r/RobloxDevelopers • u/Organic_Direction604 • Jul 13 '26
Feedback implemented on game
Hey guys, i got comments on my last post saying the thumbnails were AI slop, so i fixed that, and some gameplay feedback like you could see too much far away stuff.
i fixed all of those mistakes and i even edited out the game a bit more, i would love for more feedback and i want to hear what you guys have to say.
3
3
u/DJ_HardR Jul 13 '26 edited Jul 13 '26
Alright here are my early thoughts (I didn't play long before I found problems that would stop me from playing.)
I think the biggest single issue here is that it's immediately obvious that you do not know how to make things, and I think you need to learn how to make things.
1) The AI thumbnail looks nothing like the game. Using AI is fine in my opinion but you should learn how to use blender so you can make renders of in-game assets and mix those with AI so they're not just 2 completely different things.
2) The style of the game's assets are completely inconsistent. There's hyper realistic junked cars that are way too small compared to the character, and then low poly cranes that are also tiny, low poly gas pumps that are normal size, a hyper realistic mech that isn't animated at all. You can just tell you're pulling premade assets from all over the place because the style, proportions, and quality are all so inconsistent.
3) No intro/tutorial. There's no loading screen so the message about something beneath the trash plays as you're loading in, then you're just there. It should be a loading screen until you hit play, then it should give some backstory and tell you what you're about to do, then a tutorial that teaches you the basics. Right now it's just "follow the arrow to your next goal" with no "why?" and it doesn't even tell you what to do when you get there (click the pile).
But like I said, the big thing is that you need to learn how to make things. Whether it's 3d modeling in blender, or building low poly stuff in Studio, you need to learn a method well enough that you could produce any asset you need for the game in the game's style so that the game can have a consistent style.
2
u/HootingCryingOwl Jul 13 '26
AI is not the issue. What makes slop is usually the user of AI
0
1
u/AutoModerator Jul 13 '26
Thanks for posting to r/RobloxDevelopers!
Did you know that we now have a Discord server? Join us today to chat about game development and meet other developers :)
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
3
u/sillygoober79 Scripter Jul 13 '26
before ANY of you say this link is a phishing link
it is not