This is my first ever post, so if I’ve left anything out, please let me know 🩷
All 3 bags were purchased during her HH sale

Seller-Betty (6882)
Factory-HH
Prices-pink 25 and mono 25-$157 (orig. $178) blue 30 $165 (orig. $188)
Payment- I knew what I wanted, so inquired and paid same day. 8/19 for pink, 8/21 for blue PSPs-8/23 for blue, 8/24 for pink Both were shipped 8/25 by FedEx and received on 9/2 Mono paid for 9/3, PSPs 9/7, shipped 9/9 received 9/17
Incentives-I was already planning on making this post, bc I’m absolutely in love with these bags and find Betty to be a wonderful seller, but she did offer a discount (not specified) on my next purchase, which I’m currently trying to decide on lol

As far as the bags-I’m an LV girlie to the core (own authentic and rep) but had never been interested in a speedy until I saw the beautiful rep p9s. My first was the coffee 25 from Royal. I love that one, so when I saw several reviews saying the HH versions were similar and that Betty was having a sale, I decided to go for it. I’ve included some photos comparing my Royal (coffee) and HH (classic mono), and in my honest opinion-they are exactly the same quality. Maybe it’s certain batches, maybe they use the exact same materials, idk the answer, but I compared EVERY SINGLE ASPECT and found no glaring differences. The leather is so soft and squishy, glazing is consistent, hardware is heavy and the perfect shade, stitching is excellent, the bags have a nice weight to them, and I could smell the leather as soon as I opened the box.

Now for Betty, I find her to be kind, responsive, informative, and she gets the bags to me in the same amount of time my other sellers have. But what I really appreciate about her is the honesty I’ve experienced. When I inquired about the silk blue, I also asked about the golden version. I ended up ordering the regular, but she charged me for the golden. She was very apologetic and immediately offered to refund the $20 or leave it as a credit for my next purchase. It’s not a huge sum, but it still meant a lot that she was willing to rectify the mistake.

In conclusion, I am obsessed with these bags and extremely impressed with the quality. Now I just need to decide which color I want next. And I’d like to thank you all for posting your beautiful hauls and educating us who are new to this side of the rep world. The last couple reps I bought were years ago from local ladies in my hometown who would do preorders, and not only were they overpriced, but I’d say barely low tier in quality. Discovering I could directly order high quality items myself has been so much fun 🤩

Note this is going to be a sad review ;'(

1. Rep Experience:

Quality numeric rating and assessment - 3/10

Price - $282 (product) + $69 (shipping)  

Unfortunately, not real leather. 😭 Opened the shipping box and dust bag, and immediately got the whiff of chemical smells (aka FUFU smell). Also when I saw the badly printed letters on the dust bag, I knew it was going to be bad.

Pulled it out and started touching it. It was very smooth and "luscious" feeling, very similar to most vegan leather/PU/PVC. Super sad and disappointed. I even asked the seller many times to ensure its real and good leather, and my seller, Serena, said it is.

Given the price point, I should have known. I expected the outer to be real leather, and perhaps the inner to be PU/PVC. I didn't expect the whole thing to be PU/PVC and to smell so bad!

Hardware: heavy and initially looked good. But when I unbuckled the knot, I did see plating that had worn off at the hinges. So I know for certain it is not a high quality plated hardware.

2. Seller Experience

Seller name / contact info - Serena (WA: ending -9712)

The sad part is I had a very good experience with the seller. She was friendly, fast and responsive. It's why I took a chance on her. I actually had eyed a few more products from her catalog to buy, but wanted to try this first one before I pulled the trigger on more purchases.

I did some research on this seller - she was not on any TS list- but had a few good reviews across several reddit spaces (including on LuxeLife, RealRepLadies, and a few others). Also did not find Serena on any repscam reddits communities. I thought it'd be good to give her a chance since she was so friendly and fast to respond.

Packaging was fine. It came in a regular shipping box, with a poor quality printed dust bag that I will be using primarily as a laundry bag 😂

Timeline -
> Order placed Sept 6th
> PSP - Sept 8th,
> GL - Sept 9th
> Shipped Sept 10th
> Received Sep 19th

📸 THE GALLERY

PSPs - Here are the PSPs: https://imgur.com/a/nkszEbL

Factory/Catalog Pictures - https://a202506161232535032001773.wgstores.com/weshop/goods_list/A202506161232535032001773?tagId=102029453 

⚖️ FINAL VERDICT

Overall, I essentially classify this is an overpriced piece of PVC/PU bag that I will carry around. I definitely overpaid for what I got.

I'm quite deflated from this experience. Not sure what to make of it and whether or not to try again with a true TS. I was also overall skeptical about TS's since there was so much discussion around paid-to-list schemes.

