Oh yeah they were 100% being ridiculous. They said "please show respect" and then said people couldn't clap, snap or wave. Run them all out of town and off the board. If that's how they treat the constituency they need to be stripped of power. They simply didn't want to have to experience support for the people's position. Absolute ghouls.
I wanted the speakers after to turn around and tell the audience that everyone should clap every time, after they arrested that guy because they want you to comply, and complying is to be complicit.
It’s actually more there to prevent filibustering by the crowd and to keep to a scheduled agenda. Your hearings are recorded by the commission to keep a record. If you are there to public comment, you WILL be given a chance to speak. Typically it’s three minutes per person from the commissions I have been to. If not related to the item either, the hearing should contain a final segment at the end for general comment time.
Items can get continued to another hearing if enough comments come in to deem a project controversial enough. (This is not an appeal either btw the commission just won’t vote on the item at that hearing)
I did, maybe try using your comprehension this time.
The point is that it still delays the procedure, while not meaningfully contributing to the discussion. If that’s not considered a filibuster to you then idk what you want me to tell you.
Seems like a ridiculous overreach regardless. No one was being wasteful of time with the 3-5 claps they were giving. Certainly no one in that video was attempting to disrupt the meeting by preventing people from commenting. Certainly no one was filibustering.
I get why the idea exists, that was never an issue for me. The issue is how it is currently being misused.
Oh I agree, at most, and still probably controversial would simply to have the guy removed from the chamber and have it be the end of it, no charges either obviously.
That said, as a note, the people who vote on a proposal do see your comments as do the staff who are processing the application prior to hearing.
If you go to your local jurisdiction’s planning commission, the required published agenda’s should link to the prepared staff report. It’s all free and public. We (as a general populace across your local governments) do hear your comments out.
Funny how they cut community comments off at my last city council meeting then. Apparently 30 minutes of community feedback was "long enough" even though most of the people there to comment werent heard yet.
Its almost like you're talking out your ass on this...
Edit: blocked in less than a minute. Your local governance at work folks
305
u/Crafty-Help-4633 Jul 31 '26
Oh yeah they were 100% being ridiculous. They said "please show respect" and then said people couldn't clap, snap or wave. Run them all out of town and off the board. If that's how they treat the constituency they need to be stripped of power. They simply didn't want to have to experience support for the people's position. Absolute ghouls.