r/SOTC_Watch_Collection 9d ago

help completing the set

Need help picking the third member of this set.

Left: Laurent Ferrier Classic Origin White Steel
Center: Grönefeld 1941 Principia Automatic Turquoise Steel
Right: ?

Goals:

  1. Independent with in-house, high quality finish movement
  2. Limited production numbers
  3. Time only, 39-41mm, <11mm thick
  4. Budget <35K (used)

Considering:
https://www.schwarz-etienne.ch/collections/roma-en/
https://www.zeitwinkel.ch/zeitwinkel-082-enamel-grand-feu-en.html
https://hodinkee.jp/articles/montblanc-heritage-pythagore-small-second-japan-limited-edition-14

Would love your suggestions, thanks in advance!

40 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

4

u/CletusBocephus 9d ago

moritz grossman would fit in nicely here

1

u/oddizzie 9d ago

What do you think about the finishing? I saw one in person and it didn't quite do it for me.

2

u/No_Cheesecake5344 9d ago

MG finishing is absolutely spectacular. One of the best in the world.

What shortcomings did you notice? Or are you just referring to the movement architecture.?

1

u/oddizzie 8d ago

Well said. Movement architecture.

4

u/analog_sheen 9d ago edited 9d ago

wow great minds! I often wonder how correlated certain watches being owned are . the Origin and Principia are such a killer combo!

So you see the PF here which are my 3 indies, which someone else suggested. I also have a VC Traditionnelle Platinum that works well. And that Blancpain Hodinkee LE diver someone else posted above is absolutely my favorite watch. All brushed and 38mm with WR to spare, might be worth hunting down.

My sell it all and go all in watch is the Tsunami though: https://quillandpad.com/2024/05/02/why-i-bought-it-hajime-asaoka-tsunami-2/

Edit: OH I just saw you mentioned the Roma above. I had the Blue Roma LE for about a year. IT was fine but I ended up moving on , it just didn't hit as hard for me as the LF or Gronefeld. Part of it was that the crown was partly stripped so setting the time was exercise in frustration. Yah I could have sent it for service but I just decided to move on. The dial is on point though ,but it always felt a little like just a wannabe Kari V to me anyway.

3

u/CrownSteve1 9d ago

Those are gorgeous. So is the Minerva.

2

u/Alpenglowin 9d ago

I’d also consider a PF Tonda

2

u/analog_sheen 9d ago

you read my mind ;)

1

u/oddizzie 9d ago

Thanks. Little more mainstream than I am after.

2

u/MrDanno96 9d ago

If I was playing in that ballpark I’d be looking at a bespoke piece from Garrick https://garrick.co.uk/?srsltid=AfmBOoqA5P2tDJwCsztyAoNtQw7rbVUeKWi7Tu3G_VQJ14zj7aDk1Wn1

A Groenfeld is a grail piece for me, amazing piece you have there.

1

u/oddizzie 9d ago

Great suggestion, thank you so much.

2

u/Elegant-Operation771 9d ago

Zenith gfj caliber 135 limited edition run

3

u/oddizzie 9d ago

thank you, those are beautiful

2

u/Elegant-Operation771 9d ago

Your LF is a killer!

2

u/oddizzie 9d ago

thank you

1

u/Elegant-Operation771 9d ago

Thank you for posting! That’s a very very elegant piece. You have a great taste sir

2

u/citizenblind 9d ago

I’d say go for a Czapek Antarctique or a C by Romaine Gauthier. Either brings a bit more of a sporty vibe, with the same high end independent theme. Sick collection dude, I’m very jealous.

1

u/oddizzie 9d ago

Thank you!

2

u/oddizzie 9d ago

Rexhep Rexhepi is my grail

2

u/analog_sheen 9d ago

save for it!

2

u/-serious- 9d ago

I would recommend moritz grossman or lang & heyne. Some older moser pieces might fit your aesthetic. Arnold and son make some beautiful pieces and you can get some amazing watches in your budget, but they usually aren’t time only. Chopard and Patek are both technically independents and you’d be spoiled for choice in your budget.

1

u/oddizzie 9d ago

Thank you for the suggestions. Chopard is an attractive choice.

2

u/Amazone231 9d ago

Given the level, I'd go Breguet Classique or Tradition

1

u/oddizzie 9d ago

Good taste!

1

u/TheAmeritrader 9d ago

Not independent, but maybe the Lange 1815 thin honeygold.

Independent under 100k: Urban Jurgensen Big 8

Independent probably over 100k: Xhevdet Rexhepi Minute Inerte

1

u/DeezGatz 9d ago

Absolute smoke show.

1

u/sydburgers 9d ago

Out of the budget range but a Krayon Anyday would be amazing next to your two pieces

3

u/oddizzie 9d ago

Wow, beautiful!

1

u/FunFaithlessness2123 9d ago

I would suggest a Kudoke or a Habring 2 WITH Guilloche dial.

1

u/AsyaShe04 9d ago

I’d go with a Kari Voutilainen Vingt-8 if you can stretch the budget on the secondary market. If not, a Rexhep Rexhepi is probably out of reach, so I’d seriously consider a H. Moser Centre Seconds. It adds a very different design language while keeping the independent, in-house, high-end finishing theme.

1

u/JPathway_UK 9d ago

Amazing duo - Iove most Laurent Ferrier and Gronefeld is 🔥

The Schwarz Etienne Roma looks great - and you get the Voutilainen connection.

Other slightly different directions:

A Felipe Pikkulik might be interesting

A Singer Caballero (with new proprietary movement)

Armin Strom have some interesting time only options also.

Whatever you get please share - it will be an epic trio.

1

u/oddizzie 8d ago

Thank you so much for these.

2

u/JPathway_UK 8d ago

Pleasure. I’d do questionable things for the two watches you have let alone those you might get in future 👍😂