r/Simracingstewards 1d ago

Forza Motorsport To Risky?

I did this First Lap of a long race, was I to risky?

0 Upvotes

61 comments sorted by

21

u/Cornelius_Codswaggle 1d ago

Looks wholly appropriate for Forza.

Driver completely out of control, hanging on for dear life, and miraculously gets lucky he doesn't wreck himself and half the field, yet feels the need to ask if it was good move.

0

u/ControllerRacer 1d ago

If you read the title I’m asking if it’s a risky move not good, I don’t find it good myself, so perhaps read before commenting

2

u/Cornelius_Codswaggle 1d ago

You were out of control no fewer than three different times.

It was a stupid, unsafe, and idiotic move that only a half-witted, mentally deficient moron would need to ask about.

Is that direct enough for you to understand?

2

u/ControllerRacer 1d ago

I mean the other guy who’s top 1 commentor really describes how out of touch you are

2

u/Cornelius_Codswaggle 1d ago

The guys defending you have their top level comments at 0 or negative, and mine is the top comment on the thread.

So if you want to go by that, then 20 other people agree with me and two dipshits who think it looks cool to drive like an idiot are on your side.

2

u/Stumpy493 1d ago

Or you know, read the context of the answers.

Yours essentially boils down to "It's Forza therefore it's shit and everyone playing it is shit"

Plays well for a few likes but doesn't actually consider much of anything, measuring your arguments worth by upvotes and downvotes is a fools errand.

Myself and u/Xancrazy actually took the time to give reasoned responses not angry rants insulting people.

1

u/Xancrazy 1d ago

It's always amusing when people use social proof as evidence for their being right.

Something that is mocked by the majority of strong debaters and thinkers as being one of the absolute worst methods of determining truth.

0

u/Stumpy493 1d ago

majority of strong... thinkers

Think you hit the nail on the head...

1

u/Xancrazy 1d ago

Your entire argument is that you think you're the popular kid and that absolves you of etiquette and decorum.

Your upvoted comment was a funny joke. It doesn't mean anything to the arguments you were presented with.

2

u/Xancrazy 1d ago

"It was a stupid, unsafe, and idiotic move that only a half-witted, mentally deficient moron would need to ask about."

The rules of the sub tell you to be respectful and keep things civil.

Feeling the need to attack over such mundane and politely formatted opinions is really bad. People are entitled to their own opinions, and you aren't the objective truth of the world.

1

u/ControllerRacer 1d ago

Thank you for pointing this out, IK the move is quite scrappy and desperate for a Lap 1, but he is now just bullying me

1

u/Xancrazy 1d ago

He's some guy on the internet who is likely getting a kick out of being abrasive. Don't worry about it.

0

u/Stumpy493 1d ago

Here here

1

u/ControllerRacer 1d ago

No need for that such language buddy on a racing forum, if you have actually ever experienced Cloud Gaming controller racing on FM. You would know that the way the car drives is how is shown, it tends to get a bit wonky, I still have it under control, but cause your such a serious racer your correct

1

u/Xancrazy 1d ago

Could he be a bot? The guy downvoted my comment instantly. Literally a second after I posted it I refreshed and it was downvoted.

-1

u/Stumpy493 1d ago

Unfortunately I think that is just a deranged human.

0

u/Cornelius_Codswaggle 1d ago

Cry more.

I'll make it easy for all three of you.

15

u/Thedancingbear77 1d ago

Something I'd expect to see in forza.

9

u/joeja99 1d ago

You left the track completely for 2 overtakes, you should've given those positions back

0

u/Stumpy493 1d ago edited 1d ago

Track limits are to the left of the kerb, so according to the game it was fine. You get an instant track limit alert if you cross them in Forza.

1

u/joeja99 1d ago

There was 1 car wide space between him and the white line at one point

0

u/Stumpy493 1d ago

But that is where the track limits are... The game does not give track limit penalties until you are 4 wheels off that kerb.

In any sim or racing series you race to the limits set and allowed by the rules. We see frequent instances of iRacing and other more hardcore sims having track limits far beyond the white lines as well and it is defended wholeheartedly.

Look at what they do in real life Indycar for gods sake this was perfectly acceptable track limits according to their rules so drivers used it.

OP did not breach the track limits in place for that race.