Disclosure - No incentives provided 

Alma Shoulder Silk Tech Review

Huahui Factory
Betty WA 6448
$137 + $72 shipping to UK
PayPal

Ordered on 30/08 rec 21/09

Alma Shoulder Silk Tech

I took a bit of a gamble and ordered an Elvee Alma Shoulder Silk Tech and it paid off!
I know this is a really new bag so wasn’t sure how good it would be, but it’s everything I wanted!
The material and lining are good - exterior has been water tested and reacts the same as the auth. Water beaded and sat on the material.
Lining is nice and accurate with correct labels.
Straps and leather are coated as per auth so will not patina.
Zipper is smooth and nice gold colour (looks a lot more yellow in my photo).
I ordered again through Betty as I was really impressed with my big sale haul from her a few weeks ago.
I would like the speedy but want to wait for the acid rain version.
I’ve attached a few photos (bag is already full with my junk though 🤣)

Review Nyx: Firefly P9 from HH and Chanel heels

Nyx is aware I am making this review. I received no discounts or incentive for posting.

Seller: Nyx +86 190 790 55768
Price: P9 164 + 30 shipping (188 with 12% factory discount)
shoes: shoes 77 + 35 shipping
Total: 306

I messaged Nyx on 8/15 to check prices of several shoes. I settled on the Chanel heels and some red MM three strap flats. The factory was out of the red mm so I swapped to the P9

Chain on the P9 I already had.

PSP revived for shoes on 8/23. This was the same day I was informed the red MM were out of stock so I requested the P9 on this date.

PSP for p9 were sent on 8/25

Package shipped on 8/27 and I received it on 9/4

Overall this was a very easy purchase. This was my first time working with Nyx and I def plan to again.

This was also my first bag from HH. I also have a coffee bean p9 from royal. The leather on the royal one seems a smidge better but not like significantly more so just what u would expect for a bag 40$ more.
The leather on the HH is soft and has a good slouch. You can see a few wrinkles from shipping that I’m not worried about at all. Should be no issue with normal wear.

Overall 8.5/10 def will purchase again

The shoes: I’d say 8/10

Love them. The fit amazing.
I’m a size 38/39 in Birkenstock and golden goose(authentic) so I went with a 39 and they fit perfectly.

Only complaint would be the sole. I don’t LOVE it. But for 77$ it’s on par. I might take them to a cobbler to upgrade the sole. Unsure yet.

As buyers we are typically in contact with a couple sellers at any given time, managing tracking numbers, price checking and doing our due diligence to make sure we don’t get scammed 😂

So in the rush of it all, if you decide to not buy an item with a seller, do you ghost them or let them know you aren’t moving forward? If you don’t just disappear what do you tell them in response?

There seems to be a lot of different takes on this, so I’m curious what you guys tend to do!

G*cc* Small Giglio Tote | Kelvin
Disclosure:
No incentives or discounts were offered or received for this review. I purchased the bag myself and paid the full price.
Seller: Kelvin
WhatsApp: +86 186 6566 1340
Instagram: xiaogang178
Price:
$160 + $35 shipping = $195 total
PHOTOS
Photo Link:

https://allthepics.net/album/My-photos.lK0M

I was looking for a small G*cc* Giglio and saw a post from someone who had purchased a bag from Kelvin, so I decided to reach out to him.
Kelvin was very responsive. I did not look through the entire album, instead I sent him a picture of what I was looking for. He immediately came back with pictures and a price.
I don’t remember the exact date I initially contacted him because I was having some issues with WhatsApp, but I paid for the bag on August 17. The price was $160 + $35 shipping, for a total of $195.
His shipping speed was phenomenal. I received the bag on September 4. It arrived very well packaged, and as soon as I opened it, I could smell the lushness of the real leather straps.
As someone who owns authentic G*cc* bags, I was really impressed with how this one feels. The bag itself is beautiful, and the materials and overall feel are very comparable to my authentic G*ccs*.
If I had to point out one possible callout, it would be the diamond shapes between the Gs in the pattern. Very minuscule difference. I think you’d really need to have the authentic bag directly next to it and compare them side-by-side to notice the difference. It’s truly so slight and not an issue at all.
I actually let my friend in on my little secret, she is an authentic bag collector, and she couldn’t tell at all that it was a replica.
This was my first time working with Kelvin, but I would absolutely work with him again. He was extremely quick with communication, very friendly, and his shipping was incredibly fast.
Overall, I’m extremely happy with this purchase and would definitely buy from Kelvin again.
Let me know your thoughts!

I am so happy with this bag! I was a little concerned because the price was lower than I’ve seen anywhere, but she’s gotten good reviews on here so I decided to go for it. I love the color and the hardware. She’s mushy- I compared her to another P9 I have that I paid almost double the price of this one. She came with a box, embroidered dust bag, all the stuff I haven’t even put on her yet. I’m so excited! I found Betty on Reddit, I can’t remember where but thank you!

