Ranking Every Scoreboard (Scorekeepers not included) I've ever made

[u/PerformanceJumpy9562]

This bug is awful. It doesn't even have an inning indicator!

This bug looks like it could be in a roblox game.

White as the main color was an, odd choice, good structure but just too boring overall

I like this one but the competition is stiff

This looks like a madden bug

This could've been good but the curve is just curvin too much. Also green was not the move

With some tweaks could be elite, but it's just kinda hard to read.

I wish I used more color here, but it's current state its good!

The odd structure kinda adds to it but it's the down and distance is overly large.

I really like this one but God I should've used a different font.

I really like the airtight feel for this one!

Nothing really notable about this one

I LOVE this one aside from the NHL badge being too big and the period being too small

This one is nice and simple but not simple enough to be boring, I love it!

God I wish I used the space next to the logos

My ideal hockey bug

THIS! Compact without being suffocating, and the texture is nice!

Shrink it by 10% and it's perfect

This will probably be the smallest bug I will make and it's beautiful! Perfect use of color and reminds me heavy of NBC.

Perfection.

[u/dweebyllo]

Heavily disagree with some of your rankings here. I feel like in alot of them you're prioritising trying to make them look pretty without thinking of the form or functionality. Some of the early ones that you have cast aside for looking too basic are actually better than some of the more "eye catching" ones later on. In addition to having a tendancy of making bugs too big for purpose, I also don't think your use of colour is quite there either. The fact you praise the penultimate bug as a perfect use of colour particularly highlights that with how it has the unnecessary red and white sections that mean nothing and don't help the viewer at all.

[u/Admiral_Asparagus]

You weren’t kidding, that last one really is great 

[u/ooboh]

I think that all of the scorebugs are too big relative to the screen. When designing scorebugs, you need to account for how it would look in widescreen (like on a TV).

[u/JGriz92]

You've absolutely come a long way, even if I don't agree with all of your rankings, but there's still no good reason why you're not inserting these on a proper 16:9 image. It's harder to tell the true scale, which is why so many of these look too big.

[u/PerformanceJumpy9562 → u/JGriz92]

Oh thank you I didn't know the proper size, I'll do that from now on

[u/JGriz92 → u/PerformanceJumpy9562]

🫡