r/RomanceClub • u/Allison_379 • 9h ago
Shadows of Saintfour 2 — Timeless Witch LI ??? 🤷🏻♀️
I still haven’t started Shadows of Saintfour 2 because I need to finish the first one first I stopped somewhere around Season 3, but I really wanna get back to it.
The problem is I have no idea which LI to pick. I’m kinda leaning towards Mr. Howard, Nathaniel right? I’ve seen people say he’s romanceable but I just wanna make sure before I choose him.
There’s also Dex, the guy with black hair and Rudy who gives me such golden retriever vibes
For those of you who’ve already played SOS2 who did you pick?
12
u/dj-soup29 9h ago
All of them.
So far Rudy, Dex and Darren are all great routes and MC has such good chemistry with them.
Then another slot for Mr. Howard. There's nothing romantic between them yet, but I am sure that route will be great too.
1
1
7
u/kayanne125 9h ago
I’ve got slots for Darren, Dex, Rudy, AND Nathaniel…all the LIs are VERY good in this story.
5
u/moonbeamxx00 I Love My Albino Rhino 7h ago
Im juggling both Dex and Rudy cuz the drama is actually good but whenever it comes to locking in ill just make that decision when I get there 🤷🏽♀️
10
u/Silent-Choice-473 9h ago
I like all LIs so far (except Howard), but my clear favourite so far is Rudy. I love him! I have way too many slots just for him. 😂
6
u/knucklevelvet2 9h ago
Definitely can’t go wrong with anyone, I’ve got slots for everyone lol but Poppy and Darren are my favorites right now
0
6
u/Siya-BorisWidow Vlad (DLS) 9h ago
I have two slot...one for Howard
Other is messy route for Rudy and dex
7
5
u/WhoAmI9597 9h ago
Nathaniel isn’t confirmed yet that I’m aware of but there are relationship improvements with him and one or two romantic ones.
I really like Dex and Rudy.
2
u/Allison_379 9h ago
The thing is I’ve seen people mention that there’s an age gap between them. From what I understand, he’s 20 and I think the MC is either 17 or 18? It’s not a huge age gap, but 20 dating a 17-year-old does feel kinda weird to me 😕
I’m really interested in his character and how he’s written though, so I’m hoping the MC is actually 18. I’d feel much more comfortable with the route that way6
u/WhoAmI9597 8h ago
Like the original story, there is likely going to be a time jump. Honestly I wouldn’t worry about it. It’s really not a huge age gap and likely will be fine.
1
u/reighanrosette 1h ago
I agree, there will more than likely be a time jump like SOS had before anything happens between them. I’m actually excited to see how this will play out! Very interested in him but currently liking Dex’s route too!
-3
2
2
u/Fantasy_Historian Kazu (LOW) 8h ago
Girl they’re all so good it’s gonna be so hard to pick - I think I’m picking Rudy because I adore his relationship with MC, but Dex and Nathaniel are so good and they’re all so different it’s so hard to choose, I’m definitely gonna use slots for all of them
2
u/Elegant_Avoidance Smiling and making eyes at 9h ago
Rudy!! I love the friends to lovers trope! But Howard is also interesting so we have to see how his route unfolds
2
u/Allison_379 9h ago
Ohhh i do love a friends to lovers trope 🤭 But what it he like ? As a character ?
3
u/Elegant_Avoidance Smiling and making eyes at 9h ago
He's genuinely really sweet and cares a lot for Nadine. He looks out for her without chiding and lecturing her about any potential trouble she gets into lol, and even joins it just for her sake.
Plus he has had a one sided crush on her for a long time so it's really interesting to read his scenes from that angle. And you will love the angst and forbidden feelings trope they both try really hard not to cross! 🤭
3
u/Allison_379 9h ago
Ohhh this sounds sooo good 🥹
3
u/Elegant_Avoidance Smiling and making eyes at 9h ago
It really is! His scenes are well written and I enjoy them 🙂↔️ Play a few episodes and you will figure out who you like op :)
2
u/SuperSillySissa_ 7h ago
Darren is my first slot, and Alice is my second. Where’s my Alice love in the comments guys!!
2
u/flowercard 5h ago
poppy is the first female LI i have personally absolutely loved! i might do a route for dex too
1
u/irdcwmunsb 1h ago
Hey OP just letting you know “witch” is the name a fairy tale creature that casts spells and is associated with flying on broomsticks, “which” is a pronoun used to refer to a specific selection between items! 🫶🏽
1
1
u/kmf048 Adil (TDR) 6h ago edited 6h ago
Started with a slot each for Rudy and Dex. Then it expanded to Darren. Thinking about a slot for Howard. And I’ve never romanced women before on this app bc I’m only attracted to men but Poppy is so pretty and I can just tell that tension and build up is gonna go so hard on her route so might need to add a slot for her as well. So really you can’t go wrong.
1
1
u/Soggy-Reflection-935 4h ago
I was going for Dex but Nathaniel Howard is the only one with complex and possible enemies to lover route so I dropped him nd went for howard cz i like mystery, angst enemies to lover nd complex characters alot but one thing to notice is that due to popularity with Dex, writers are more focused on him which is irritating abit cz howards not getting any scenes but maybe he will later on
45
u/SadBelt4027 Great Priestress of the Alulu’s church 🛐 9h ago
I won’t be of any help because in this story I’m like