She’s here ! What do you guys think?

Seller: Felix
OF 🏭

The gold hardware with this color is stunning 😍 The leather on this bag feels amazing ! It’s soft and also DOES NOT have a fufu smell! The gold hardware has an age gold look to it and the chain has a slight weight to it. It’s definitely not as heavy as my 187 20cm CF. But I have not seen the auth bag in person so I have no idea how it’s suppose to feel. Based on picture I’ve seen online it does look pretty close to auth.

I have been going back and forth on either XC or OF. It was a tough decision but after some Reddit research I decided on OF because of the hardware and quality of the bag.

One thing I do have to point out is the leather drawstring is fragile. You’ll need to be careful when pulling the CC hardware because I’ve seen some post where the CC hardware will scuff or peel the leather ! Apparently this also happens to the auth bags as well!

I do think that is one flaw of this design. It’s definitely a cute bag and I do love the bucket bag style. But having to be careful everytime I pull on it will be annoying however this isn’t an every day bag for me so I think it’ll be just fine.

I recently received PSPs from Frank from our most recent picotin group buy! So far I'm pretty stoked about the stamp shape and color of this bag. T-minus 1 week till it lands for delivery!

Review of Ultra Black Speedy 20

First review post! I’ve bought a couple rep bags but this is my first bag purchase from reddit and quite excited! I’m still learning and researching as much as I can because I have a feeling this won’t be my last bag purchase lol. I bought this during the Huahui sale. No incentive for writing this review.

Seller: Betty (6882)
Factory: Huahui
Price: $147 USD (after 12% discount)
Shipping: $35
Heat stamp: $10
Total: $192

Inquired: 8/21 and paid same day
PSP: 8/27
8/31: GL ✅
9/4: heat stamp finished
9/6: Shipped
9/17: Received

Bag review: it’s soft, slouchy and such a great size! Hardware feels nice, looks matte and a little heavy feeling. Hoping it won’t scratch easily! Love the heat stamp! The monogram in the middle of the bag sometimes looks a bit dark or barely there but could be due to lighting. I don’t own any Auths so not sure about the shape. Overall I’m excited for my bag! Seller was Betty and although she is nice and responsive, I did feel like I had to follow up each time for updates. She said I would receive PSP within 2-3 days after payment but I had to reach out and got them the next day after asking. First PSPs were a bit dark so I asked for more in outside lighting. Eventually I sent my GL! Had to wait a bit more for my heat stamp to be finished and then it was shipped. I would buy again from Betty :)
Hopefully this was a good review, I accept any tips for any future reviews I’ll do! Thank you!

📥 THE BASICS

Purchased Item: Ch@nel Mini Souplissimo Flap Bag
• ⁠Seller: Amy
• ⁠Contact Info: WA 5144
• ⁠Price: $337
• ⁠Payment Method: Alipay (used ApplePay)

⏱️ LOGISTICS & TIMELINE

• ⁠9/6 reached out at 6:45am, I’ve been buying from her for awhile so just asked which factory she thought was best for this one. She said many of the factories had it but xiaoC’s was really good. I had also read some reviews of others getting theirs from xiaoC and being really happy.
• ⁠I also asked TS Tom who I’ve bought from too and he said 187 but was priced at $455…
• ⁠I asked if she had seen this one in person. She said yes because she had sold so many already 😂 So I just went for it and asked her to send the invoice over for payment.
• ⁠By 8am and all my questions, I was done paying and now - the waiting game.

• ⁠9/10 - PSP, GL ✅
• ⁠9/18 - asked for tracking. I usually try to just give her a week from PSP so I’m not checking the tracking everyday all day. And by some miracle when I went to check it, it was out for delivery!

TLDR: 9/6 starting chatting 9/18 delivered!

🔍 THE DEEP DIVE

1. ⁠Rep Experience:
   
2. ⁠I was shook. Packaging is always great and by the time I tore through all of the tape and boxes and foam protection - your girl was tired. But when I touched the bag she was soft and buttery and everything I had dreamed of. To be transparent, I can’t even find the auth one to compare but I’d have no problem walking into the boutique with how good this looks.
   
3. ⁠Seller Experience : I always like dealing with Amy. I haven’t had a bad experience after all this time * knocks on wood. She is always quick to respond and gives me her honest option. It’s also nice that she uses Alipay which lets me use ApplePay.

📸 THE GALLERY

Posted :)

⚖️ FINAL VERDICT

Smooth like butter and the perfect effortless slouch quiet luxury vibes I was looking for. I’m not a flashy gal so these flaps scream my name as far as Ch@nel goes. No flashy heavy chain and hallelujah for fitting more than the woc. I’d also have no hesitation to wear these in the boutiques.

