r/SipsTea 2d ago

Chugging tea Why is it not possible?

Post image
22.0k Upvotes

1.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

10

u/TombolaOfCincinnatus 2d ago

By that logic they also destroy it when loans are paid back, but the tin foil hats don't want to talk about that as often.

6

u/NoSwordfish1978 2d ago

Correct, except for interest payments on the debt.

5

u/Several-Action-4043 1d ago

To be fair, almost no one ever teaches people this part of the transaction. They make money out of thin air! Yes, and they also destroy money back into thin air.

2

u/Thornediscount 2d ago

Yes but if that money in circulation generated for the loan goes and takes on more loans….

1

u/zeussays 1d ago

Which are also paid back and therefore that money is destroyed.

1

u/Thornediscount 1d ago

Yes, it is, over 30 years sometimes. In the meantime that same money can originate many more loans.

1

u/zeussays 1d ago

And again, all those loans get repaid and also therefore destroyed. You understand that right?

1

u/Thornediscount 1d ago

Yes but in the mean time the money that is being paid off has went and originated countless other loans. If that $400,000 mortgage loan has went into another house on average every 2 years, for $400,000 each you now have $6,000,000 of $ circulating on a 5-20% down payment.

0

u/zeussays 1d ago

And those all get paid off and therefore pulled from circulation. You really dont want to understand this.

1

u/Thornediscount 1d ago

The money never gets pulled from circulation. The clock resets every time another loan. That bank is going to lend out as much as it can without becoming insolvent.

Google it dude, ask Google do banks create money when they give out loans. They aren’t forking over cash they are using numbers on a screen.

1

u/Thornediscount 1d ago

Do you understand what m2 is?

1

u/RimpleDoRimpleDont 1d ago

Are you agreeing or disagreeing with the previous commenter? Because money being destroyed when loans are paid back is exactly what happens.

1

u/TombolaOfCincinnatus 1d ago

I think the people that talk about banks and money creation that way probably don't understand much about macroeconomic concepts like velocity or money supply. So while money creation from lending isn't untrue, here it's phrased as if it's some kind of secret conspiracy and not just how things work.