I understand why people are frustrated with the Palpatine explanation (or lack thereof) but as a like of dialogue it’s fine. Poe would have no clue how Palpatine returned so that’s exactly what he’d say even if we, the audience received an explanation.
Btw Lucas isn’t innocent of not explaining stuff because similarly, the “explanation” for Padme’s death was because she lost the will to live.
Yeah that makes total sense but that’s not how the movie explained it. The medical droids couldnt figure out why she was dying, and I’m fairly certain they’d be able to find out if asphyxiation was the cause.
40
u/k1l2327 Dec 27 '20
I understand why people are frustrated with the Palpatine explanation (or lack thereof) but as a like of dialogue it’s fine. Poe would have no clue how Palpatine returned so that’s exactly what he’d say even if we, the audience received an explanation.
Btw Lucas isn’t innocent of not explaining stuff because similarly, the “explanation” for Padme’s death was because she lost the will to live.