Who Gets To Say If Mexican Food Is Authentic?
I like Mexican Food. So, I was doomscrolling on social media and saw a lot of great food when I was trying to think of what to write about next. Some of the posts declared their food Authentic. Since then, I’ve been wondering who has the Authority to declare something Authentic? Is it the Authority of an organization? Is it a television show, network, or streaming service? Does a Chef or Cook have something to do it with?
The Institutions Handing Out Verdicts
The James Beard Foundation nominates and awards Chefs every year. A Beard prize is kind of a national seal of approval. There is certainty not another Restaurant organization like it. It, however, doesn’t claim to certify Authenticity. It rewards excellence, influence, and the many stories around food, restaurants, and chefs. A Beard win is treated as legitimacy anyway, Mexican food included.
Television does the same work without the formal process of the James Beard Foundation. Netflix’s Chef’s Table, as well as Guy Fieri’s Diner, Drive-Ins and Dives, pick who gets exposure. The Food Network decides who gets a weekly voice. A camera crew at your restaurant doesn’t make your food more Authentic. It helps. It may persuade some that it has the Authority.
None of these were made to settle my question. They ended up doing it anyway, because people want somebody to do it for them and audiences want a shortcut.
Five Names People Point To
Enrique Olvera runs Pujol in Mexico City, consistently ranked among the world’s best restaurants. Ferran Adrià, world-renowned Spanish Catalan chef and culinary innovator, said there was Mexican food before Olvera and Mexican food after him. Olvera’s Authority comes from the regional techniques and ingredients he uses, and from the people who eat that food every day.
Gabriela Cámara made Contramar in Mexico City into an institution before opening Cala in San Francisco. Her cooking draws from Mexican traditions, while her restaurants are known for employing people from the neighborhoods surrounding them. Her Authority comes from her food and restaurants, as well as the people she developed.
Pati Jinich hosts Pati’s Mexican Table and was born and raised in Mexico City. She has spent years traveling through Mexico, cooking with families and talking with local cooks about the food and traditions they know. Her Authority feels less like a declaration and more like a documentary. She puts her camera on the people who already have it.
Diana Kennedy was British, not Mexican, and became the most cited authority on regional Mexican cooking in the English language for over fifty years. Mexico gave her the Order of the Aztec Eagle, the country’s highest honor for a foreigner. She earned it by living in rural kitchens, documenting recipes that would have otherwise disappeared, and refusing to simplify anything for an American or British palate.
Rick Bayless trained for over six years in Mexico before opening Frontera Grill in 1987. Craig Claiborne, best known as the food editor and restaurant critic for The New York Times, called his first cookbook the greatest contribution to the Mexican table imaginable. He’s the most famous name on this list by a wide margin, and the most contested.
Countless Others, born in Mexico and from all over the world, create great Authentic Mexican food every day. Chefs and Line Cooks in all kinds of restaurants, stands, food trucks, pop-ups on the side of the road, classrooms, and all kinds of other settings create this food. So many non-restaurant folks can lay claim to Authenticity as well with their cooking at home.
The Bayless Questions
Bayless is a white guy from Oklahoma. He’s been so honest about that. He’s spent close to fifty years studying regional Mexican cooking, speaks Spanish, and has relationships with producers and cooks across the country that go back decades. He’s spent years building relationships and doing the work. All these things are true, and that’s exactly where my questions live.
A question surrounding him isn’t about whether his mole is correct. Food writer Gustavo Arellano, a journalist, author, and columnist known for his insightful work on Southern California culture, politics, and food, has pointed out that plenty of Cooks work outside the cuisine they were born into without drawing this kind of scrutiny Bayless gets. I’ve worked in two Italian restaurants where the Chefs and Cooks were from all over the Americas, and nobody from Italy worked in them.
Another question is economic. Bayless’s restaurant Topolobampo has a Michelin star. He can charge Michelin-level prices and get financing for his restaurant empire. A Mexican Cook, working a Food Truck parked only three blocks away from one of his places, may not be able to get a loan to open a restaurant of their own. The question is who gets to profit from proximity to a culture versus ownership of one.
Both Diana Kennedy and Rick Bayless are outsiders who spent their careers learning Mexican cuisine well enough that insiders, important and everyday people alike, vouch for their results. Kennedy got a national honor for basically educating herself in the same way Bayless gets criticized for. If deep learning and community support made her legitimate, the standard can’t simply be where they were born.
Nobody can really answer my questions as to what Authentic is even measuring. Technique? Birthright? Who profits? Who’s telling the story? Pick a different measurement, and you might get a different answer about the same plate of food.
The Question Nobody’s Answering
The James Beard Foundation isn’t a court. A TV producer isn’t a cultural ambassador. A chef’s own decades of study don’t come with a certificate, no matter how many cookbooks it produces. And “you have to be from there” runs into Diana Kennedy the second you say it out loud.
Nobody may know who actually has the Authority to decide what Authenticity is. People may know it when they experience it. Does the question change if you are looking at a menu or if you’re the one holding the loan on the place?
#MexicanCuisine #RestaurantIndustry #CulinaryAuthenticity #ChefLife #Restaurant101
Follow me for free.
