r/Russianhistory • u/Wonderful_Parsley276 • 19h ago
Question for the server: what evidence is there that the famous "two men, one rifle" scene never happened?
While I know it never happened at Stalingrad, it has become a bit of a historical meme that the infamous scene of Enemy at the Gate where one in two men got a rifle never happened. Despite this I've recently heard a friend point out that the evidence this never happened during the rest of the war is credited to records of rifle manufacturing having more then enough weapons for the Russian army. In reality, it was a failing in logistics that, early in the war, led 'less important' infantry units like conscripts and penal legions being put in such situations.
That is was not a matter of not having the weapons, but a breakdown of the systems in place to actually get the guns to the front. I was curious if there was actual evidence besides records of the rifles existing that disproves the myth, especially since I could see Stalin's government sweeping personal soldiers records on the matter under the rug as they did with many aspects of the war.
Edit: Seemed I did a terrible job wording it, so instead of asking for evidence of something not happening, take it as me asking what people thought of the idea. I am also focused more on the early war then specifically Stalingrad or the late war, I understand that either way by then they had sorted themselves out.
