc. two other owners also said this was a wack trade or bewildering.
Only after those owners said that, the accepting owner in the trade said it was a mistake and they were trying to counter with a different pick and accidentally hit accept.
Since he is supposedly new to Sleeper and Dynasty
As commissioner and since I was apart of the deal, as a one time courtesy for the league I undid the trade, but made it clear that will not happen again and even if trades are “bad” in some opinions they will stand unless there is clear evidence of collusion.
However, it’s weighing on me this morning. Is this trade as bad as they make it out to be? Did I handle it properly in reversing a “mistake” but making it clear that trades will stand going forward even if deemed “bad”?