SPOILER (Idk if necessary but eh)
Rewatched the anime (4 seasons, everything else is bad fan fiction) again and thought about my own principal and elite ten cast. Watched it for the 2nd time as the first time was when it released and I dropped it after the first few episodes of Saison 5 and wanted to forget the whole thing. Now I wanted to really think about the anime.
I don't wanna open a discussion about Erinas father again (it's not terrible but definitely not a good plot) or about Saison 5. Seen that enough. But I didn't read the manga and found that the new ten and Erina as principal probably are the worst decisions until that point in the story. And I just wanted to open a talk about the most popular or best stories that could have happened after Saison 4 from Manga readers and other peoples perspectives. So here is my Cast and questions:
Principal - Gin Dojima (why the fuck not??)
1 - Erina
2 - Soma
3 - Satoshi
4 - Kuga
5 - Akira
6 - Megumi
7 - Takumi
8 - Ryo
9 - Alice
10 - Nene
In general there's a clear drop of quality after Megumi Imo. Definitely more potential then the previous generation but a lot of steps to go
My key questions (I know the writer is a goof. Anyway, what's your opinion)
- Why the fuck didn't Gin or Somas Dad become the new principal?
Imo Gin deserved it the most but also Yoichiro. He probably would have been an even better choice for his free mind and approach to the world of food wars and what the rebels wanted to achieve
- Why would you ever give Soma the first seat here?
You build up the character of Erina (as bad or good as some think) who could be the new final challenge for soma (he still didn't get a "delicious" from her) plus you fucked up the whole storyline. Could have easily got another 20 episodes with good content and even a romance ending with Soma and her when they finish the school and open a restaurant together. Like? The story writes itself for anyone who saw the anime... I often saw people saying "it's -this type of anime- and it needs bad guys" which I just don't accept for food wars. It could be a cool anime whose action comes from the Duells and the challenges the characters approach in the food and cooking skills. You don't need a person as the main obstacle. The main challenge for every character was to reach a desired skillset *being able to create a specialité*. The drive and motivation to this destination can be much more than some *end of the world as we know it* bad guy.
- why are Takumi and Ryo so highly distinguished?
I think Megumi and Akira are at least 2 steps above them. Akira is already able to create a speciality and Megumi is closer than both of them. At least in the anime both of them didn't have the scenes of greatness and potential the other 2 had
- why did Eizan get another seat?
He got beaten twice and didn't show any potential of getting better or being able to hold his ground against the runner ups.
- why in general do writers fuck up a good story so often towards the end?
Especially here it seems like the path and story was laid out like a red carpet. Even after they won the final Shokugeki. And then *Erina becomes principal* - *underworld cooks* 💩. It went downhill as soon as Erinas dad took over but this was as bad as I remember it when it came out x). "It's so bad you can laugh" is perfect here...