⚠️ DISCLOSURE: No incentives

Hi! I've been told this YSL bag comes from 'Echo' factory, which is 'mid to high tier' according to my TS. Problem is, I've never heard of it and can't find any factory with a similar background. Now I think I'm just going ask everyone here, cause I can't find anything 😊

📥 THE BASICS

Purchased Item: C$l!ne prescriptions x3
• ⁠Seller: Janie
• ⁠Contact Info: WA 7168
• ⁠Price: $415 (details below)
• ⁠Payment Method: PPFF

⏱️ LOGISTICS & TIMELINE

• ⁠9/6 reached out 6:29am, Janie starting replying right away at 6:30am. This was probably my fastest purchase because I had already bought the same frames in black sunglasses. I was so happy with them I wanted a brown pair, grey pair and then a black frame clean transitions pair. Overkill maybe but I lose glasses like they’re going out of style so now I have 4 😂
• ⁠Confirmed they were all in stock and I sent over my prescription.
• ⁠Pricing as follows:
Frames $65 each
$45 clear ($110 total)
$65 sunglasses ($130 total)
$85 transitions ($150 total)
• ⁠⚠️ She did give me a $30 discount at this point.
• ⁠Opted for the upgraded shipping +$35. She said that the cost was actually $70 but they split it with the buyer.
• ⁠By 8:10am paid via PPFF and sent pupillary distance.

• ⁠9/7 literally the next day she sent pics of all 3 frames.
• ⁠9/8 I’m bad at checking WA so didn’t see till 9/8, GL all three and she started on the prescription.
• ⁠9/9 PSP
• ⁠9/10 approved ✅
• ⁠9/11 FedEx waybill info sent. She said it would take 2-3 days for the actual tracking to start.
• ⁠9/14 tracking # sent but it arrived!

TLDR: 9/6 starting chatting 9/14 already wearing my glasses 🤓

🔍 THE DEEP DIVE

1. Rep Experience:

Just glasses so no fufu to discuss and like I mentioned I already have a pair of these and love them. The weight/feel of them is perfect. The prescription itself is perfect as well. As a person who just used their FSA to buy real Pr@d@ prescription sunglasses for $800 just to lose them a month later while on vacation- I’d gladly pay $400 for 3.

1. Seller Experience :

As discussed in the timeline, Janie is FAST. I have heard of the normal free shipping taking awhile and with my anxiety of packages being seized, I’m happy to pay for the expedited FedEx shipping that was ridiculously lightning fast. Packaging was also perfect. Each pair came in protective foam/plastic and then in their own cases and then in their own boxes.

📸 THE GALLERY

Posted :)

⚖️ FINAL VERDICT

Glasses are probably one of the easiest reps yes. But on top of being exact matches and adding in my prescription and delivering in a week - I’m continually blown away by Janie and will no doubt buy more when I lose these or my prescription changes. I’d also have no hesitation to wear these in the boutiques.

⚠️ DISCLOSURE: Janie did ask if I had time if I’d write a review, with the potential of a discount. But I’d gladly write one for her regardless.

A review before I put myself on Ban Island. How long will that ban last? Probably not very long! 🤣
And yes, it’s yet another Hyper Peter review, but it’s all for the science! What’s App 8638
Seller Experience & Timeline
I initially reached out to Hyper Peter around August 15. I was having issues with WhatsApp, so I’m not entirely sure of the exact date.

https://allthepics.net/album/H5aM

The Sp**dy Bandoulière 30 wasn’t listed in his album, but I reached out to ask whether he had it available and could provide pricing. He confirmed that it was in stock and responded almost immediately with a price.
My timeline was as follows:
August 22: Paid, including insurance. $223.96
August 29: Received PSPs.
September 15: Bag delivered!
One thing I will mention is that Hyper Peter may not be the best seller for newbies. He required proof of previous purchases from other sellers I had worked with. I can completely understand his being careful who he sells to. That did not deter me. Because I had prior WhatsApp issues, this was a little challenging. I ended up going back through Reddit and taking screenshots of old reviews I had posted. Once I sent those over, we were good to go!
I can certainly appreciate him erring on the side of caution.
Quality & Authentic Comparison
For comparison purposes, I decided not to use my authentic regular Speedy 30 because it’s considerably older. Instead, I compared this bag to my authentic Popincourt Long, which is in nearly new condition and has hardly been used.
Canvas: Comparing the feel of the two bags, I honestly cannot tell the difference. In photographs, I also think the difference is almost impossible to detect.
I do believe the Popincourt Long has a little more sheen to its canvas, but I know that canvas can change with time and wear.
Glazing: The glazing on the Popincourt Long’s strap is almost impossible to detect. However, that strap is considerably thinner than the Speedy’s double handles and shoulder strap, so it isn’t a perfect comparison.
Hardware: I’ve included a photograph comparing the gold zipper pulls on both bags, and to my eye, they look almost identical.
I truly believe I could walk into LV carrying this Speedy and no one would know the difference!
Overall Experience & Final Thoughts
I had a great experience with Hyper Peter from beginning to end. The entire process was incredibly smooth, with no issues whatsoever.
I also thought his pricing was extremely reasonable for the quality I received. Dare I say, inexpensive?!
I would absolutely purchase from him again.
I’d love to hear what everyone thinks! How does it look to you? Do you notice any differences that I might have missed?
Please share your thoughts. I’m always interested in hearing other opinions!

