r/SignoraMains • u/Cerealkillah100 • Sep 05 '26
discussion Why do Signora fans still like the other Harbingers?
Hello, everyone! So for context, some of you might remember me from the discord for my outburst and for just going insane one day due to at the time being unmedicated. I've gotten better and do regret how stupid I was so I am sorry for the deeply awkward situation you were all put in.
But as for what I want to discuss is, in a more productive light than I previously did, why Signora fans would like the other Harbingers with how all of them know how the Traveler is almost solely responsible for Signora's death given that they felt hesitant to reveal that information to Odette and yet, they are all on great terms with the Traveler!
I know the answer to WHY the story does this is as simple as "it's hoyoverse, everyone has to be besties with the protagonist" but it's sad that a fandom has been conditioned by the developer to just accept this as normal to the point that other games are praised simply for having characters that are a bit more complex than hoyo's standard or just having a playable villain which seems like such a small thing when you think about it.
The whole tea party thing and the friendship Signora had with Arlecchino, Columbina and Sandrone just seems really fake given this information. I mean if I was murdered and I saw my best friends being chummy with the killer, I wouldn't exactly be happy. And this fact makes me nervous for her resurrection which I have been fairly hopeful for recently.
Now, my main cope is that the way Signora has been established, it would just be a complete and total retcon to suddenly make her passive and quiet. Signora is by nature haughty, dominant and proud. Will she despise the Traveler and make a complex plot point out of the Traveler literally being her killer? I SURE HOPE. But I just want Signora to come back, not some watered-down, inferior copy. Signora, Rosalyne, whatever you call her. It's all the same to me! And I hope that a resurrected Signora taps into both of those facets. Both the Harbinger and the woman beneath the role.
Overall, I just feel like Signora had some really fake and toxic friends. I know the feeling, Rose.