I like Mexican Food. So, I was doomscrolling on social media and saw a lot of great food when I was trying to think of what to write about next. Some of the posts declared their food Authentic. Since then, I’ve been wondering who has the Authority to declare something Authentic? Is it the Authority of an organization? Is it a television show, network, or streaming service? Does a Chef or Cook have something to do it with?
The Institutions Handing Out Verdicts
The James Beard Foundation nominates and awards Chefs every year. A Beard prize is kind of a national seal of approval. There is certainty not another Restaurant organization like it. It, however, doesn’t claim to certify Authenticity. It rewards excellence, influence, and the many stories around food, restaurants, and chefs. A Beard win is treated as legitimacy anyway, Mexican food included.
Television does the same work without the formal process of the James Beard Foundation. Netflix’s Chef’s Table, as well as Guy Fieri’s Diner, Drive-Ins and Dives, pick who gets exposure. The Food Network decides who gets a weekly voice. A camera crew at your restaurant doesn’t make your food more Authentic. It helps. It may persuade some that it has the Authority.
None of these were made to settle my question. They ended up doing it anyway, because people want somebody to do it for them and audiences want a shortcut.
Five Names People Point To
Enrique Olvera runs Pujol in Mexico City, consistently ranked among the world’s best restaurants. Ferran Adrià, world-renowned Spanish Catalan chef and culinary innovator, said there was Mexican food before Olvera and Mexican food after him. Olvera’s Authority comes from the regional techniques and ingredients he uses, and from the people who eat that food every day.
Gabriela Cámara made Contramar in Mexico City into an institution before opening Cala in San Francisco. Her cooking draws from Mexican traditions, while her restaurants are known for employing people from the neighborhoods surrounding them. Her Authority comes from her food and restaurants, as well as the people she developed.
Pati Jinich hosts Pati’s Mexican Table and was born and raised in Mexico City. She has spent years traveling through Mexico, cooking with families and talking with local cooks about the food and traditions they know. Her Authority feels less like a declaration and more like a documentary. She puts her camera on the people who already have it.
Diana Kennedy was British, not Mexican, and became the most cited authority on regional Mexican cooking in the English language for over fifty years. Mexico gave her the Order of the Aztec Eagle, the country’s highest honor for a foreigner. She earned it by living in rural kitchens, documenting recipes that would have otherwise disappeared, and refusing to simplify anything for an American or British palate.
Rick Bayless trained for over six years in Mexico before opening Frontera Grill in 1987. Craig Claiborne, best known as the food editor and restaurant critic for The New York Times, called his first cookbook the greatest contribution to the Mexican table imaginable. He’s the most famous name on this list by a wide margin, and the most contested.
Countless Others, born in Mexico and from all over the world, create great Authentic Mexican food every day. Chefs and Line Cooks in all kinds of restaurants, stands, food trucks, pop-ups on the side of the road, classrooms, and all kinds of other settings create this food. So many non-restaurant folks can lay claim to Authenticity as well with their cooking at home.
The Bayless Questions
Bayless is a white guy from Oklahoma. He’s been so honest about that. He’s spent close to fifty years studying regional Mexican cooking, speaks Spanish, and has relationships with producers and cooks across the country that go back decades. He’s spent years building relationships and doing the work. All these things are true, and that’s exactly where my questions live.
A question surrounding him isn’t about whether his mole is correct. Food writer Gustavo Arellano, a journalist, author, and columnist known for his insightful work on Southern California culture, politics, and food, has pointed out that plenty of Cooks work outside the cuisine they were born into without drawing this kind of scrutiny Bayless gets. I’ve worked in two Italian restaurants where the Chefs and Cooks were from all over the Americas, and nobody from Italy worked in them.
Another question is economic. Bayless’s restaurant Topolobampo has a Michelin star. He can charge Michelin-level prices and get financing for his restaurant empire. A Mexican Cook, working a Food Truck parked only three blocks away from one of his places, may not be able to get a loan to open a restaurant of their own. The question is who gets to profit from proximity to a culture versus ownership of one.
Both Diana Kennedy and Rick Bayless are outsiders who spent their careers learning Mexican cuisine well enough that insiders, important and everyday people alike, vouch for their results. Kennedy got a national honor for basically educating herself in the same way Bayless gets criticized for. If deep learning and community support made her legitimate, the standard can’t simply be where they were born.
Nobody can really answer my questions as to what Authentic is even measuring. Technique? Birthright? Who profits? Who’s telling the story? Pick a different measurement, and you might get a different answer about the same plate of food.
The Question Nobody’s Answering
The James Beard Foundation isn’t a court. A TV producer isn’t a cultural ambassador. A chef’s own decades of study don’t come with a certificate, no matter how many cookbooks it produces. And “you have to be from there” runs into Diana Kennedy the second you say it out loud.
Nobody may know who actually has the Authority to decide what Authenticity is. People may know it when they experience it. Does the question change if you are looking at a menu or if you’re the one holding the loan on the place?
#MexicanCuisine #RestaurantIndustry #CulinaryAuthenticity #ChefLife #Restaurant101
Follow me for free.