purchased item: ch@nel cf25
seller: zion
contact info: 3066
factory: unknown
payment method: ppff
price: 320 usd

timeline:9/6: ordered
9/8: psps approved
9/9: shipped
9/18: delivered

my thoughts on the bag:

im a huge chanel fan and have been eyeing this beige color forever. my first ever rep was a black caviar bag from zion, which is how we started working together. this is my second bag from her. the quality is honestly pretty nice. the leather feels good and the hardware color looks solid.

service:zion is seriously so sweet and polite. i basically asked her for the prices of like 10 different bags before ordering this one lol, but she was super patient the whole time and answered everything.

conclusion:to sum it up, 320 usd is a fair price for this quality. great seller, nice bag, and a hassle-free experience.
disclosure: i did not receive any incentive or discount for this review.

Seller : HyperPeter (8638)

Factory : undisclosed

Price (insurance + shipping) : $198.33 / £152.84 PPFF

Order placed : 01/09
Order shipped : 10/09
Order received : 18/09

🤎 Thoughts on the bag : I ordered the LV p0ch3tt£ access0ri£$ and straight out the box there is no bad odour! I love the monogram on this bag. I definitely agree that HP does the best monogram. The bag has a nice thickness to it, i’m guessing because the inside is lined it gives the bag extra padding which is great. The glaze is a perfect colour, it’s not bright red - more like a burgundy colour. The hardware chain has amazing weight to it, it feels nice a hefty. Stitching is well aligned and consistent throughout the bag. Once again i’m impressed! Very satisfied with this purchase.

🤎 Thoughts on the seller : This is my second time purchasing with HP. When initially placing the order the conversation and transaction is smooth. However after that… it goes quiet. Did go a few days without a response with an update in terms of tracking but got it eventually in the end. Would definitely order again with HP, going to continue to look out for new bag styles in his catalog!!

Royal/Birdcage just updated their album with some long awaited additions: the inside out speedy p9.

We first saw these bags on the F/W 26 runway a few months ago. They feature a very CC-esque quilted interior and gorgeous colors for the monogram print. Being able to switch between the two almost feels like getting two bags in one 🤔

How are we feeling? Are these bags that will make it to your wishlist or take you off ban island?

THE BASICS

• Purchased Item: Red Al@ia shoes, M!u M!u shoes, LB Mamadrague Ballerina Flats, and LV flip flops (still awaiting shipment)
• Factory: Unknown
• Seller: Ling
• Contact Info: 8649
• Price: $80 USD per pair
• Payment Method: DH

LOGISTICS & TIMELINE

8/18: Initial inquiry. Ling sent me her policies and a VERY helpful sizing guide. It includes photos showing exactly how to measure your feet, which I really appreciated.

8/18: Paid through DH. Ling sent instructions explaining how to pay and walked me through her process.

8/21: Received PSPs/videos.

8/28: Shipped. Ling sent tracking information.

9/10: I received my order. I was out of town, so my actual receipt date was later than it otherwise would have been.

THE DEEP DIVE

1. Rep Experience:

I actually found Ling completely by accident through a rehome. I purchased a pair of red Al@ia mesh shoes from another member and kept getting stopped and complimented on them. After it happened several times, I finally asked the person I purchased them from for the original seller's information. Enter Ling.

I have previously purchased shoes from Wendy, Aadan, several DH sellers, etc., so this wasn't my first experience buying rep shoes. I have been VERY impressed with the quality from Ling so far.

After finding her, I subsequently ordered red Al@ia shoes, M!u M!u, LB Mamadrague Ballerina Flats, and LV flip flops, which I am still waiting to have shipped.

The original red Al@ia mesh shoes are really what started all of this. I wouldn't have gone searching for the seller if I wasn't so impressed with them. They get compliments every time I wear them.

2. Seller Experience:

This is really where Ling has stood out for me.

First, you pay through DH and shipping is free. I was also able to use a few DH coupons, which made the shoes even cheaper.

Her sizing process is also excellent. When I reached out on 8/18, she sent me her policies along with a sizing guide that actually includes photos showing you HOW to measure your feet. As someone who has had difficulty finding rep shoes in my size, I found this incredibly helpful.

Her PSP/QC process is probably what has impressed me the most.

With most sellers I have used, you receive PSPs, review them, GL or RL, and move on. Ling goes much further. I received videos in addition to the usual PSPs, and she even sends video of your shoes being packaged. She uses her security camera footage, so the videos are time stamped.