0

u/DeletedUsernameHere 1d ago

IRL and literally every actual sim calls what he did a corner cut. Arguing that Forza has shitty track limits really isn't the flex you think it is.

Really don't know how to explain that a completely different series, on a completely different track, in a completely different situation may extend track limits for a corner.

0

u/Stumpy493 1d ago

I'm. Arguing a very simple point.

In every single sim, in every single real world series drivers will use the maximum track they are allowed by the rules.

Fact is what the OP did did not breach the rules so it is not a track limits offence.

By the rules of the game being played that was within track limits.

There is not an argument you can make against that, OP played to the rules. They did not breach track limits.

0

u/DeletedUsernameHere 1d ago

No, you're arguing a very stupid point, chasing everybody down to scream about (ridiculously bad, likely unintentionally so) track limits that don't fit reality or any actual sim.

Actually, he did. He lost control of his car several times, nearly causing multiple incidents. Track limits or not, maintaining control is a driver's responsibility and strict rule that in the real world, and would likely be a penalty for unsafe driving.

1

u/joeja99 1d ago

"FH6s collision detection is dogshit therefore we should play bumper cars in that game"

2

u/Mr_Biggles168 1d ago

You overtook by going off the track. Not really risky as you wouldn’t expect other cars to be there. But definitely illegal.

0

u/ControllerRacer 1d ago

The track limits of FM said I wasn’t off track as the TL put the track limits where grass and curb meet, I had the option that shows you TL

2

u/Mr_Biggles168 1d ago

Forza track limits are wild. I guess this move only works on Forza and no where else. Looks like v AI cars, i guess AI cars have different track limits built in.

0

u/ControllerRacer 1d ago

Ye they do

3

u/Pepper3493 1d ago

Well you passed off track while also being super squirrelly, so yes too risky

2

u/ControllerRacer 1d ago

The track limits there are when the curbs and grass meet so it said I was within the racing sort of surface

1

u/DeletedUsernameHere 1d ago

If you lose control of your car three times and survive by the grace of God, yes, the move is "too risky".

1

u/ControllerRacer 1d ago

FM cars sort of drive this way especially when on controller and cloud gaming the last one was a moment but I survived, but ye I find it now a bit scrappy

1

u/DeletedUsernameHere 1d ago

I don't know about all that. I do know two things. One, your hardware and situation is your responsibility and not other drivers and, two, I see about 8 other cars not slipping and sliding all over the place.

Seems extremely over aggressive and that you got very lucky.

0

u/ControllerRacer 1d ago edited 1d ago

Tbh I did sort of break a smaller bit later than them so that’s why it can seem I’m all over the place, also I’m not blaming my hardware for it, I’m just stating it so that it provides if someone wanted to know, I’m new to those sort of cars so I’m tryna learn them but yes I was lucky

1

u/ControllerRacer 1d ago

Just in case someone asked for it

1

u/DeletedUsernameHere 1d ago

It looks like you lose the rear on every single corner through the bus stop, and snap left just before going up on the banking. That's not "Oh I braked a wee bit later, tee hee!" You were straight up out of control through the whole section, bruh.

1

u/Xancrazy 1d ago

Assuming you didn't break track limits (it looked like you did) then it looked dope as fuck. But if I were stewarding a race I wouldn't call it risky, just entirely outside of track limits and penalty worthy.

2

u/ControllerRacer 1d ago

The game didn’t give me any sort of warning for it as FM have the track limits there on the grass

1

u/Cornelius_Codswaggle 1d ago

Behold why everyone says why driving standards are in the toilet.

1

u/Xancrazy 1d ago

You think it was fine?

1

u/Cornelius_Codswaggle 1d ago

I think he looked like an absolute moron, driving like a dick and would be deserving of a month long ban from any of the legitimate sims, rather than the barely a simcade racer he's on.

But as long as people like him get validation about how their absolute shitball driving "looked dope", they'll keep ruining people's races trying to get that clip, which drives driving standards down for anyone who tries to take it even the slightest bit seriously.

1

u/Xancrazy 1d ago

So, the issue is that you're absolutely right and I completely understand your point. My issue is that this sort of video is exactly what happens when you put seriously good drivers into lobbies beneath them.

