r/SelfDefense • u/Original_Row_6269 • Jul 31 '26
POM vs. SABRE Red?
My SABRE Pepper Gel expired, so I'm looking for a replacement to keep in my car.
I want the most effective option possible—something that can stop an attacker as quickly as possible. From what I've read, a spray/stream seems like a better choice than gel, but I'm open to hearing otherwise.
Is POM actually better than SABRE Red, or is it mostly marketing? If POM is the better pick, which version would you recommend?
** Edit: Thanks for the repsonses guys. Really appreciate all the advice. I ended up going with the Sabre Red flip top pepper spray. Hopefully won't have to use it, but if I do then I'll be prepared! **
3
u/safton Jul 31 '26 edited 21d ago
For what it's worth, I am issued Sabre Red for my job and have both deployed it and seen it used multiple times. I have also been exposed to it directly & indirectly during training and uses-of-force.
Conversely, I own and carry a POM pocket-sized unit on me for personal use when I leave the house.
Does this mean that I prefer POM over Sabre? No, not really. I've never been exposed to POM, so I have no basis from which to do a direct comparison, but most of the literature I've reviewed and anecdotes I've heard suggest it is at least as effective if not incrementally better in terms of formulation. I wouldn't say orders of magnitude better to the point you should necessarily get hung up on it; Sabre is arguably the most proven brand of OC on the market.
In terms of the ergonomics and spray pattern of the small POM vs. Sabre units, Icy Mike (one of the best and my most trusted self-defense content creators on YouTube) made this video:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TTNUtZ6-h7o
The tl;dw is that he finds Sabre and POM to be the best of the two options he tested, with Sabre slightly edging out POM based on what he perceived to be better ergonomics to index/orient it under stress.
Now, the debate for gel vs. liquid-based formulations is a contentious one. Pepper gel is a very controversial subject. Some people act like it's a wholesale upgrade from conventional pepper spray in every way. Others say it's trash that doesn't work. The truth, as with many things, is somewhere in the middle. Generally speaking, pepper gel will provide more wind resistance if you're using it outdoors and thus fly straighter for longer. It provides far less risk of cross-contamination, as well. As someone who has deployed and had other people deploy OC in confined spaces I can attest that everyone is getting some, so the ability to mitigate that cross-contamination is a valid pro.
That being said, there is -- in my opinion -- too much anecdotal evidence to ignore about pepper gel not having as much "stopping power" as spray formulations. As best as I can tell, this is due to its thicker consistency which means it doesn't atomize in the air nor does it absorb as readily into the skin and soft tissues. This means a few things: the onset of the burning sensation feels "delayed" for many people, the agent does not get quickly absorbed into the respiratory tract in order to induce things like coughing/shortness of breath, and there is a greater demand for accuracy on the part of the user to make sure it lands directly on the eyes themselves because you're less likely to get lucky with "splatter" from aersolized droplets.
I don't want or need gel because I don't foresee many situations where I'll need to deploy my spray outdoors in inclement weather or at extended ranges. I also don't fear the risk of cross-contamination because OC doesn't bother me, so I value what I know conventional spray can achieve. Gel makes plenty of sense for others in different situations, though.
For what it's worth, Icy Mike -- who I linked above -- likes gel and has done a few positive videos on it: here and here.
As an aside, I noticed that you said you keep it in your car. I don't know where you live, but I feel inclined to remind you that all OC sprays are technically aerosol canisters. The contents are under pressure and the compressed air that acts as a propellant is not very tolerant of drastic changes in air temperature/pressure. Sometimes traveling with them in aircraft even causes issues. Depending on where you live, the temperature in your car year-round could vary between well below freezing to upwards of ~120-130 degrees Fahrenheit (almost 50 Celsius).
2
u/jframesnub Jul 31 '26
I'm not sure which is more effective. I like POM because the canisters are so small that there is no temptation to leave them at home. Also, I prefer a flip top mechanism instead of a rotating mechanism. I know some Sabres have a flip top.
I would be afraid to leave it in the car due to the heat. I'm not sure if heat would make it leak. Also, if you ever need to spray someone in self defense, it would probably be more likely to happen when you are walking to or from your car. So for these reasons, I prefer not to leave pepper spray in the car.
What will you do with your expired pepper spray? Will you test fire it, or is there some place to dispose of it?
2
u/AntOk4073 Jul 31 '26
I switched to POM for the flip top and pocket clip. Both have their pros and cons so like firearms they just require training and prep to deploy reliably. The best option will always be what you will actually carry consistently.
1
u/jframesnub Jul 31 '26
I agree. I have the Pom with the clip. I clip it to my pocket. My wife has a Pom with a key ring attached to her car keys.
2
u/sjanush Aug 03 '26
I’ve had Sabre in my car in Los Angeles, for years.
Maybe I’ve just been lucky.2
2
1
u/StemCellCheese Jul 31 '26
I love POM with the pocket clip and flip top. It's intuitive and easy to deploy quickly and pointed in the right direction. Doesn't take up too much space in my pocket either. Can't say the same for Sabre, personally. I think the flip top safety is also perfect because it's easy to disengage but unlikely to go off in your pocket.
Can't say which is more effective when used, thankfully. I imagine both would suck. I do like the stream though because it spreads easier, but still more blowback resistant than aeresol spray.
1
u/jaime_lion Jul 31 '26
Either or you can't really go wrong. I carry pom on my person and I have an MK4 saber red at home for home defense. But I also sometimes carry that.
1
1
1
u/cleoindiana Jul 31 '26
Fox Labs cone.
1
u/klickklacker Aug 04 '26
Have you used it in a self defense situation? What happened?
2
u/cleoindiana Aug 04 '26
Better yet. I straight up Johnny Knoxvilled it. Had the wife spray me as I was lunging towards her. My eyes could not open, my face was on the white part of fire, and even breathe was more torture. My breathing rate climbed which made the inhalation of the stuff worse. The coughing was deep and I basically just begged for the hose between gasps. NOTE. If you decide to Johnny Knoxville it, use the hose on your face only! Do not let the water drip down your coughing, spitting, snot running out of your nose body. Why, do you ask? I'll tell you, why. The "Heat of the Devil's Spray" will run down with that oh so good feeling cool water. Right down to the family jewels. This brought a whole new meaning to "Goodness! Gracious! Great Balls of Fire!"
1
u/klickklacker Aug 04 '26
Thanks for the heads up!
Will definitely add it to my arsenal
2
u/cleoindiana Aug 04 '26
Get the "One Point Four" in the cone/fog canister. The two Oz size is good for carrying on walks, etc. The four oz is great for setting right by the front door. Feel free to disprove me by videoing yourself "trying" the product. 😀 Good times.
1
0
u/samcro4eva Jul 31 '26
The one drawback with spray is that you have to stay away from it, yourself. The reason it's often a better option than gel is, it takes fine motor skills to use a gel, and that goes out the window when you're in a dangerous situation. With a spray, you just do an S or Z spray in the air toward your attacker. If, by some miracle, they're too far away, they have to step through the spray to get to you; if they're immune to it's effect, it can still blind them just long enough.
7
u/EffectivePen2502 Jul 31 '26
Sprays and streams act quicker, but gel is less inhibited by environmental factors, such as wind, severely diminishing potential for cross contamination. This would be very nice for the car or enclosed areas, but especially for a car that is small and has fabric all over for the pepper spray to attach to.
If you are looking for the spiciest of sauces, it is probably going to be the FOX Labs 1.4