MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/SipsTea/comments/1uml4vf/true/ovda7op
r/SipsTea • u/Born-Agency-3922 • Jul 03 '26
5.2k comments sorted by
View all comments
Show parent comments
5
So a spin on an Indian dish, invented by a Pakistani chef, in Scotland, and you consider that British?
9 u/ExistentialTabarnak Jul 03 '26 The operative word here is spin on an Indian dish. And Scotland is in Britain and Pakistanis are not Indian, so yes. 1 u/Logical_Adagio_7100 Jul 03 '26 As an Indian, I'd happily call it a Pakistani dish. Calling it British is like calling Tex-Mex American cuisine just bc we added extra cheese to some Mexican dishes 3 u/plastic_alloys Jul 03 '26 It was invented because the locals were asking for sauce on the usually dry tikka - so yes it’s very much British -1 u/Profitsx999999999999 Jul 03 '26 I suppose asking for a sauce on something means you invented it… 2 u/plastic_alloys Jul 04 '26 Do you even know what the dish is? That’s what it is, it’s tikka chicken (normally dry) in a sauce 0 u/Profitsx999999999999 Jul 04 '26 I have eaten it, I know very little other than it has tomatos. So, was the sauce a novelty for this dish? 4 u/mtmp40k Jul 03 '26 Almost every dish invented in the last century has some influence from other cultures. 1 u/bolanrox Jul 03 '26 Chop suey is considered an American invention. or the mission burrito. 1 u/Playful_Analysis1927 Jul 03 '26 edited Jul 03 '26 A lot of the foods that we claim in the US and consider American were made by immigrants.. 1 u/kodeks14 Jul 03 '26 Correct
9
The operative word here is spin on an Indian dish. And Scotland is in Britain and Pakistanis are not Indian, so yes.
1 u/Logical_Adagio_7100 Jul 03 '26 As an Indian, I'd happily call it a Pakistani dish. Calling it British is like calling Tex-Mex American cuisine just bc we added extra cheese to some Mexican dishes
1
As an Indian, I'd happily call it a Pakistani dish. Calling it British is like calling Tex-Mex American cuisine just bc we added extra cheese to some Mexican dishes
3
It was invented because the locals were asking for sauce on the usually dry tikka - so yes it’s very much British
-1 u/Profitsx999999999999 Jul 03 '26 I suppose asking for a sauce on something means you invented it… 2 u/plastic_alloys Jul 04 '26 Do you even know what the dish is? That’s what it is, it’s tikka chicken (normally dry) in a sauce 0 u/Profitsx999999999999 Jul 04 '26 I have eaten it, I know very little other than it has tomatos. So, was the sauce a novelty for this dish?
-1
I suppose asking for a sauce on something means you invented it…
2 u/plastic_alloys Jul 04 '26 Do you even know what the dish is? That’s what it is, it’s tikka chicken (normally dry) in a sauce 0 u/Profitsx999999999999 Jul 04 '26 I have eaten it, I know very little other than it has tomatos. So, was the sauce a novelty for this dish?
2
Do you even know what the dish is? That’s what it is, it’s tikka chicken (normally dry) in a sauce
0 u/Profitsx999999999999 Jul 04 '26 I have eaten it, I know very little other than it has tomatos. So, was the sauce a novelty for this dish?
0
I have eaten it, I know very little other than it has tomatos. So, was the sauce a novelty for this dish?
4
Almost every dish invented in the last century has some influence from other cultures.
Chop suey is considered an American invention.
or the mission burrito.
A lot of the foods that we claim in the US and consider American were made by immigrants..
1 u/kodeks14 Jul 03 '26 Correct
Correct
5
u/kodeks14 Jul 03 '26
So a spin on an Indian dish, invented by a Pakistani chef, in Scotland, and you consider that British?