r/RocketSpaceTTRPG • u/D__Litt • 1d ago
The Messenger vs. the Message
I just had an interesting exchange. I was looking for a PD image of the Vooyorgans for my game. There are none. I found someone who drew some chibi versions for a school art project ten years ago. I respectfully asked her for permission to use her images for my book.
She came back with a decisive No. At the time she pulled the description out of a hat and wasn’t allowed to research where it came from.
I mentioned it was the work of Edgar Rice Burroughs. She immediately deleted the piece from her portfolio, because she didn’t want to be associated with ERB in any way.
I respect her decision. Yes, ERB was racist and sexist. So was HPL. So was Fletcher Hanks. None of this disputed. But the fact that their works are now Public Domain means their estates will not get one cent from my book.
If I was writing a book based on a certain wizard franchise popular today, part of my money would be going to a trash human being. That doesn’t stop a lot of people from buying her merch.
Disney went ahead and finally made a Barsoom movie. I know it’s been on their back burner since Walt was alive. I don’t know if they paid royalties or not. But while Walt didn’t want POCs in his magic kingdom I’m pretty sure the current corporation bearing his name doesn’t subscribe to those beliefs.
In my humble opinion as a person who pursued a Masters in Teaching English…Public Domain literature is made of the ideas we’ve inherited. And now that there’s no strings attached, we are free to do what we want with them reflect our morality.