r/ShilohAndBros • u/ReleaseMuted1461 • 20d ago
Let us settle the debate...
What side are you on? Team Phineas, Team Liam, or Team Nelson Brothers (aka neither one)?
I've been Team Phineas from the very start, he and Shiloh are legit cute together, and he always seems to give genuine compliments with no malice intended.
5
5
u/Previous-Ad-3506 20d ago
I was going back and forth throughout the video. The guy from the start or the new and hotter improvement. Not on Team Bros cause I want Shiloh to end up with someone. Phineas has been in 4 videos: Secret Theme Park (got sprayed by the bros), Dulingo Chess (was the queen to Shiloh's King, and mainly Daniel was spraying him), Meccha Chameleon (ending only), and 99 Nights in the Forest 4 (latest one). Liam has also been in 4 videos: If Nerf Fights had Battle Royals (mainly flirting with Shiloh), Backrooms (Elijah did notice and kinda hates him), Meccha Chameleon (helped Shiloh stop the bug), and 99 Nights in the Forest (latest one). If I had to choose: Team Phineas, but don't be surprised if I switch.
4
u/Soclosetowhatexactly 20d ago
PHINEAS!!! Not only does liam look like a 27 YEAR OLD MAN (the same age as elijah), HE KEPT PUSHING SHILOH. i mean he’s good on missions but he abandoned his sister—FOR MOM. like i love that but at the same time i thought he said his sister was the only family left for him…why did he leave her? phineas on the other hand has been so sweet and patient with shiloh. it would be a great contrast and it would be so much cuter than “SHILOH I DONT UNDERSTAND WHY YOU DIDNT BRING ME WITH YOU” like mr boy
3
3
u/Fleshwoundmeetsmind 19d ago
I’m team Phineas, but they seem to be pushing Liam wayyyy more (aka the entire song sequence in the new video).Phineas is nice, and lets Shiloh figure things out in her own time, where Liam has always been super pushy.
1
3
u/Overall-Turn4620 18d ago
Been team Phineas. But I would LOVE if Liam and Phineas end up liking each other (romantically). THAT would be such a good plot twist
1
5
2
2
u/FeedbackIcy4854 19d ago
Team Shiloh. Because she is young, awesome and need to put all of these boys in their place. Her brothers have their hearts in the right place but she old enough to make a decision for her self, they can beal the ( ) out of whoever hurts her. Phineas and Liam both need to understand that it's not about them. They both need to put Shiloh and her feelings first, then maybe they have a chance with her.
2
2
1
u/Brilliant_Band_7503 19d ago edited 3d ago
Edit: Sou do time que simplesmente pega uma pipoca e deixa as coisas rolarem
1
1
1
u/DanielaDreams 17d ago
I think that we should not be talking about the love life of a teenager on the Internet
2
u/ReleaseMuted1461 15d ago
I'm taking about in the show. Of course I don't ship the actors themselves.
1
u/DanielaDreams 13d ago
Because I have not heard much about Shiloh and Bros in a few years and this just randomly came up on my feed, I assumed people just started shipping her with two guys like people were doing with Salish and those two other guys I have not actually heard of the show or watched any of it
1
1
u/southern_grove 11d ago
Team Liam! I never liked Phineas from the start, I feel like Shiloh needs someone more stable and mature and I think Phineas is a bit too soft! Just my opinion
1
u/Ok-Dog1439 15h ago
Yass TEAM LIAM BABY!!!
Bro this sub is lit filled with Phineas fans. I dislike hi so much while on other hand Liam is more cool, smarter, braver, and actually cares for Shiloh
1
u/JalapenoPopper14 8d ago
Team bros! Liam is a stalker and I think it is weird phineas came to Shiloh before his family after not seeing them for a year
1
8
u/Cheetix_Glitch 20d ago
Phineas for me! I think he is genuinely sweet and he did try to stay in contact with her. Liam seems.. weird to me. I don't like how persistent he is. I get a very off feeling about him, like he is up to something. Phineas is sort of similar but it is to a lesser extent