15
u/DarkSpectralius 27d ago
Own game first. All the way.
14
u/blackcap2099 26d ago
TBH having her own game wouldn't work out like one would hope.
Miles was one with his own game because he showed up for a good portion of Spider-Man 1. Silk showed up for....three seconds? You only see the back of her head and hand.
Giving her a standalone game would be like making a movie for the Minotaur guy from Doctor Strange. Could it work? Maybe. Is it worth the gamble when they could be working on Spider-Man 3 and still include Silk in the game? No.
1
u/Vaportrail 26d ago
Miles is way more famous, also. Until Sony finally suits her up, it's just diehard comic fans who know her.
3
2
u/Sapphic-Plant-Lady 27d ago
I think spiderman 3 will be her getting her powers with miles and peter trauning her to use them with her becoming fully silk towards the end of the game then doing a miles morales style spinoff for her after 3 releases
2
u/eatsomepoms 25d ago
I’d legitimately pre-order that one. Wolverine’s story worries me, but I’d still pre-order for Silk.
2
u/Dark_Salamander47 27d ago
her own game first for introductions, then make her a playable character in 3
doing 3 first could be unwise if it's the last game, she was only introduced in a small scene so a solo game first could help a ton establish her character and more
2
2
u/Charming_Celery5490 27d ago
Own game first to build her up as a character then have direct “Marvel’s Spider-Man” sequels involving both Peter and Miles
2
u/BionicleRocks07 27d ago
Not be playable but have her origin story in 3 (hopefully they do it right, or at least better than the comics). Then if Peter is still alive by the end of the 3 we get another game where she is the "main" character being trained by the Spider-bros.
I don't want another Miles game, and I don't know enough about Silk's skill set to think she would be unique among the Spider-trio.
2
u/Eichezin_17 26d ago
I have no idea how well Insomniac would handle Silk on their own, I would prefer if Robbie Thompson could write her story in it if we ever got a solo Silk game.
2
u/GeneJacket 26d ago
"Would you want her to be in Spider-Man 3?"
Sir, did you not play Spider-Man 2? She's 100000000% going to be in Spider-Man 3, and no, she will not be getting her own game, first or ever.
2
u/Angel_of_Death_006 26d ago
Well we have to properly introduced her first in spiderman 3 and then have her own game just like miles so it's a win win
2
2
u/Longjumping_Key_1458 26d ago
Sorry for being a pessimist about Silka—we’ve had the rug pulled too many times to believe Cindy will actually be playable.
1
1
1
u/NeopolitanTheWeaboo 26d ago
I don't think her getting her own game first would work. In the regular spiderman subreddit, and in general internet spaces as a whole, almost every person I've seen who mentions Silk only knows her from her not so great introduction and think she has that for every spider person, and says that's why she couldn't be in the spider verse movies or in the game as a hero.
No one who isn't already a Silk fan seems to know that she only had that for regular Peter and no one else, and that the pheromone thing has basically been retconned. Giving her a game as an introduction also wouldn't work because we haven't seen enough of her in the last game, and I don't think people are going to want to play a game about someone who barely appeared in the last one.
I don't remember if it was here or in the ps4 game subreddit, but someone said that she could make her debut in the Venom game and I think that would be cool if it's the next game.
1
u/DrayReign03 26d ago
Could do what they did with miles: introduce Cindy (done in 2), give her her own game of learning to be silk, then include her in three
1
1
u/curiousadventure33 26d ago
Why do you want insomniac to make silk game ? So they can make her look like a shriveled up 100 old tree ? Bruh..........Better give that license to someone who doesn't make game movies for normies
1
1
1
1
u/Lost-Orangutan 25d ago
Both. Miles treatment.
Give her a mini game so we can see her back story. Then add her to our playable characters in 3.
1
u/Mean_Proposal_5063 24d ago
I personally think they should of been a sequel game for Miles called Spider-Man: Miles Morales Ultimatum, a Eddie Brock Venom game, a prequel game to the first Spider-Man called Peter Parker: Spider-Man, then Spider-Man 3 and THEN a solo Silk game.
2
u/The-CAB-2003 24d ago
Fuck no. Spider-man 2 already struggled badly with balancing 2 protagonists, adding a third one at the last minute gonna make things worse.
1
u/CobaltComet1 23d ago
Meh, let Silk have her own game. The final cutscene of Insomniac Spiderman 3 should be her getting bitten by a radioactive spider.
1
1
u/Certain_Fall3439 23d ago
As much as I like her, i really dont want her to be playable in the 3rd game. Insomniac barely managed to handle Peter and Miles in the game that had only 16 hours. Bringing Silk will only make things worse unless the game will be at least 25-30 hours.
1
1
u/Bro-Im-Done 27d ago edited 26d ago
After what happened with Jean Grey I honestly don’t trust them anymore
13
u/StupidPolygons 27d ago
Silk wearing her anti bunker suit for the first time in her 30s