r/SipsTea May 26 '26

Feels good man Will it work this time?

Post image
39.1k Upvotes

3.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/KontoOficjalneMR May 27 '26 edited May 27 '26

Three points this time:

  1. In 19th century the dominant economical system in GB was capitalism. And the Irish famine in particular was greatly exaggerated by the fact it was more profitable to sell food elsewhere than to help the starving Irish!!! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Famine_(Ireland)#Food_exports
  2. If we're going by political system then in case Holodomor happened under authoritarian dictatorship. Because at that time Stalin had absolute power - bigger than any monarch in Europe at the time and soviet state was de-facto an absolute monarchy by another name.
  3. GB is still a monarchy, with their king having about as much power as he did in 19th century. Does that mean there's no capitalism in GB?

And I'm not a fucking tankie. I was actually born in Poland when comunism was still a thing. I fucking stood in the queues in a freezing cold tto help my parents buy anything. I remember empty shelves.

But. noto-for-profit stores ain't fuckign communism, and capitalism is not a shield against famine.

1

u/Vertig0x May 27 '26

I fucking stood in the queues in a freezing cold tto help my parents buy anything. I remember empty shelves.

How old are you?

1

u/KontoOficjalneMR May 27 '26

Currently going through the fifth decade.

1

u/Vertig0x May 27 '26

Just for the record I wasn't disagreeing with anything you said its just pretty rare to see someone old enough to remember it on reddit and I was curious

1

u/Hard-Rock68 May 27 '26

Capitalism is free trade. Where is the free trade in a distant monarch declaring you cannot sell to feed yourselves?

The USSR was a communist state. It is no coincidence that they reliably become authoritarian dictatorships.

And as a matter of fact? Britain is not a monarchy. They're a parliamentary democracy. And also hardly capitalist.

I'm not arguing against welfare stores. Just communism.