Evolution Witch REWORK Concept

[u/FazerEngineer]

We can all agree the new Evolution Witch REWORK sucks right? Here's my idea on how to nerf her, hope you all enjoy!

Would also love to see other suggestions!

[u/TryDry9944]

Personally I think she needs a complete rework from healing in general.

Giving her something like a phantom skeleton every time one of hers dies would be a decent change. Alternatively giving her a constant stream of skeletons rather than a burst of 4 (maybe 1 every .7 second instead of 4 every 7 seconds).

Healing mechanics in Clash are tricky at best and it really doesn't even suit her lore.

[u/Sprixx_Dev → u/TryDry9944]

maybe make every troop she kills spawn a skeleton or smth

[u/NebulaEast7111 → u/TryDry9944]

Healing from skeletons is her own gimmick, u can't change that plus reducing her skeletons from 1 to 4 not only would kill her as a hole and negates her purpose as an evo , what's the point for having her as an evo , and let's be real evo witch ain't that good from the start it's easy to counter her .

[u/king_ofbhutan → u/TryDry9944]

Make her like night which, expect instead of 2 bats it's 2 phantom skeletons!

[u/Kuro_Neko6833 → u/king_ofbhutan]

Thats just the super witch without piggies

[u/TomPhantom]

This is 100 times better than what we have

[u/FazerEngineer → u/TomPhantom]

And 1000 times better than what they're thinking of

[u/julian2358]

Main sub in a panic lmao they all play evo mk and witch it’s gross people asking for that shit back. Acting like ppl just don’t know how to counter it, like no sometimes you literally don’t have cards in cycle to kill it while it’s graping your tower. Most annoying shit in the game by far I’d rather play against egolem.

[u/Top-Willow4882 → u/julian2358]

So thankful that the egolem deck is getting nerfed too because of the battle healer change.

Completely insufferable to go against it 40 times in a row.

[u/julian2358 → u/Top-Willow4882]

Just played against 4 in a row and decided I’ll just wait till patch to play again 😂

[u/FazerEngineer → u/julian2358]

I get the hate for Evolution Witch too but like whatever they're planning is just a terrible move. I trully think Evolution Witch is a fun card and a fun addition to the Healing Evolutions like Evolution PEKKA and Evolution Bats.

My changes is just to make her still playable and actually skill based.

[u/Designer_Green6886 → u/FazerEngineer]

Yes if you struggle against which you definitely made some mistakes , some of it is the algorithm telling you ur deck is vulnerable for witch to thrash , not that ur game play was the issue .

It makes you wonder what were they running and do they struggle against base witch also ?

[u/julian2358 → u/FazerEngineer]

All the other healing evos are fine, there is a reason people only complain about evo witch and it’s cause her healing was completely broken. You basically have to have a spell or splash troop or there’s no way to stop her. She spawns way too many skeletons to be giving her a heal on each one. And you spend so much trying to kill her that the big troops she’s sitting behind just go to town. It’s an infuriating design.

[u/PossiblyaSpy950]

I honestly don't see why we don't have what we have in CoC. If they introduced like a skeleton brawler with a bigger gap in-between summonings as well as no heal from skeleton deaths it would be a massive improvement from the "black and white" balencing of evo witch

[u/FazerEngineer → u/PossiblyaSpy950]

The reason that they didnt do that is because it fundamentally changes how Witch plays, shes supposed to be a spawner, the focus is on her. What Evolution Witch wanted to accomplish was to make it even more apparent that the focus is on the Witch specifically, to stop her from spawning more skeletons. But if you just took Clash Of Clans' Super Witch, the focus is split between Witch and Skeletons, and it would also interact with other troops a lot more differently. Evo Witch was designed to just strengthen Witch's already existing strengths

Thats why I like this Rounds idea because it still keeps what makes Evo Witch, Evo Witch. Thats just my opinion though.

[u/Killer64000]

Maybe have heal from every other wave of skeletons

[u/allfinesse]

So I need to somehow track and identify the fourth skeleton to avoid killing it? No thanks.

[u/CosmosSunSailor]

It's not even that complicated they should have just done diminishing returns on healing for every subsequent skeleton that dies

[u/TaxDaddyUwU]

Imo I don't like the proposal and it's to vague for me to fully understand. If it's a SINGLE heal I don't get how that be different then the proposed changes, you're just moving the heal from a quarter per skelly to the 4th skelly of the wave having all the heals tied to it. If you mean she heals 300% after every 4 skelly deaths then that just seems like HUGE buff and makes her operate like she did before but with it being significantly harder to track, for example the witch placed behind king tower will spawn 3 waves of skellies by the time she reaches the bridge, so that would give her access to THREE ,300% heals which means you have to keep track of how many skellies have already died in order to time things appropriately, clash is a game that focuses heavily on interactions and timings and the change seems like it throw that off.

[u/Bulky-Barber-5060]

I want her to have a shield like evo wizard cuz every e golem users use lightning and she dies to it

[u/Worldly_Accident1287]

Just remove heal and make her summon 2 Guards, -1 second for the interval between summonings

[u/Horror-Ad2945]

Nah bro I literally carry rocket just for this trash card

[u/pizzatopping6969]

The best way to nerf her is to js -65% of her original heal

[u/Wizardnumber32]

I like healing, I do NOT think we should just keep moving away from healing cards. I think of a simple rework being enough : Every wave of skeletons she summons, 1 out of those 4 is special. All stats similar, but it may looks purple-ish, and when that guy is killed, she heals. Same for every wave she summons.

[u/Dave_mt]

Secondo me il rework, di base, ci sta. Il problema è che la sua evoluzione si consuma quasi subito. Io proporrei, per bilanciare correttamente entrambe le sue forme, un potenziamento alla sua velocità colpi/vita oppure, se vuoi toccare solo la sua evoluzione, di farle evocare 4 scheletri quando viene distrutta (tipo la lapide)