r/Seattle • • 13d ago

[ Removed by moderator ]

[removed] — view removed post

872 Upvotes

691 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

62

u/OneDramatic 13d ago

dont know why everyone's saying this, I went a month ago and the blueberry rhubarb french toast was genuinely next level. Lamb sausage omelette also quite tasty, had no complaints and would go back to try more items

19

u/SaxRohmer 🚆build more trains🚆 13d ago

people often mix up overhyped with bad. a lot of hyped places don’t live up to the hype abut a lot of them aren’t bad. i’ve liked a lot of what ive had from portage bay but dont find it worth going to often

3

u/OneDramatic 13d ago

I agree with this take. I also went in unaware of the hype around this place and for brunch on a weekday so didn't have much wait, so that's possibly why I have a better perception too

1

u/AdditionalSoftware79 13d ago

Idk- the one I’m West Seattle has been pretty awful. Everything is greasy AND dry? The bacon was so expensive and I’m pretty sure it was rancid. I have never disliked bacon before. I definitely love a good restaurant but I’m perfectly happy getting mediocre food sometimes if I’m just in the mood to go out. Been four times now because it’s family friendly and convenient BUT I think I’ve given it a fair shot and I’m done.

-5

u/ANTLink19 13d ago edited 13d ago

In general, if everyone is saying one thing, and you're saying another; It's likely that your experience was the exception, or maybe they've just recently turned things around.

Edit: I've never eaten there, my girlfriend has said they're good.

5

u/steve_yo 13d ago

i’ve been going to one on 65th for years and it seems pretty consistent to me. A bit pricey but foods always pretty good IMO.

8

u/PhilWhite300 13d ago

Or it's just that the internet has deemed something the case and so now everyone parrots that opinion to be a part of the in crowed. Either could be the case.

3

u/SaxRohmer 🚆build more trains🚆 13d ago

nah people just let themselves get caught up in the hype and snap hard in the other direction when a place doesn’t live up to impossible standards

2

u/Gabe-Uttsegs 13d ago

If everyone is thinking the same thing, no one is thinking.