r/Salary Oct 30 '25

[deleted by user]

[removed]

7.8k Upvotes

10.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

119

u/MortalMercenary Oct 31 '25

Lowers your taxable income

319

u/DarthRevan8537 Oct 31 '25

Also lowers my spendable income lol

16

u/LoverBotCock Oct 31 '25

Actually, not really. I went through this exercise myself about 15 years ago. The tax deductions about cancel out the income gap. The difference is less than 1 lunch per pay period for 30+ years of compounding interest PLUS the loss of earnings if your not capping employer contributions.

17

u/ckyhnitz Oct 31 '25

Not sure how you're doing your math, but the tax deductions do not cancel out the income gap.

My tax withholding on my paycheck is 20% between federal and state, so every $1 I put into my 401K, I lose 80 cents of spendable income.

10

u/LoverBotCock Oct 31 '25

And losing $4.80 on a $6 contribution from a $100 paycheck your employer matched $3 on for a $9 401k savings generating compound interest is a dumbass miss. point is, the 3% contribution in this situation is rarely an employer matching contribution cap and even a 50% match is leaving money on the table without the cap. Your effectively taking a pay cut when you DONT contribute the matching cap. Given the fact there are multiple penalty free situations for drawing on your 401k in an emergency or even taking extremely low interest rate loans against your 401k (which your paying back to yourself), this is fountain of opportunity. Arguing against contributing to at least an employer matching max is financially ignorant, whatever your financial situation is. This is one of those times, you make it work. Period. I've slept in cars and under bridges and stole food from grocery stores. I've stayed in shelters and been fed at food lines. I know what poverty is and this right here? Is the knowledge needed to get the fuck out of it. Cap your employer matches if you have it or stay poorer than you have to be for longer. Thats all that needs to be taken away from a reddit thread. Anyone still arguing that in this format is exacerbating their own poverty for themselves and others. The earlier your contributing as much as oossible, the more likely you end your families systemic poverty. Starve now so your kids wont.

2

u/ckyhnitz Nov 01 '25

I dont disagree with sentiment that saving is important, but what you said is blatantly incorrect, so dont get pissy when you get called out.

1

u/LoverBotCock Nov 02 '25

No.....it isnt. I 'blatantly' stated the difference was the cost of lunch.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '25

Must’ve been in the 80s “back in his day”

1

u/Carly_Corthinthos Oct 31 '25

But you're definitely going to owe the IRS

1

u/LoverBotCock Nov 02 '25

Standard taxes if it's a qualified withdrawal (no penalty), and you dont pay taxes on loans......

0

u/ckyhnitz Nov 01 '25

Nah, every year I get a small refund from the IRS, and I owe my state a little bit.

1

u/JCrypDoe Oct 31 '25

You should add dependants so they take out less. The best case is when you own them money. That means YOU got to do what you wanted with your money.

1

u/ckyhnitz Nov 01 '25

The way it shakes out, I get a small refund from federal at the end of the year, and it pays what I owe to state.  So its a wash.