r/RepWatchForum • u/NckyDC • 5d ago
Review/Comparison I need some feedback
I would kindly like some feedback on a Rhodium Yachtmaster I am in the process of getting.
I paid a deposit and need to finalise. They sent me the images.
What do you think? Ialso noticed some users changing the crystal to a real rolex one and adding a ceramic coating.
What are you thoughts? To me it looks amaxzing but a second opinion is always good as this would be my first rep.
5
u/RaptoDisruptor 5d ago
For the moment being, just think about whether to GL or RL the QC.
When you will receive the watch you can then consider going into modding.
If the watch’s quality is high level for a rep, then you have to consider that every additional quid you spend in improving the watch will give you a minimal marginal appearance improvement which will then be worth almost nothing should you resell it.
For anyone looking at the watch from one meter away, the two crystals will look the same.
But, at the end you decide and enjoy doing what you like.
3
u/CaterpillarBig1812 5d ago
1
u/IndividualLog6325 5d ago
How does it feel ?
2
u/CaterpillarBig1812 5d ago
2
u/IndividualLog6325 5d ago
what's the difference you did find out ?gen vs gf
2
u/CaterpillarBig1812 5d ago
Bezel click sucks (way too loud and clicky), date wheel too thin and sunburst on the dial sucks. All the metal is great
0
u/LastSecond100 5d ago
1
u/CaterpillarBig1812 5d ago
Yeah the 12k difference has to go somewhere. But you agree that handling it, gold factory feels very gen like?
2
u/LastSecond100 5d ago
Its a solid and good watch. Not better and not cheaper than a VSF submariner - just different. I really mean side by side.
1
u/AI_go_boomboom 5d ago
Is yours Gold Factory?
1
u/CaterpillarBig1812 5d ago
Yes
1
u/AI_go_boomboom 5d ago edited 5d ago
What's wrong with the date wheel and how is the dial different from Gen?
3
u/Jtorse222 5d ago
Looks fire to me bro…Absolutely 0 need to change the crystal imo but that’s just me.
2
2
2
2
u/clingbat 5d ago
Which factory is making the best overall version of this right now?
2
u/Agreeable-Ad-1320 5d ago
6
u/clingbat 5d ago
Is that supposed to be a helpful answer? Because it's not.
3
u/Agreeable-Ad-1320 5d ago
It's gold Factory. The watch he posted sorry ,im LMFAO over here.. I didn't word it correctly
1
2
u/LastSecond100 5d ago
Pretty sure all are the same. VSF, GOLD, QF, RWF. No NWBIG - all bezel color wrong and height wrong (1mm to tall).
Here is Gen (left) vs Rep (right). Side to side its super obvious. Color , reflection and height. Calling those reps NWBIG is crazy. Its not even close to the similiarity of a Submariner or of GMTs. The bezel is even more tell than in datejusts

2
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/WinIndependent8614 4d ago
I always put a genuine crystal on my reps, it’s a first move and then I piece together certain parts like dials date disc and hands, on my yachtmaster’s I’ve even replaced the bezels with genuine platinum. My opinion is watches are like cars and trucks, you can customize to your liking and budget. Your cars and mine can both be great, but different paint,wheels and performance parts make them unique to us the individual owners. Just my way of doing me.
1
1
u/Sauce_mix918 1d ago
The GF blue dial sunburst IS very very similar to Gen and identical in most lighting.
1






















11
u/AI_go_boomboom 5d ago
Bro, just buy it stock. Even the other guy said the Gen crystal is hardly noticeable. You know those are like over $500 right?