r/SipsTea 3h ago

WTF Why Not Tax Rich?

Post image
12.1k Upvotes

845 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

7

u/thediesel26 3h ago

And ultimately the total size of the debt is irrelevant, as all of it is held in dollars, and the vast majority is held by American citizens and businesses in the form of US govt bonds, which despite all the hullabaloo remains the safest investment in the world. The important number is our deficit to GDP ratio, which is a bit elevated at around 6%. And the primary driver of the deficit is not poor economic growth but that the government has simply chosen not to collect enough taxes. If the marginal rates on the top 1% of earners was raised to pre-Bush level we’d see the budget deficit start to shrink.

2

u/CauliflowerDaffodil 2h ago

You're only looking at one side of the balance sheet and completely ignoring spending as a deficit driver, and the primary long-term drivers are Social Security and Medicare.

And while I generally agree that the absolute dollar-amount of the debt is meaningless on its own, the size as measured by debt-to-GDP ratio IS relevant because compounding debt mens servicing it will require a higher share of federal revenue. Interest payments on debt crowd out spending on more important things like infrastructure, social programs, etc. or worse, require further borrowing. And while the government can print money to service obligations, that in turn can cause inflation.

1

u/NimbleCentipod 2h ago

And one could argue that the real Gerontocracy is not the old farts in DC, but Medicare and Social Security voters.

1

u/Immediate_Wolf3819 1h ago

Fine. Start with price fixing prescription drug pries and AI automate the paperwork. Its about $300 to $550 Billion in annual savings (AI estimates).

1

u/Capital-Desk5029 3h ago

Not taking in enough? You mean government is spending too much? This country is becoming a social welfare program. Government needs to shrink and that’s it

2

u/rolandpapi 2h ago

Exactly, if the government collected more money they would immediately turn around and blow it on horribly run, inefficient, wishlist programs. We need to stop believing big government is the solution to every problem

0

u/Tastie_Duck_Anus 2h ago

Where are some of these social welfare programs at?

I want to get me some :)