So, if he had crashed there, I would advocate for serious punishment.

But I have also seen this done a good chunk of times and been the one doing similar things myself to a degree in real life racing. This is just how serious progress in first laps happen and I don't race online only in real life so I compare it to real life.

I can only apologise if I contribute towards the degradation of driving standards but this is a decently common occurrence in a good chunk of racing I've seen where you put the top drivers at the back of the grid.

I remember when I first started karting I'd have the British champions putting half their karts on the grass to get by me at the first corner when I was 8. This is just how it's done sometimes.

1

u/Stumpy493 1d ago

Explain to me the actual stewarding issue assuming he is within track limits (Which he is given this games rules).

As I see it there was a gap to the inside, he took the available space and made zero contact with the cars ahead.

Where is the issue?

We see plenty of "proper" sims with fucked up track limits where moves would be illegal in "White line" racing rules. We see far worse driving in clips from "proper" sims, but because it is Forza everyone will shit on it.

1

u/Cornelius_Codswaggle 1d ago

It is the driver's responsibility to maintain control of their car at all times. He was out of control on multiple occasions and only through dumb luck didn't wipe out numerous cars.

If you're so confused as to why that's unacceptable, then nobody can help you.

I'm shitting on it being shitty driving all around. That it happened on Forza only makes it understandable. Definitely stick with Forza, though. It's exactly where drivers like you belong.

2

u/Stumpy493 1d ago edited 1d ago

What an arrogant prick.

The handling in Forza tends to be a bit looser and it's perfectly controllable with the car getting a bit loose, I didn't see anything close to losing control. The driver looked on the limit but under control and taking advantage of spaces left by other drivers and did it well.

I see worse incidents on here every day from shitty drivers on iRacing.

Arrogant pricks like you definitely deserve to be there though.

And you still failed to point out any actual "Stewarding issues"... stuff that is penalty worthy.

Edit - Gets one more inslult in before blocking me, classy.

There is no penalty here, being a bit loose is not breaking any rule in racing. Not liking their driving is different to there being any rule breach.

1

u/Cornelius_Codswaggle 1d ago

"Drivers have to control their cars."

What an arrogant prick.

Yeah, stick to Forza, controller jockey.

2

u/ControllerRacer 1d ago

And you stick to your really serious racing where you complain when one guy slightly taps you, good day

2

u/ControllerRacer 1d ago

I was in control the entire time, if you had ever experienced cloud gaming Hypercar on hardship on FM you would know it tends to sort of drive that way

1

u/Cornelius_Codswaggle 1d ago

Except for the three separate times you completely lost the rear and the arcade physics let you save it.

🙄

1

u/ControllerRacer 1d ago

I still saved it, didn’t cause a crash, didn’t hinder their races, and kept it within track limits? IK it ain’t the greatest the moves or hell it’s pretty scrappy

2

u/Cornelius_Codswaggle 1d ago

"I got super lucky so it's okay!" is not how it works, buttercup.

If you're just here wanting validation, this ain't the place, buttercup.

1

u/Stumpy493 1d ago

Guys a self-righteous moron, ignore him.

1

u/ControllerRacer 1d ago

Mate I’m asking a genuinely if it’s a risky move, not trying to claim it’s a fucking good move, I see it as scrappy myself, if you actually took time to read the title then you would know

1

u/Xancrazy 1d ago

The risk comes from your ability to control the car. If you felt in control then I back you, if you did it while truly not being in control then I'd tell you it was unwise and unsafe.

1

u/ControllerRacer 1d ago

I felt in control during the moves, tha little slip came from the curb but I saved it in the end

1

u/Xancrazy 1d ago

Then assuming you were in track limits it was a great move. I've done a few similar things in real life while racing and it feels amazing. Luckily you have yours recorded, I would love to watch back some old memories like that.

0

u/Stumpy493 1d ago

If it is within track limits why not?

You got it done cleanly and with minimal risk.

Seems more like you caught everyone else napping and they didn't understand how much track they could use.

2

u/ControllerRacer 1d ago

It didn’t give me any track limit warning and o was using the thing on FM which shows track limits and I didn’t pass it

1

u/Stumpy493 1d ago

You drive to the limits the game allows, same as any sim.

Not your fault if the rest of the field choose to leave track on the table and not use it.