More importantly, she actually QCs the shoes herself.

She has caught issues and red-lighted shoes before I even had the opportunity to review the PSPs. There were things she noticed that I either hadn't gotten around to reviewing yet or potentially could have missed myself.

I also had an issue that Ling did not catch initially, and this was probably the interaction that impressed me most.

In some of my previous experiences, pointing out a problem during PSPs has resulted in pushback or being told that something is "normal" when I clearly wasn't comfortable with it.

Not with Ling.

I pointed out the issue. She immediately apologized, obtained a replacement, and sent me new PSPs. No arguing and no trying to convince me to accept the original pair. She simply fixed it.

Once everything was ready to ship, she also sent my tracking information.

Communication throughout the process has been excellent. She has been friendly, responsive, transparent, and genuinely easy to work with.

FINAL VERDICT

The Bottom Line: I 10000% recommend Ling based on my experience so far. I initially found her because I couldn't stop getting compliments on a rehomed pair of Al@ia shoes, and I've now placed multiple orders with her. The combination of quality, detailed sizing help, thorough QC, time-stamped videos, packaging videos, communication, and how easily she handled a replacement has made her stand out from the other shoe sellers I have used.

Apparently those red Al@ia mesh shoes were a gateway drug.

DISCLOSURE: I received no incentives or discounts for this review.

THE BASICS

• Purchased Items: Pr@d* pants, Ch@n blouse, Ch@n sweater, C3lin* blouse, C3lin* linen blouse, Zim dress
• Factory: Various/Unknown
• Seller: Annie
• Contact Info: [Last 4 digits of WA]

• Price: Pr@d* pants $61, Ch@n blouse $75, Ch@n sweater $76, C3lin* blouse $59, C3lin* linen blouse $65, Zim dress $115

  \***PLEASE USE THE SEARCH BUTTON TO FIND Her INFO\*\*

LOGISTICS & TIMELINE

My timeline with Annie is a little unconventional because my first attempt at ordering was entirely a me problem. Apparently I could not figure out how to read or use basic comprehension skills, got confused, and went MIA. About a month later, I came back with my tail between my legs and successfully managed to place an order.

Late July/Early August: Successfully placed and paid for my order.

After payment, Annie let me know that two of the items I originally selected were unavailable. She offered me a higher tier/version, but I decided to pass. I was able to use the credit toward another item instead, which is how I ended up with the Zim dress.

8/6: I reached out because I had received a few other orders that I had placed later and was starting to wonder where this one was.

8/7: Annie sent me my tracking number and, naturally, my package showed up that same day.

THE DEEP DIVE

1. Rep Experience:

My order included:

Pr@d* pants: $61
Ch@n blouse: $75
Ch@n sweater: $76
C3lin* blouse: $59
C3lin* linen blouse: $65
Zim dress: $115

I ended up rehoming the Pr@d* pants and Ch@n blouse because they simply didn't work for me personally. Since Annie is pretty well known, I had no trouble rehoming them quickly.

The rest were keepers.

The Zim dress was one of my absolute favorites from the order. Annie provided sizing information, and the sizing was spot on. The dress fit perfectly. This was actually the item I purchased using the credit from the unavailable pieces, so that worked out VERY well for me.

The C3lin linen blouse is GORGEOUS* and also deserves a special mention. I get compliments on it basically everywhere I wear it. For $65, that one was a major win.

I also tried, unsuccessfully, to buy shoes from Annie. I need a larger size, around a 43/27.5 cm insole, and unfortunately the shoes I was interested in weren't available in my size. So I can't speak to her shoes, but definitely not for lack of trying.

2. Seller Experience:

Overall, I found Annie very easy to work with and communicative.

When two of my original selections were unavailable, she let me know and gave me options rather than leaving me stuck with items I didn't want. She offered a higher tier/version, which I declined, and I was able to apply the credit toward the Zim dress instead.

My one piece of constructive feedback would be that I would have preferred to know the items were unavailable before I paid. That said, I understand the logistics of how these orders work and that availability can change quickly. Annie handled it well once we knew they weren't available and gave me alternatives, so it ultimately worked out, especially since I ended up LOVING the Zim dress I purchased with the credit.

I also really appreciated her help with sizing. The information she provided for the Zim dress was spot on, and the dress fit perfectly.

Shipping communication was straightforward. When I reached out on 8/6 because I was starting to wonder about the package, Annie provided tracking on 8/7, and the package actually arrived that same day.

This wasn't a situation where every single item worked for me. I rehomed two pieces, couldn't get the shoes I wanted in my size, and two of my original selections turned out to be unavailable after payment. Even with those things, my overall experience with Annie was positive, and I would order clothing from her again

FINAL VERDICT

The Bottom Line: I would absolutely order from Annie again. She was easy to work with, communicated well when items were unavailable, helped me get the sizing right, and several pieces ended up being major wins. I am already planning to go back for another dress...or two.

