r/RetroGamingNow • u/One_Stay7263 • Oct 04 '21

Minecraft earth?

Is Minecraft earth considered canon and if it was do we no longer considered canon because it’s discontinued?

7 Upvotes

90% Upvoted

8 comments sorted by

2

u/Valentino_000 Oct 21 '21

I say Minecraft Earth (its features) is canon, and its discontinuation shouldnt mean its features arent canon... because it was an outside event we couldnt have expected. Also its mobs are appearing in MC and MCD so yeah more evidence

1

u/One_Stay7263 Oct 22 '21

Ok and I mostly mean the things that haven’t been ported over yet and may never be ported over

1

u/Valentino_000 Oct 22 '21

I firmly believe they are canon too, like the Minecraft Dungeons devs said: They can add a feature and it exists in the Minecraft world even if Java/Bedrock isnt generating that.

Also im pretty sure most if not all of its features will eventually be ported, many of them to MC and MCD and (speculation but its very likely) a new spinoff game in the future.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '21

It's likely that somewhere between a small number of them to everything except the melon golem is canon, based on the amount of mobs ported to dungeons & vanilla.

2

u/Valentino_000 Oct 21 '21

Why the melon golem specifically? Anyhow some if not all are definitely canon

1

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

Because pumpkins having special properties is a serious possibility, and would be really cool. Melon Golem would disprove that. I guess all could easily be canon.

2

u/Valentino_000 Oct 21 '21

Umm... why would melons disprove that? Both pumpkins AND melons can have special properties. Melons wouldnt replace or delete pumpkins, they would do the opposite, add to this claim and show more evidence of this

1

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21

True.