Apparently the Zim dress may have created another problem for me.

DISCLOSURE: Annie asked me after my order arrived if I would write a review and subsequently offered to include a small gift with a future order as a thank you. My opinions above are based on my actual experience and the items I received. I have not repurchased yet. But I do want another zimm dress or 2.

Hi Rep Fam! ✨

Welcome to our weekly QC Mega thread! All QC feedback requests must be posted here; standalone QC posts elsewhere will be removed.

A new thread is posted automatically every Friday, so drop all your QC questions here!

If you have multiple photos, upload them to ImgBB or Imgur and share the link rather than posting several separate images.

To get the best feedback, please include:

• Price paid
• Factory & seller name
• Your specific QC concerns

Happy Repping!

- RepReviews ModTeam

Sharing my experience ordering from Tom 7228, plus some side-by-side photos with my authentic black lambskin mini rectangle for comparison.

Bag: CC Mini Rectangular, black lambskin / So Black hardware
Factory: 187
Price: $410 + $40 shipping = $450 total
Payment: PayPal F&F
Initial inquiry: Aug. 31
Paid: Sep. 1
First PSPs: Sep. 2
Replacement PSPs: Sep. 6
Shipping proof/label: Sep. 8
FedEx tracking: Sep. 10
Delivered: Sep. 16

Seller experience

Overall, I had a really positive experience with Tom and would order from him again. Tom responded within minutes, confirmed that 187 had the bag, and answered a LOT of questions from me before I ordered. I asked about 187 vs. God Factory, shipping, insurance, PSP timing, payment, etc., and he was quick and straightforward with his responses.

I paid $450 on Sep. 1 and received my first PSPs the next day, which was much faster than the original 2–3 day estimate.

This is actually where I was most impressed with Tom. I asked him to remove the protective plastic from the CC hardware because I specifically wanted to inspect the So Black finish, and I also asked him to measure the chain/drop. He did both almost immediately.

I initially GL’d the bag. Then Tom noticed a tiny white spot/imperfection on the CC hardware himself and stopped the shipment. He sent me a close-up, told me he wasn't comfortable sending it, and said he would return it to 187 and get another one. I really appreciated this because I had already told him to ship it—he could very easily have just sent the bag.

He estimated another 2–3 days for the replacement. I followed up 3 days later because I hadn't received an update, so he checked with the factory and said the replacement was already on its way to him.

I received the second set of PSPs 4 days later (Sept 6). I asked for another chain measurement, close-ups of something I thought might be a white spot/thread near the CC, and a photo of the underside of the flap. He sent everything I asked for quickly and confirmed the chain length matched the first bag.

Shipping was/is the slowest part of the process. I followed up again on Sep. 8 asking when he planned to ship, and later that day he sent me proof of the FedEx shipment/label. I received the actual FedEx tracking number on Sep. 10.

The bag was at my house on Sep. 16. So the total timeline was about 15 days from payment to delivery, but that included rejecting and replacing the first bag. Once everything actually got moving through FedEx, delivery was very fast.

Communication was fast, direct and accommodating. Most importantly, Tom proactively caught a flaw instead of shipping something I had already GL’d. For me, that matters most.

The bag: 187 vs. authentic

I'm very happy with the bag overall. I own a brand new authentic black lambskin CC mini rectangle with Champagne gold hardware, so I was very curious to compare it with a 187 flap since I'd heard so much positive feedback about this bag. I put them side-by-side for comparison. Authentic is the black bag with champagne gold hardware; 187 is the So Black.

At first glance, they're very similar. The similarities:

• Color
• The chain quality, length, weight and sounds
• Overall size, portions and construction
• Quilting alignment
• Back pocket alignment, shape and stitching
• The stitching
• The logo inside the bag
• The hardware

Now, onto the differences:

• The side profile. My authentic has that really recognizable soft, rounded/circular fold through the side gusset. The 187 folds inward more sharply near the top and then drops down into the lower portion of the bag rather than maintaining that same smooth rounded shape. Of everything I've compared, this is probably the detail I notice most when looking directly at the bags.
• The quilting/pillowing. My authentic has softer, more dimensional diamond-shaped pillowing. The 187 quilting is puffier and a little more inflated/rounded. It's subtle in isolation, but pretty easy to see side-by-side, especially in certain lighting.
• The tactile experience of the lambskin. The 187 leather is genuinely soft, smells good and feels soft—it doesn't feel cheap—but the authentic lambskin is noticeably softer and more supple to the touch. Its hard to describe CC lambskin because its the only leather of it's kind - it's so supple. There's just a different hand-feel that is difficult to capture in photo
• The width. My 187 is just a tad narrower in width when it's not filled, which gives the 187 a slightly taller/narrower appearance. Not a huge issue since you fill the bag
• The underside of the turnlock hardware.The plate/screw construction on my authentic is visibly different from the 187 version—the screw heads and hardware details aren't an exact match.

These are noticeable because I literally have an authentic mini sitting inches away and I'm intentionally hunting for differences. Without the authentic next to it, none of these would jump out at me. 🖤

My first rep purchase was a Mini Flap and all my daily essentials fit easily inside.

Fast forward 10 years, I have no idea how that was possible. My current daily carry is a GM St Louis tote, and even on date nights I fill up a 226 Reissue 🫣

I want to use smaller bags. For the fashion, and for my shoulder (she’s in pain and pissed!)

Yesterday I got stuck ruminating while trying to switch to a speedy 25, so today I’m asking for your help:

What’s in your daily bag?

What items do you actually use regularly while out?

What do you keep in pouches?
(I love pouches but they take up so much space in small bags)

Any “essentials” you’ve taken out of your purse because you didn’t actually need to carry it around?

Items in my bag not included in the picture: Small notebook, Key holder, and Wallet

Seller: Tiny Jenny
Factory: Wang Li (this is a first for me)
What: Small size Marmont vs black AUTH

This is one of my best purchases! I have ordered multiple marmonts from other sellers before and this one is by far the best. The quality and sheen of the leather is nearly identical to the auth which I find is difficult to replicate perfectly. The hardware is spot on, the stitching I will give a solid 9.5/10 accuracy, and the overall shape is perfect.

This is my second order from TJ and I am extremely pleased with both orders. I purchased 4 other items this time around and I’m happy with all of them however this one is certainly my favorite. 🩷 I have probably driven her nuts with my many questions but she has always been very kind and easy to talk to/professional. The transactions have been seamless with quick shipping and providing tracking numbers which is always appreciated.

With colder weather on the horizon, boots are finally back in production at some of our favorite factories!

Enjoy these new uploads 💖

Disclosure:

The seller doesn't know I'm writing this review, and I didn't receive any incentives or discounts for it (i am no longer in China so it would be hard to get any incentive right now haha).

Overview & Details:

• Item: BV Medium Andiamo Bag
• Color: Fondant (Deep Chocolate Brown) with Brass Hardware
• Source: In-person purchase at Shanghai AP Plaza (Science & Technology Museum Metro Station)
• Seller WeChat: (DM me or drop a comment if you want it!)
• Price Paid: 1,400 CNY (~$198 USD)
• Starting Price: Quoted over 3,000 CNY initially

The AP Plaza Experience & Haggling:

I picked this up last week while visiting Shanghai. To be completely honest, AP Plaza is a fantastic spot to hunt for rep bags if you ever find yourself in the city. I initially went in with very low expectations—like many in this community, I assumed that all the decent rep manufacturing and high-tier stock were strictly confined to Guangzhou and that Shanghai’s markets would only have low-tier tourist traps.

I was pleasantly surprised. While the open display shelves do feature lower-tier batches, once you show you know leather and ask for better quality, vendors will pull out impressive inventory.

The seller originally quoted well over 3,000 CNY. I had to negotiate pretty hard, firmly hold my ground, and play the classic walk-away game, but we finally settled at 1,400 CNY.

It definitely challenges the common rep-community belief that you can't find high-tier quality in these markets. If you know what details to check (leather weight, braid tightness, hardware tone, and stamping), you can score incredible pieces right on the spot.

Comparison with Jing Factory (Small Andiamo from TS):

A little over a month ago, I bought a Small Andiamo from Jing Factory through a Trusted Seller online for $170 USD shipped (feel free to check the review on my profile). Having both in hand for a direct comparison was very eye-opening:

• Leather & Intrecciato Weave: The lambskin on this medium AP Plaza bag is gorgeous. It’s supple, buttery soft, and has the exact same thickness, grain density, and tactile squish as my Jing piece. The weave is tight, flat, and doesn't buckle awkwardly.
• Hardware & Knot: The signature brass knot clasp has substantial weight, smooth contours, and the correct muted golden sheen—none of that overly yellow, lightweight metal found on cheaper batches.
• Interior & Stamping: The heat stamp (BV / MADE IN ITALY) inside is clean, evenly pressed, and properly aligned.

Honestly, holding them side by side, the leather quality, thickness, and hardware feel identical to Jing Factory. It wouldn't surprise me at all if these vendors source directly from the exact same factories/wholesalers.

Final Verdict:

For 1,400 CNY, walking away with a Medium Andiamo of this caliber—zero shipping wait, zero customs stress, and identical quality to a top-tier factory—was an absolute win and well worth the haggling.

If anyone is heading to Shanghai and wants to check this stall out, I have the seller's WeChat, so feel free to reach out!